Win Shares Per Plate Appearance
by Cyril Morong
The back of the Win Shares book by Bill James proclaims “Win Shares, a revolutionary system that allows for player evaluation across positions, teams and eras, measures the total sum of player contributions in one groundbreaking number. James’ latest advancement in the world of statistical analysis is the next big stepping stone in the “greatest players of all time” debate.
This website shows how the greatest players rank in Win Shares (WS) per plate appearance (PA). I did this because WS can never be negative, so the longer a player plays, the more WS he gets. So I wanted to see how good each player was per plate appearance, sort of by quality instead of quantity. Actually, instead of just dividing WS by PA, I multiplied it by 648, to get an idea of how many WS they would have for a full season. I used the Lee Sinins Sabermetric Encyclopedia to get PA for each player.
Players included in the study had either at least 5000 (PAs) or at least 141 WS or both through the 2001 season. A few players like Kid Gleason and Cy Seymour, who got alot WS from pitching are not included because I could not easily determine how many of their WS came from pitching. This information, however, was clearly stated in the book for Babe Ruth. So his WS per PA has his pitching WS subtracted. There is also a ranking with only players who had 7500 PA. This is at the end.
I first look at what the breakdown is by position for both the top 100 players and the bottom 100 players. Then I present the ranking of the 861 players in the study. Then players are ranked by position.
Below are how many players from each position were in the top 100 in WS/648PA:
Position |
Count |
% of Total |
Expected % |
1B |
18 |
18.00% |
12.50% |
2B |
8 |
8.00% |
12.50% |
3B |
6 |
6.00% |
12.50% |
C |
12 |
12.00% |
12.50% |
OF |
50 |
50.00% |
37.50% |
SS |
6 |
6.00% |
12.50% |
Some observations:
1. Players were listed at a position if they played more games there than any other position. Outfield was counted as one position.
2. Outfielders are very over represented among the top 100 players.
3. Infielders, especially shortstops and third basemen are very under represented among the top 100 players.
If WS is supposed to allow for comparisons across positions, this is a surprising result. Why would so few infielders be in the top 100? Are outfielders really better than infielders? Consider the two following teams of eight players. The players on the left are the top 8 in WS/648PA. The players on the right are the best of the remaining players at their position. Which team would you expect to win more games if they each had average pitching staffs?
Babe Ruth |
|
Joe Jackson |
Mickey Mantle |
|
Willie Mays |
Ted Williams |
|
Lou Gehrig |
Honus Wagner |
|
Joe DiMaggio |
Ty Cobb |
|
Mike Piazza |
Barry Bonds |
|
Eddie Collins |
|
|
Mike Schmidt |
Tris Speaker |
|
Arky |
The team on the left lacks a first baseman, third baseman and catcher. The team on the right has one player for each position. Win Shares says that the team on the left must be better since all eight of those players ranks higher than all eight of the players on the right. Yet the team on the left might not field some positions very well and therefore may not be as good as the team on the right.
What does the bottom 100-player profile look like?
Position |
Count |
% of Total |
Expected % |
1B |
11 |
11.00% |
12.50% |
2B |
30 |
30.00% |
12.50% |
3B |
8 |
8.00% |
12.50% |
C |
4 |
4.00% |
12.50% |
OF |
21 |
21.00% |
37.50% |
SS |
26 |
26.00% |
12.50% |
The reverse of the top 100 is true. Many fewer outfielders than expected. But many more second basemen and shortstops than expected.
What about the profile of all the players? There are 861 players in the ranking. Seven were DHs, so the percentages below in the third column are based on a total 854. The average refers to average WS/648PA.
Position |
Count |
% of Total |
Expected % |
Average |
1B |
122 |
14.29% |
12.50% |
20.51 |
2B |
107 |
12.53% |
12.50% |
18.83 |
3B |
96 |
11.24% |
12.50% |
19.92 |
C |
68 |
7.96% |
12.50% |
20.98 |
OF |
354 |
41.45% |
37.50% |
21.13 |
SS |
107 |
12.53% |
12.50% |
18.44 |
Notice that catchers and outfielders have a much higher average than shortstops. Have catchers and outfielders really been better players than shortstops in baseball history? The low number of catchers might be explained by the wear and tear of the position, making hard to get to 5000 PA.
Rank |
Player |
WS per 648 PA |
POS |
1 |
Babe Ruth |
39.92 |
OF |
2 |
Mickey
Mantle |
36.95 |
OF |
3 |
Ted
Williams |
36.74 |
OF |
4 |
Honus
Wagner |
36.16 |
SS |
5 |
Ty Cobb |
35.79 |
OF |
6 |
Barry
Bonds |
34.56 |
OF |
7 |
|
34.33 |
2B |
8 |
Tris
Speaker |
34.05 |
OF |
9 |
Joe
Jackson |
33.48 |
OF |
10 |
Willie
Mays |
33.30 |
OF |
11 |
Lou
Gehrig |
32.80 |
1B |
12 |
Joe
DiMaggio |
32.69 |
OF |
13 |
Mike
Piazza |
31.82 |
C |
14 |
Benny
Kauff |
31.82 |
OF |
15 |
Eddie
Collins |
30.90 |
2B |
16 |
Stan
Musial |
30.79 |
OF |
17 |
Nap
Lajoie |
30.73 |
2B |
18 |
Charlie
Keller |
30.68 |
OF |
19 |
Dick
Allen |
30.30 |
1B |
20 |
Mel Ott |
30.18 |
OF |
21 |
Frank
Chance |
30.12 |
1B |
22 |
Mike
Schmidt |
30.08 |
3B |
23 |
Dan
Brouthers |
29.97 |
1B |
24 |
Hank
Aaron |
29.89 |
OF |
25 |
Arky |
29.88 |
SS |
26 |
Johnny
Mize |
29.71 |
1B |
27 |
Elmer
Flick |
29.42 |
OF |
28 |
Home Run
Baker |
29.29 |
3B |
29 |
Joe
Morgan |
29.29 |
2B |
30 |
Jimmie
Foxx |
29.15 |
1B |
31 |
Yogi
Berra |
29.06 |
C |
32 |
Frank
Thomas-cws |
29.02 |
1B |
33 |
Mark
McGwire |
28.93 |
1B |
34 |
Eddie
Mathews |
28.87 |
3B |
35 |
Gabby
Hartnett |
28.86 |
C |
36 |
Bill
Dickey |
28.82 |
C |
37 |
Billy
Hamilton |
28.77 |
OF |
38 |
Mickey
Cochrane |
28.71 |
C |
39 |
Jackie
Robinson |
28.70 |
2B |
40 |
Frank
Robinson |
28.64 |
OF |
41 |
Jeff
Bagwell |
28.48 |
1B |
42 |
Hank
Greenberg |
28.38 |
1B |
43 |
Alex
Rodriguez |
28.23 |
SS |
44 |
King
Kelly |
27.91 |
OF |
45 |
Roger
Bresnahan |
27.86 |
C |
46 |
Roy
Campanella |
27.85 |
C |
47 |
Duke
Snider |
27.69 |
OF |
48 |
Wally
Berger |
27.58 |
OF |
49 |
Larry
Doby |
27.56 |
OF |
50 |
Dave Orr |
27.55 |
1B |
51 |
Pete
Browning |
27.43 |
OF |
52 |
Ed
Delahanty |
27.41 |
OF |
53 |
Al Rosen |
27.41 |
3B |
54 |
Willie
McCovey |
27.30 |
1B |
55 |
Sam
Crawford |
27.28 |
OF |
56 |
John
McGraw |
27.16 |
3B |
57 |
Gene
Tenace |
27.09 |
C |
58 |
Buck
Ewing |
27.06 |
C |
59 |
Sherry
Magee |
26.84 |
OF |
60 |
Johnny
Bench |
26.61 |
C |
61 |
Roger
Connor |
26.60 |
1B |
62 |
Willie
Stargell |
26.56 |
OF |
63 |
George
Gore |
26.54 |
OF |
64 |
Jason
Giambi |
26.50 |
1B |
65 |
Barry
Larkin |
26.45 |
SS |
66 |
Fred
Clarke |
26.40 |
OF |
67 |
Gary
Sheffield |
26.39 |
OF |
68 |
Manny
Ramirez |
26.39 |
OF |
69 |
Charley
Jones |
26.36 |
OF |
70 |
Rickey |
26.34 |
OF |
71 |
Mike
Donlin |
26.33 |
OF |
72 |
Jesse
Burkett |
26.22 |
OF |
73 |
Ken
Griffey Jr. |
26.22 |
OF |
74 |
Frank
Howard |
26.17 |
OF |
75 |
Reggie
Smith |
26.16 |
OF |
76 |
Hack |
26.13 |
OF |
77 |
Pedro
Guerrero |
26.07 |
1B |
78 |
Bobby
Grich |
25.94 |
2B |
79 |
Will |
25.89 |
1B |
80 |
George
Stone |
25.81 |
OF |
81 |
Darryl
Strawberry |
25.81 |
OF |
82 |
Norm Cash |
25.81 |
1B |
83 |
Harry
Heilmann |
25.75 |
OF |
84 |
Craig
Biggio |
25.72 |
2B |
85 |
Tom
Haller |
25.67 |
C |
86 |
Roy
Thomas |
25.62 |
OF |
87 |
Lou
Boudreau |
25.56 |
SS |
88 |
Al
Simmons |
25.53 |
OF |
89 |
Lefty
O'Doul |
25.50 |
OF |
90 |
Paul
Waner |
25.47 |
OF |
91 |
George
Davis |
25.39 |
SS |
92 |
Chipper
Jones |
25.38 |
3B |
93 |
Larry
Doyle |
25.37 |
2B |
94 |
Bill
Terry |
25.33 |
1B |
95 |
Jeff
Heath |
25.29 |
OF |
96 |
Tony
Gwynn |
25.21 |
OF |
97 |
Reggie
Jackson |
25.20 |
OF |
98 |
Harry
Stovey |
25.14 |
OF |
99 |
Earl
Averill |
25.12 |
OF |
100 |
Bill
Freehan |
25.08 |
C |
101 |
Fred
Dunlap |
25.08 |
2B |
102 |
Ralph
Kiner |
25.07 |
OF |
103 |
Heine
Groh |
25.05 |
3B |
104 |
Ross
Youngs |
25.03 |
OF |
105 |
Topsy
Hartsel |
24.97 |
OF |
106 |
Larry
Walker |
24.96 |
OF |
107 |
Roberto
Alomar |
24.96 |
2B |
108 |
Edd Roush |
24.95 |
OF |
109 |
Tommy
Henrich |
24.92 |
OF |
110 |
Jack
Clark |
24.90 |
OF |
111 |
Jim
O'Rourke |
24.85 |
OF |
112 |
Joe
Medwick |
24.83 |
OF |
113 |
Jack
Fournier |
24.81 |
1B |
114 |
George
Van Haltren |
24.79 |
OF |
115 |
Al Kaline |
24.75 |
OF |
116 |
Hardy |
24.72 |
2B |
117 |
Roger
Maris |
24.72 |
OF |
118 |
Wally
Schang |
24.72 |
C |
119 |
Jimmy
Wynn |
24.67 |
OF |
120 |
Tim
Raines |
24.67 |
OF |
121 |
Lenny
Dykstra |
24.66 |
OF |
122 |
Oyster
Burns |
24.65 |
OF |
123 |
Zack
Wheat |
24.65 |
OF |
124 |
Roy
Cullenbine |
24.64 |
OF |
125 |
Stan
Spence |
24.63 |
OF |
126 |
Kevin
Mitchell |
24.56 |
OF |
127 |
Bill
Dahlen |
24.55 |
SS |
128 |
Denny |
24.52 |
3B |
129 |
Hughie
Jennings |
24.52 |
SS |
130 |
Bill
Joyce |
24.49 |
3B |
131 |
Art
Devlin |
24.48 |
3B |
132 |
Bernie
Williams |
24.45 |
OF |
133 |
Harmon
Killebrew |
24.45 |
1B |
134 |
Joe
Cronin |
24.42 |
SS |
135 |
Cap Anson |
24.40 |
1B |
136 |
Hugh
Duffy |
24.39 |
OF |
137 |
Jim Thome |
24.35 |
1B |
138 |
Augie
Galan |
24.34 |
OF |
139 |
Joe
Kelley |
24.28 |
OF |
140 |
Paul
Hines |
24.25 |
OF |
141 |
Moises
Alou |
24.25 |
OF |
142 |
Charlie
Gehringer |
24.24 |
2B |
143 |
Gary
Carter |
24.21 |
C |
144 |
|
24.20 |
C |
145 |
Mike
Tiernan |
24.20 |
OF |
146 |
Bobby
Bonds |
24.19 |
OF |
147 |
Heinie
Zimmerman |
24.16 |
3B |
148 |
Ryne
Sandberg |
24.16 |
2B |
149 |
Babe
Herman |
24.15 |
1B |
150 |
Jimmy
Sheckard |
24.09 |
OF |
151 |
Johnny
Evers |
24.09 |
2B |
152 |
George
Brett |
24.08 |
3B |
153 |
Stan Hack |
24.07 |
3B |
154 |
Edgar
Martinez |
24.05 |
DH |
155 |
Edgardo
Alfonzo |
24.01 |
2B |
156 |
Joe
Gordon |
23.99 |
2B |
157 |
Riggs
Stephenson |
23.98 |
OF |
158 |
Chick
Stahl |
23.95 |
OF |
159 |
Roberto
Clemente |
23.92 |
OF |
160 |
Luke
Appling |
23.91 |
SS |
161 |
Fielder
Jones |
23.81 |
OF |
162 |
Jimmy
Collins |
23.80 |
3B |
163 |
Minnie
Minoso |
23.79 |
OF |
164 |
Wade
Boggs |
23.77 |
3B |
165 |
Darren
Daulton |
23.76 |
C |
166 |
Jim
Edmonds |
23.75 |
OF |
167 |
Ivan
Rodriguez |
23.74 |
C |
168 |
Vern
Stephens |
23.72 |
SS |
169 |
Danny
Green |
23.70 |
OF |
170 |
Patsy
Dougherty |
23.69 |
OF |
171 |
Ryan
Klesko |
23.65 |
OF |
172 |
Ginger
Beaumont |
23.63 |
OF |
173 |
Eric
Davis |
23.61 |
OF |
174 |
Charlie
Bennett |
23.60 |
C |
175 |
Albert
Belle |
23.60 |
OF |
176 |
Rod Carew |
23.59 |
1B |
177 |
Cesar
Cedeno |
23.58 |
OF |
178 |
Chick
Hafey |
23.57 |
OF |
179 |
Keith
Hernandez |
23.56 |
1B |
180 |
Don
Buford |
23.51 |
OF |
181 |
Socks
Seybold |
23.50 |
OF |
182 |
Dixie |
23.50 |
OF |
183 |
Sam
Thompson |
23.49 |
OF |
184 |
Frankie
Frisch |
23.48 |
2B |
185 |
Tommy
Leach |
23.48 |
OF |
186 |
David
Justice |
23.47 |
OF |
187 |
Goose
Goslin |
23.42 |
OF |
188 |
Boog
Powell |
23.40 |
1B |
189 |
Rocky
Colavito |
23.40 |
OF |
190 |
Art
Fletcher |
23.39 |
SS |
191 |
Joe
Tinker |
23.37 |
SS |
192 |
Kiki
Cuyler |
23.37 |
OF |
193 |
Rick
Monday |
23.34 |
OF |
194 |
Sam
Mertes |
23.33 |
OF |
195 |
Danny
Murphy |
23.33 |
2B |
196 |
Ken
Williams |
23.32 |
OF |
197 |
Gil
McDougald |
23.30 |
2B |
198 |
Bobby
Murcer |
23.26 |
OF |
199 |
Bobby
Wallace |
23.26 |
SS |
200 |
Kirby
Puckett |
23.25 |
OF |
201 |
Mike
Griffin |
23.22 |
OF |
202 |
Joe Torre |
23.19 |
C |
203 |
Andy Van
Slyke |
23.11 |
OF |
204 |
Bob
Johnson |
23.11 |
OF |
205 |
|
23.10 |
1B |
206 |
Red Smith |
23.10 |
3B |
207 |
Tony
Oliva |
23.08 |
OF |
208 |
Billy
Williams |
23.04 |
OF |
209 |
Enos
Slaughter |
23.04 |
OF |
210 |
Derek
Jeter |
23.02 |
SS |
211 |
Jeff Kent |
23.00 |
2B |
212 |
Ezra
Sutton |
22.99 |
3B |
213 |
Fred Lynn |
22.90 |
OF |
214 |
Ken
Singleton |
22.87 |
OF |
215 |
Dolph
Camilli |
22.85 |
1B |
216 |
Jim
Fregosi |
22.85 |
SS |
217 |
Lou
Whitaker |
22.82 |
2B |
218 |
Cupid
Childs |
22.81 |
2B |
219 |
Ray
Lankford |
22.79 |
OF |
220 |
George
Burns |
22.78 |
OF |
221 |
Eddie
Stanky |
22.77 |
2B |
222 |
Bob
Elliott |
22.71 |
3B |
223 |
Bobby
Veach |
22.71 |
OF |
224 |
Jose Cruz |
22.71 |
OF |
225 |
Bobby
Doerr |
22.68 |
2B |
226 |
Ripper
Collins |
22.65 |
1B |
227 |
Jim Ray
Hart |
22.64 |
3B |
228 |
Kid
Elberfeld |
22.62 |
SS |
229 |
Thurman
Munson |
22.61 |
C |
230 |
Carl
Yastrzemski |
22.60 |
OF |
231 |
Earle
Combs |
22.60 |
OF |
232 |
Bill
Nicholson |
22.52 |
OF |
233 |
Elston
Howard |
22.51 |
C |
234 |
Amos Otis |
22.47 |
OF |
235 |
Jimmy
Ryan |
22.47 |
OF |
236 |
Willie
Keeler |
22.45 |
OF |
237 |
Buck
Freeman |
22.45 |
OF |
238 |
Tim
Salmon |
22.44 |
OF |
239 |
Earl
Battey |
22.42 |
C |
240 |
Jack
Glasscock |
22.41 |
SS |
241 |
Rafael
Palmeiro |
22.41 |
1B |
242 |
John
Titus |
22.39 |
OF |
243 |
Robin
Yount |
22.38 |
SS |
244 |
Tony
Lazzeri |
22.36 |
2B |
245 |
Billy
Herman |
22.35 |
2B |
246 |
Pete Rose |
22.35 |
OF |
247 |
Gene
Woodling |
22.34 |
OF |
248 |
Ron Santo |
22.34 |
3B |
249 |
Fred
McGriff |
22.33 |
1B |
250 |
Ed Bailey |
22.33 |
C |
251 |
George
Foster |
22.31 |
OF |
252 |
Phil
Rizzuto |
22.31 |
SS |
253 |
Smoky
Burgess |
22.23 |
C |
254 |
Don
Mincher |
22.22 |
1B |
255 |
Bob
Allison |
22.22 |
OF |
256 |
Sid
Gordon |
22.19 |
OF |
257 |
John
Olerud |
22.19 |
1B |
258 |
Abner
Dalrymple |
22.17 |
OF |
259 |
Ernie
Lombardi |
22.15 |
C |
260 |
Sal Bando |
22.13 |
3B |
261 |
Eddie
Murray |
22.09 |
1B |
262 |
Walker
Cooper |
22.08 |
C |
263 |
Don
Mattingly |
22.07 |
1B |
264 |
Sammy
Sosa |
22.07 |
OF |
265 |
Oscar
Gamble |
22.07 |
OF |
266 |
Paul
Molitor |
22.06 |
DH |
267 |
Ned
Williamson |
22.06 |
3B |
268 |
Roy White |
22.03 |
OF |
269 |
Dom
DiMaggio |
22.01 |
OF |
270 |
Ken
Caminiti |
22.01 |
3B |
271 |
Bob
O'Farrell |
22.00 |
C |
272 |
Howard
Johnson |
22.00 |
3B |
273 |
Hal
Trosky |
21.99 |
1B |
274 |
Alan
Trammell |
21.98 |
SS |
275 |
Bob
Watson |
21.97 |
1B |
276 |
Johnny
Pesky |
21.97 |
SS |
277 |
John Kruk |
21.96 |
1B |
278 |
Heinie
Manush |
21.95 |
OF |
279 |
Jimmy
Williams |
21.95 |
2B |
280 |
Darrell
Evans |
21.91 |
3B |
281 |
Darrell
Porter |
21.90 |
C |
282 |
Richie
Ashburn |
21.90 |
OF |
283 |
Tommy
Holmes |
21.89 |
OF |
284 |
Ken Boyer |
21.87 |
3B |
285 |
Juan
Gonzalez |
21.86 |
OF |
286 |
Solly
Hofman |
21.82 |
OF |
287 |
Chet
Lemon |
21.81 |
OF |
288 |
Dick
McAuliffe |
21.81 |
2B |
289 |
Larry
Gardner |
21.77 |
3B |
290 |
Dave
Winfield |
21.76 |
OF |
291 |
Ron Cey |
21.74 |
3B |
292 |
Deacon
White |
21.72 |
3B |
293 |
Jose
Canseco |
21.68 |
OF |
294 |
Kevin
McReynolds |
21.68 |
OF |
295 |
Johnny
Kling |
21.66 |
C |
296 |
Curt
Welch |
21.65 |
OF |
297 |
Pepper
Martin |
21.64 |
OF |
298 |
Henry
Larkin |
21.63 |
1B |
299 |
Robin
Ventura |
21.60 |
3B |
300 |
Larry
Parrish |
21.57 |
3B |
301 |
Joe
Sewell |
21.55 |
SS |
302 |
Mike
Scioscia |
21.53 |
C |
303 |
Rico
Petrocelli |
21.53 |
SS |
304 |
Chuck
Klein |
21.52 |
OF |
305 |
Pee Wee
Reese |
21.49 |
SS |
306 |
Cal
Ripken |
21.48 |
SS |
307 |
Tom Daly |
21.48 |
2B |
308 |
Ed
Konetchy |
21.47 |
1B |
309 |
Rico
Carty |
21.44 |
OF |
310 |
Pie
Traynor |
21.41 |
3B |
311 |
Sixto
Lezcano |
21.40 |
OF |
312 |
Billy
Nash |
21.40 |
3B |
313 |
Dwayne
Murphy |
21.39 |
OF |
314 |
Willie
Randolph |
21.37 |
2B |
315 |
Woodie
Held |
21.34 |
SS |
316 |
John
Briggs |
21.30 |
OF |
317 |
Greg
Luzinski |
21.30 |
OF |
318 |
Tim
McCarver |
21.30 |
C |
319 |
Dwight
Evans |
21.28 |
OF |
320 |
Matty
McIntyre |
21.28 |
OF |
321 |
Ferris
Fain |
21.27 |
1B |
322 |
Bill
Madlock |
21.27 |
3B |
323 |
Willie
Davis |
21.24 |
OF |
324 |
Bobby
Avila |
21.22 |
2B |
325 |
John
Roseboro |
21.22 |
C |
326 |
Kirk
Gibson |
21.22 |
OF |
327 |
Toby
Harrah |
21.22 |
3B |
328 |
George
Grantham |
21.21 |
2B |
329 |
Davey
Lopes |
21.19 |
2B |
330 |
Tom Tresh |
21.18 |
OF |
331 |
Casey
Stengel |
21.16 |
OF |
332 |
Miller
Huggins |
21.16 |
2B |
333 |
Dave
Bancroft |
21.14 |
SS |
334 |
Max Carey |
21.12 |
OF |
335 |
Bill
Doran |
21.12 |
2B |
336 |
Johnny
Grubb |
21.09 |
OF |
337 |
Frank
McCormick |
21.09 |
1B |
338 |
Ted
Simmons |
21.08 |
C |
339 |
Dale
Murphy |
21.07 |
OF |
340 |
Kenny
Lofton |
21.07 |
OF |
341 |
Lonny
Frey |
21.05 |
2B |
342 |
Norm
Siebern |
21.04 |
1B |
343 |
Chuck
Knoblauch |
21.03 |
2B |
344 |
Gil
Hodges |
21.03 |
1B |
345 |
Dode
Paskert |
21.02 |
OF |
346 |
Mark
Grace |
21.02 |
1B |
347 |
Ival
Goodman |
21.02 |
OF |
348 |
Raul
Mondesi |
21.00 |
OF |
349 |
Johnny
Callison |
21.00 |
OF |
350 |
Bid
McPhee |
20.99 |
2B |
351 |
George
Sisler |
20.99 |
1B |
352 |
Bobby
Bonilla |
20.96 |
3B |
353 |
Joe
Adcock |
20.94 |
1B |
354 |
Johnny
Hopp |
20.90 |
OF |
355 |
Harry
Davis |
20.90 |
1B |
356 |
Wildfire
Schulte |
20.89 |
OF |
357 |
Kent
Hrbek |
20.88 |
1B |
358 |
Matt
Williams |
20.88 |
3B |
359 |
Ray
Chapman |
20.87 |
SS |
360 |
Danny
Tartabull |
20.85 |
OF |
361 |
Ken
Griffey Sr. |
20.85 |
OF |
362 |
Mo Vaughn |
20.83 |
1B |
363 |
Hank
Sauer |
20.83 |
OF |
364 |
Tony
Perez |
20.82 |
1B |
365 |
Terry
Puhl |
20.82 |
OF |
366 |
Dave
Parker |
20.81 |
OF |
367 |
Del
Crandall |
20.78 |
C |
368 |
Mickey
Tettleton |
20.75 |
C |
369 |
Brian
Downing |
20.74 |
DH |
370 |
Clyde |
20.74 |
OF |
371 |
Ernie
Banks |
20.70 |
1B |
372 |
Lonnie
Smith |
20.69 |
OF |
373 |
Sam Rice |
20.68 |
OF |
374 |
Ellis
Burks |
20.66 |
OF |
375 |
Ron
Fairly |
20.66 |
1B |
376 |
Rusty
Staub |
20.66 |
OF |
377 |
Max
Bishop |
20.64 |
2B |
378 |
Rudy York |
20.64 |
1B |
379 |
Tony
Fernandez |
20.64 |
SS |
380 |
Johnny
Bates |
20.61 |
OF |
381 |
Del Pratt |
20.61 |
2B |
382 |
Jim
Delahanty |
20.60 |
2B |
383 |
Curt
Flood |
20.58 |
OF |
384 |
Elbie
Fletcher |
20.58 |
1B |
385 |
Mike
Hargrove |
20.53 |
1B |
386 |
Freddy
Lindstrom |
20.49 |
3B |
387 |
Spud |
20.49 |
C |
388 |
Bill
Bradley |
20.48 |
3B |
389 |
Tony
Gonzalez |
20.47 |
OF |
390 |
Travis
Jackson |
20.47 |
SS |
391 |
Andre
Dawson |
20.46 |
OF |
392 |
Ken
Keltner |
20.43 |
3B |
393 |
Buddy
Myer |
20.42 |
2B |
394 |
Luis
Gonzalez |
20.39 |
OF |
395 |
Mike
Mitchell |
20.38 |
OF |
396 |
Wally
Moon |
20.37 |
OF |
397 |
Al Smith |
20.37 |
OF |
398 |
|
20.37 |
1B |
399 |
Ben
Chapman |
20.35 |
OF |
400 |
Gary
Matthews |
20.34 |
OF |
401 |
Graig
Nettles |
20.34 |
3B |
402 |
Doug
DeCinces |
20.33 |
3B |
403 |
Ray Boone |
20.31 |
3B |
404 |
Harlond
Clift |
20.30 |
3B |
405 |
Harry
Hooper |
20.30 |
OF |
406 |
Andy
Pafko |
20.29 |
OF |
407 |
Davey
Johnson |
20.28 |
2B |
408 |
Bill
White |
20.27 |
1B |
409 |
Richie
Hebner |
20.23 |
3B |
410 |
Cecil
Travis |
20.23 |
SS |
411 |
Al Oliver |
20.21 |
OF |
412 |
Herman
Long |
20.21 |
SS |
413 |
Vic Wertz |
20.21 |
OF |
414 |
Wally
Joyner |
20.20 |
1B |
415 |
Hank
Bauer |
20.19 |
OF |
416 |
Jack Rowe |
20.17 |
SS |
417 |
Jim Rice |
20.17 |
OF |
418 |
Leon
Wagner |
20.16 |
OF |
419 |
Paul
O'Neill |
20.15 |
OF |
420 |
Harry
Steinfeldt |
20.14 |
3B |
421 |
Andy
Seminick |
20.13 |
C |
422 |
Richie
Zisk |
20.11 |
OF |
423 |
Ron Hunt |
20.10 |
2B |
424 |
Jack
Clements |
20.10 |
C |
425 |
Lou Brock |
20.07 |
OF |
426 |
Bill
North |
20.05 |
OF |
427 |
Brett
Butler |
20.03 |
OF |
428 |
Carl
Furillo |
20.03 |
OF |
429 |
Jim
Bottomley |
20.01 |
1B |
430 |
John
Anderson |
20.01 |
OF |
431 |
Jim
Northrup |
20.01 |
OF |
432 |
Carney
Lansford |
20.00 |
3B |
433 |
John
Mayberry |
20.00 |
1B |
434 |
Vada
Pinson |
20.00 |
OF |
435 |
Eddie
Joost |
19.97 |
SS |
436 |
Jesse
Barfield |
19.94 |
OF |
437 |
Phil
Cavarretta |
19.94 |
1B |
438 |
Jackie
Jensen |
19.93 |
OF |
439 |
Ray
Schalk |
19.91 |
C |
440 |
Johnny
Logan |
19.90 |
SS |
441 |
Mickey
Rivers |
19.89 |
OF |
442 |
Elmer
Valo |
19.89 |
OF |
443 |
Jimmy
Slagle |
19.88 |
OF |
444 |
Barney
McCosky |
19.88 |
OF |
445 |
Wes
Parker |
19.84 |
1B |
446 |
John
Reilly |
19.83 |
1B |
447 |
Sam Wise |
19.79 |
SS |
448 |
Larry
Hisle |
19.79 |
OF |
449 |
Ken
McMullen |
19.79 |
3B |
450 |
Reggie
Sanders |
19.79 |
OF |
451 |
Dusty
Baker |
19.79 |
OF |
452 |
Alvin
Davis |
19.79 |
1B |
453 |
Bob
Meusel |
19.78 |
OF |
454 |
Earl
Torgeson |
19.75 |
1B |
455 |
Felipe
Alou |
19.75 |
OF |
456 |
Maury
Wills |
19.74 |
SS |
457 |
Cy
Williams |
19.73 |
OF |
458 |
George
Kell |
19.71 |
3B |
459 |
Jeff
Burroughs |
19.69 |
OF |
460 |
Cecil
Cooper |
19.67 |
1B |
461 |
Irish
Meusel |
19.65 |
OF |
462 |
Dummy Hoy |
19.64 |
OF |
463 |
Jake
Beckley |
19.64 |
1B |
464 |
Kip
Selbach |
19.64 |
OF |
465 |
George
Hendrick |
19.63 |
OF |
466 |
Bill
Skowron |
19.61 |
1B |
467 |
Dan
McGann |
19.61 |
1B |
468 |
George
Pinckney |
19.61 |
3B |
469 |
Brooks
Robinson |
19.58 |
3B |
470 |
Les Mann |
19.56 |
OF |
471 |
Dickie
Thon |
19.56 |
SS |
472 |
Freddy
Parent |
19.54 |
SS |
473 |
Ozzie
Smith |
19.54 |
SS |
474 |
Buddy
Lewis |
19.54 |
3B |
475 |
Chief
Zimmer |
19.52 |
C |
476 |
Jake
Daubert |
19.50 |
1B |
477 |
Mickey
Vernon |
19.50 |
1B |
478 |
Buddy |
19.49 |
3B |
479 |
Al Bumbry |
19.49 |
OF |
480 |
Claude
Ritchey |
19.48 |
2B |
481 |
Jim
Landis |
19.47 |
OF |
482 |
Hans
Lobert |
19.46 |
3B |
483 |
Amos
Strunk |
19.45 |
OF |
484 |
Red Rolfe |
19.42 |
3B |
485 |
Duffy
Lewis |
19.42 |
OF |
486 |
Garry
Maddox |
19.42 |
OF |
487 |
Cleon
Jones |
19.32 |
OF |
488 |
John
Stone |
19.30 |
OF |
489 |
Fred
Merkle |
19.26 |
1B |
490 |
Julio
Franco |
19.25 |
SS |
491 |
Jim
Gilliam |
19.24 |
2B |
492 |
Denis
Menke |
19.22 |
SS |
493 |
Tom Burns |
19.20 |
3B |
494 |
Dave
Magadan |
19.19 |
3B |
495 |
Robby
Thompson |
19.19 |
2B |
496 |
Fred
Luderus |
19.19 |
1B |
497 |
Tommy
McCarthy |
19.16 |
OF |
498 |
Andre
Thornton |
19.15 |
DH |
499 |
Tony
Cuccinello |
19.13 |
2B |
500 |
Muddy
Ruel |
19.10 |
C |
501 |
Pete
Runnels |
19.10 |
1B |
502 |
Steve
Garvey |
19.10 |
1B |
503 |
Bobby
Thomson |
19.09 |
OF |
504 |
Joe Judge |
19.08 |
1B |
505 |
Lloyd
Waner |
19.07 |
OF |
506 |
Arlie
Latham |
19.06 |
3B |
507 |
Tony
Phillips |
19.06 |
OF |
508 |
Ben
Oglivie |
19.05 |
OF |
509 |
George
Kelly |
19.05 |
1B |
510 |
Jay
Buhner |
19.02 |
OF |
511 |
Del Ennis |
19.02 |
OF |
512 |
Terry
Steinbach |
19.01 |
C |
513 |
Baby Doll
Jacobson |
19.00 |
OF |
514 |
Steve
Finley |
19.00 |
OF |
515 |
Greg
Vaughn |
18.98 |
OF |
516 |
Harvey
Kuenn |
18.97 |
OF |
517 |
Von Hayes |
18.95 |
OF |
518 |
Ron
Hansen |
18.94 |
SS |
519 |
Rick
Dempsey |
18.94 |
C |
520 |
Jeff
Blauser |
18.93 |
SS |
521 |
Duke
Farrell |
18.93 |
C |
522 |
Terry
Moore |
18.93 |
OF |
523 |
Bob
Bescher |
18.91 |
OF |
524 |
Manny
Sanguillen |
18.91 |
C |
525 |
Nellie
Fox |
18.91 |
2B |
526 |
Rick
Ferrell |
18.88 |
C |
527 |
Eddie
Yost |
18.86 |
3B |
528 |
Bert
Campaneris |
18.85 |
SS |
529 |
Hal Chase |
18.85 |
1B |
530 |
Jo-Jo
Moore |
18.84 |
OF |
531 |
Mike
Stanley |
18.83 |
C |
532 |
Johnny
Edwards |
18.81 |
C |
533 |
Jason
Thompson |
18.80 |
1B |
534 |
Ed McKean |
18.79 |
SS |
535 |
Jim
Sundberg |
18.79 |
C |
536 |
Jay Bell |
18.78 |
SS |
537 |
Willie
Kamm |
18.78 |
3B |
538 |
Tilly
Walker |
18.76 |
OF |
539 |
Willie
Horton |
18.75 |
OF |
540 |
Al Dark |
18.71 |
SS |
541 |
Jerry
Mumphrey |
18.70 |
OF |
542 |
Dick
Bartell |
18.68 |
SS |
543 |
Marty |
18.68 |
SS |
544 |
Chicken
Wolf |
18.68 |
OF |
545 |
Cesar
Tovar |
18.67 |
OF |
546 |
Matty
Alou |
18.65 |
OF |
547 |
Buck
Weaver |
18.61 |
SS |
548 |
Wally
Moses |
18.61 |
OF |
549 |
Kevin
Seitzer |
18.60 |
3B |
550 |
Charlie
Hemphill |
18.58 |
OF |
551 |
John
Morrill |
18.55 |
1B |
552 |
Andres
Galarraga |
18.55 |
1B |
553 |
Billy
Southworth |
18.54 |
OF |
554 |
Lave
Cross |
18.53 |
3B |
555 |
Tito
Francona |
18.51 |
OF |
556 |
Hal McRae |
18.50 |
DH |
557 |
Chili |
18.48 |
OF |
558 |
George
Wood |
18.48 |
OF |
559 |
Roger
Peckinpaugh |
18.47 |
SS |
560 |
Willie
Wilson |
18.47 |
OF |
561 |
Bill
Bruton |
18.46 |
OF |
562 |
Bing
Miller |
18.45 |
OF |
563 |
Joe Rudi |
18.45 |
OF |
564 |
Sherm
Lollar |
18.45 |
C |
565 |
Tommy
Harper |
18.45 |
OF |
566 |
Doug
Rader |
18.44 |
3B |
567 |
Phil
Garner |
18.42 |
2B |
568 |
Red
Schoendienst |
18.41 |
2B |
569 |
Gus Suhr |
18.39 |
1B |
570 |
Fred
Pfeffer |
18.38 |
2B |
571 |
Woody
English |
18.37 |
SS |
572 |
Travis
Fryman |
18.36 |
3B |
573 |
Buck
Herzog |
18.32 |
3B |
574 |
Fred
Tenney |
18.32 |
1B |
575 |
Mike
Greenwell |
18.31 |
OF |
576 |
Delino
DeShields |
18.31 |
2B |
577 |
Dan
Driessen |
18.28 |
1B |
578 |
Dave
Henderson |
18.26 |
OF |
579 |
Don Money |
18.24 |
3B |
580 |
Puddin'
Head Jones |
18.24 |
3B |
581 |
Bibb Falk |
18.20 |
OF |
582 |
Brady
Anderson |
18.16 |
OF |
583 |
Ron Gant |
18.16 |
OF |
584 |
Burt
Shotton |
18.15 |
OF |
585 |
Kevin
Bass |
18.13 |
OF |
586 |
Dave
Concepcion |
18.08 |
SS |
587 |
Jimmy
Johnston |
18.08 |
3B |
588 |
Don
Baylor |
18.06 |
DH |
589 |
Hi Myers |
18.04 |
OF |
590 |
Tim
Wallach |
18.04 |
3B |
591 |
Tino
Martinez |
18.04 |
1B |
592 |
Tom Herr |
18.03 |
2B |
593 |
Mike
Kreevich |
18.03 |
OF |
594 |
Mookie
Wilson |
17.98 |
OF |
595 |
Doc
Hoblitzell |
17.98 |
1B |
596 |
Bill
Werber |
17.96 |
3B |
597 |
Gorman
Thomas |
17.95 |
OF |
598 |
Harold
Baines |
17.94 |
DH |
599 |
Terry
Kennedy |
17.93 |
C |
600 |
Ted
Kluszewski |
17.93 |
1B |
601 |
George
Burns-1b |
17.92 |
1B |
602 |
Bret
Boone |
17.89 |
2B |
603 |
Ruppert
Jones |
17.88 |
OF |
604 |
Lee Lacy |
17.87 |
OF |
605 |
Jose
Cardenal |
17.85 |
OF |
606 |
Sammy
West |
17.85 |
OF |
607 |
Dick
Groat |
17.83 |
SS |
608 |
Rube
Oldring |
17.80 |
OF |
609 |
Lu Blue |
17.80 |
1B |
610 |
Curt
Walker |
17.79 |
OF |
611 |
Roy
Smalley |
17.79 |
SS |
612 |
Paul
Blair |
17.77 |
OF |
613 |
Deacon
McGuire |
17.75 |
C |
614 |
Lee May |
17.74 |
1B |
615 |
Chief
Wilson |
17.74 |
OF |
616 |
Willie
McGee |
17.73 |
OF |
617 |
Wid
Conroy |
17.73 |
3B |
618 |
Steve
O'Neill |
17.71 |
C |
619 |
Glenn
Hubbard |
17.71 |
2B |
620 |
Marquis
Grissom |
17.69 |
OF |
621 |
Carlos
Baerga |
17.65 |
2B |
622 |
Dave Cash |
17.65 |
2B |
623 |
Jerry
Denny |
17.65 |
3B |
624 |
Billy
Rogell |
17.63 |
SS |
625 |
Ken
Henderson |
17.60 |
OF |
626 |
Todd
Zeile |
17.59 |
3B |
627 |
Eddie
Foster |
17.54 |
3B |
628 |
Milt
Stock |
17.53 |
3B |
629 |
Johnny
Ray |
17.53 |
2B |
630 |
Jay
Johnstone |
17.47 |
OF |
631 |
Ralph
Garr |
17.46 |
OF |
632 |
Pat Kelly |
17.46 |
OF |
633 |
Cecil
Fielder |
17.46 |
1B |
634 |
Lloyd
Moseby |
17.45 |
OF |
635 |
Leo
Cardenas |
17.42 |
SS |
636 |
Ruben
Sierra |
17.41 |
OF |
637 |
Gus
Mancuso |
17.41 |
C |
638 |
Butch
Wynegar |
17.39 |
C |
639 |
Bob
Bailey |
17.39 |
3B |
640 |
Rabbit
Maranville |
17.39 |
SS |
641 |
Steve
Brodie |
17.38 |
OF |
642 |
Jack
Doyle |
17.36 |
1B |
643 |
Tommy
Davis |
17.33 |
OF |
644 |
Lyn Lary |
17.32 |
SS |
645 |
Lance
Johnson |
17.32 |
OF |
646 |
Jerry
Priddy |
17.31 |
2B |
647 |
Joe Kuhel |
17.31 |
1B |
648 |
Marty
McManus |
17.31 |
2B |
649 |
Gregg
Jefferies |
17.29 |
1B |
650 |
Chris
Chambliss |
17.24 |
1B |
651 |
Tom Brown |
17.24 |
OF |
652 |
Donn
Clendenon |
17.24 |
1B |
653 |
Rick
Burleson |
17.23 |
SS |
654 |
Donie
Bush |
17.21 |
SS |
655 |
Bruce
Bochte |
17.19 |
1B |
656 |
Terry
Pendleton |
17.14 |
3B |
657 |
Max Flack |
17.12 |
OF |
658 |
Juan
Samuel |
17.11 |
2B |
659 |
Billy
Goodman |
17.09 |
2B |
660 |
Billy
Shindle |
17.06 |
3B |
661 |
Claudell |
17.06 |
OF |
662 |
Stuffy
McInnis |
17.06 |
1B |
663 |
Hector
Lopez |
17.02 |
OF |
664 |
Dave
Kingman |
17.01 |
OF |
665 |
Ned
Hanlon |
17.01 |
OF |
666 |
Jimmy
Dykes |
17.00 |
3B |
667 |
George
McQuinn |
16.99 |
1B |
668 |
Joe
Carter |
16.99 |
OF |
669 |
Roberto
Kelly |
16.99 |
OF |
670 |
Al Lopez |
16.97 |
C |
671 |
Bill
Mazeroski |
16.94 |
2B |
672 |
George
Scott |
16.93 |
1B |
673 |
Joe
Vosmik |
16.93 |
OF |
674 |
Luis
Aparicio |
16.91 |
SS |
675 |
Jack
Tobin |
16.90 |
OF |
676 |
Johnny
Temple |
16.86 |
2B |
677 |
Frankie
Crosetti |
16.84 |
SS |
678 |
George
Bell |
16.82 |
OF |
679 |
Wally
Pipp |
16.82 |
1B |
680 |
Eric
Karros |
16.81 |
1B |
681 |
Steve Sax |
16.81 |
2B |
682 |
Jody Reed |
16.79 |
2B |
683 |
Sam
Chapman |
16.78 |
OF |
684 |
B.J.
Surhoff |
16.75 |
OF |
685 |
Deron
Johnson |
16.74 |
1B |
686 |
Mike
Higgins |
16.73 |
3B |
687 |
Bob Boone |
16.70 |
C |
688 |
Lou
Piniella |
16.70 |
OF |
689 |
Jim Hegan |
16.69 |
C |
690 |
George
Case |
16.68 |
OF |
691 |
Bruce
Campbell |
16.66 |
OF |
692 |
Terry
Turner |
16.65 |
2B |
693 |
|
16.60 |
OF |
694 |
Bud
Harrelson |
16.56 |
SS |
695 |
Ken
Oberkfell |
16.53 |
3B |
696 |
Garry
Templeton |
16.50 |
SS |
697 |
Frankie
Hayes |
16.45 |
C |
698 |
Joe
Pepitone |
16.45 |
1B |
699 |
Gary
Gaetti |
16.44 |
3B |
700 |
Greg
Gagne |
16.39 |
SS |
701 |
Chris
Speier |
16.37 |
SS |
702 |
Clete
Boyer |
16.29 |
3B |
703 |
Darryl
Hamilton |
16.28 |
OF |
704 |
|
16.26 |
SS |
705 |
Benito
Santiago |
16.22 |
C |
706 |
|
16.20 |
SS |
707 |
Bobby
Byrne |
16.16 |
3B |
708 |
Frank
White |
16.15 |
2B |
709 |
Jack
Smith |
16.12 |
OF |
710 |
Jorge
Orta |
16.05 |
2B |
711 |
Scott
Fletcher |
16.05 |
SS |
712 |
Gus Bell |
16.03 |
OF |
713 |
Tony Pena |
16.03 |
C |
714 |
Gee |
16.00 |
OF |
715 |
Shawon
Dunston |
15.98 |
SS |
716 |
Patsy
Donovan |
15.96 |
OF |
717 |
Duff
Cooley |
15.95 |
OF |
718 |
Jimmy
Piersall |
15.93 |
OF |
719 |
Tommy
Griffith |
15.93 |
OF |
720 |
Jack
Graney |
15.92 |
OF |
721 |
Ossie
Bluege |
15.91 |
3B |
722 |
Red Kress |
15.91 |
SS |
723 |
Mark
Belanger |
15.90 |
SS |
724 |
Earl
Sheely |
15.88 |
1B |
725 |
Dante
Bichette |
15.88 |
OF |
726 |
David
Segui |
15.86 |
1B |
727 |
Larry
Herndon |
15.85 |
OF |
728 |
Charlie
Jamieson |
15.84 |
OF |
729 |
Frank
Thomas |
15.83 |
OF |
730 |
Jose
Offerman |
15.83 |
SS |
731 |
Tom
Brunansky |
15.82 |
OF |
732 |
Mickey
Doolan |
15.82 |
SS |
733 |
Bobby
Lowe |
15.72 |
2B |
734 |
Billy
Jurges |
15.71 |
SS |
735 |
Horace
Clarke |
15.70 |
2B |
736 |
Tommy
Tucker |
15.69 |
1B |
737 |
Pete Fox |
15.65 |
OF |
738 |
Dave
Collins |
15.65 |
OF |
739 |
Cass
Michaels |
15.62 |
2B |
740 |
Bill
Virdon |
15.60 |
OF |
741 |
Felix
Millan |
15.57 |
2B |
742 |
Jim
Gantner |
15.57 |
2B |
743 |
Zoilo
Versalles |
15.57 |
SS |
744 |
Freddie
Patek |
15.56 |
SS |
745 |
Bucky
Harris |
15.51 |
2B |
746 |
Dots
Miller |
15.51 |
1B |
747 |
Dean
Palmer |
15.47 |
3B |
748 |
Brook
Jacoby |
15.47 |
3B |
749 |
Tony
Armas |
15.43 |
OF |
750 |
Stan
Javier |
15.43 |
OF |
751 |
Del Unser |
15.38 |
OF |
752 |
Eddie
Miller |
15.38 |
SS |
753 |
Doggie
Miller |
15.37 |
C |
754 |
Paul
Radford |
15.36 |
OF |
755 |
Whitey
Lockman |
15.34 |
1B |
756 |
Jimmie
Wilson |
15.30 |
C |
757 |
Rollie
Hemsley |
15.29 |
C |
758 |
Pinky
Whitney |
15.28 |
3B |
759 |
Don
Blasingame |
15.28 |
2B |
760 |
Vic Power |
15.24 |
1B |
761 |
Luis
Polonia |
15.17 |
OF |
762 |
Jerry
Lumpe |
15.13 |
2B |
763 |
Sparky |
15.11 |
2B |
764 |
Tony
Taylor |
15.09 |
2B |
765 |
Ray
Knight |
15.06 |
3B |
766 |
Jeffrey
Leonard |
15.03 |
OF |
767 |
Mickey
Morandini |
15.02 |
2B |
768 |
Vince
Coleman |
14.98 |
OF |
769 |
Bucky
Dent |
14.96 |
SS |
770 |
Bill
Russell |
14.95 |
SS |
771 |
Ted
Sizemore |
14.92 |
2B |
772 |
Hubie
Brooks |
14.91 |
OF |
773 |
Brian
McRae |
14.91 |
OF |
774 |
Frank
Malzone |
14.91 |
3B |
775 |
Granny
Hamner |
14.83 |
SS |
776 |
Eric
Young |
14.81 |
2B |
777 |
Al Cowens |
14.81 |
OF |
778 |
Pete
O'Brien |
14.81 |
1B |
779 |
Otto
Knabe |
14.80 |
2B |
780 |
Tommy
Corcoran |
14.79 |
SS |
781 |
Monte
Cross |
14.78 |
SS |
782 |
Harold
Reynolds |
14.77 |
2B |
783 |
Frank
Bolling |
14.76 |
2B |
784 |
Omar
Vizquel |
14.74 |
SS |
785 |
Lou
Bierbauer |
14.73 |
2B |
786 |
Jimmy
Austin |
14.71 |
3B |
787 |
Dave
Martinez |
14.70 |
OF |
788 |
Mike
Bordick |
14.69 |
SS |
789 |
Charlie
Grimm |
14.67 |
1B |
790 |
Keith
Moreland |
14.66 |
OF |
791 |
Bill
Buckner |
14.60 |
1B |
792 |
George
Cutshaw |
14.60 |
2B |
793 |
Roy
McMillan |
14.56 |
SS |
794 |
Glenn
Beckert |
14.54 |
2B |
795 |
Walt
Weiss |
14.45 |
SS |
796 |
|
14.44 |
SS |
797 |
Kitty
Bransfield |
14.44 |
1B |
798 |
Mickey
Stanley |
14.43 |
OF |
799 |
Manny
Trillo |
14.39 |
2B |
800 |
Jim
Spencer |
14.38 |
1B |
801 |
Hobe
Ferris |
14.35 |
2B |
802 |
Doc
Cramer |
14.29 |
OF |
803 |
Ed
Kranepool |
14.26 |
1B |
804 |
Willie
Montanez |
14.26 |
1B |
805 |
Hughie
Critz |
14.24 |
2B |
806 |
Derek
Bell |
14.19 |
OF |
807 |
Otis
Nixon |
14.19 |
OF |
808 |
Julian
Javier |
14.16 |
2B |
809 |
Roy
Hartzell |
14.15 |
OF |
810 |
Mark
McLemore |
14.14 |
2B |
811 |
Tito
Fuentes |
14.08 |
2B |
812 |
Spike
Owen |
14.08 |
SS |
813 |
Omar
Moreno |
14.07 |
OF |
814 |
Jack
O'Connor |
13.89 |
C |
815 |
Tommy
Helms |
13.85 |
2B |
816 |
Wilbert
Robinson |
13.84 |
C |
817 |
Luke
Sewell |
13.73 |
C |
818 |
Shano
Collins |
13.72 |
OF |
819 |
Juan
Beniquez |
13.71 |
OF |
820 |
Cookie
Rojas |
13.58 |
2B |
821 |
Candy
LaChance |
13.58 |
1B |
822 |
Royce
Clayton |
13.57 |
SS |
823 |
Patsy
Tebeau |
13.55 |
1B |
824 |
Howard
Shanks |
13.54 |
OF |
825 |
Leo
Durocher |
13.46 |
SS |
826 |
Ozzie
Guillen |
13.45 |
SS |
827 |
Bobby
Richardson |
13.45 |
2B |
828 |
Charles
Comiskey |
13.41 |
1B |
829 |
Derrel
Thomas |
13.41 |
2B |
830 |
Enos
Cabell |
13.26 |
3B |
831 |
Ivan
DeJesus |
13.23 |
SS |
832 |
George
McBride |
13.20 |
SS |
833 |
Dave
Philley |
13.15 |
OF |
834 |
Frankie
Gustine |
13.12 |
2B |
835 |
Sandy
Alomar Sr. |
13.06 |
2B |
836 |
Charlie
Hayes |
13.04 |
3B |
837 |
Cub
Stricker |
13.00 |
2B |
838 |
George
Stovall |
12.90 |
1B |
839 |
Lance
Parrish |
12.88 |
C |
840 |
Hod Ford |
12.88 |
SS |
841 |
Bones Ely |
12.87 |
SS |
842 |
Joe Dugan |
12.79 |
3B |
843 |
Larry
Bowa |
12.74 |
SS |
844 |
Rick
Manning |
12.67 |
OF |
845 |
Bill
Hallman |
12.63 |
2B |
846 |
Rafael
Ramirez |
12.44 |
SS |
847 |
Wally
Gerber |
12.37 |
SS |
848 |
Ivy Olson |
12.22 |
SS |
849 |
Don
Kessinger |
12.08 |
SS |
850 |
Alfredo
Griffin |
11.85 |
SS |
851 |
Lou
Finney |
11.59 |
OF |
852 |
Ed
Brinkman |
11.52 |
SS |
853 |
Aurelio
Rodriguez |
11.35 |
3B |
854 |
Bill
Wambsganss |
11.26 |
2B |
855 |
Bob
Kennedy |
11.13 |
OF |
856 |
Ken Reitz |
10.72 |
3B |
857 |
Joe Quinn |
10.58 |
2B |
858 |
Tim Foli |
10.55 |
SS |
859 |
Ski
Melillo |
10.30 |
2B |
860 |
Pete
Suder |
9.83 |
2B |
861 |
Tommy
Dowd |
8.91 |
OF |
Rank |
Player |
WS per 648 PA |
|
1 |
Lou Gehrig |
32.80 |
|
2 |
Dick Allen |
30.30 |
|
3 |
Frank Chance |
30.12 |
|
4 |
Dan Brouthers |
29.97 |
|
5 |
Johnny Mize |
29.71 |
|
6 |
Jimmie Foxx |
29.15 |
|
7 |
Frank Thomas-cws |
29.02 |
|
8 |
Mark McGwire |
28.93 |
|
9 |
Jeff Bagwell |
28.48 |
|
10 |
Hank Greenberg |
28.38 |
|
11 |
Dave Orr |
27.55 |
|
12 |
Willie McCovey |
27.30 |
|
13 |
Roger Connor |
26.60 |
|
14 |
Jason Giambi |
26.50 |
|
15 |
Pedro Guerrero |
26.07 |
|
16 |
Will |
25.89 |
|
17 |
Norm Cash |
25.81 |
|
18 |
Bill Terry |
25.33 |
|
19 |
Jack Fournier |
24.81 |
|
20 |
Harmon Killebrew |
24.45 |
|
21 |
Cap Anson |
24.40 |
|
22 |
Jim Thome |
24.35 |
|
23 |
Babe Herman |
24.15 |
|
24 |
Rod Carew |
23.59 |
|
25 |
Keith Hernandez |
23.56 |
|
26 |
Boog Powell |
23.40 |
|
27 |
|
23.10 |
|
28 |
Dolph Camilli |
22.85 |
|
29 |
Ripper Collins |
22.65 |
|
30 |
Rafael Palmeiro |
22.41 |
|
31 |
Fred McGriff |
22.33 |
|
32 |
Don Mincher |
22.22 |
|
33 |
John Olerud |
22.19 |
|
34 |
Eddie Murray |
22.09 |
|
35 |
Don Mattingly |
22.07 |
|
36 |
Hal Trosky |
21.99 |
|
37 |
Bob Watson |
21.97 |
|
38 |
John Kruk |
21.96 |
|
39 |
Henry Larkin |
21.63 |
|
40 |
Ed Konetchy |
21.47 |
|
41 |
Ferris Fain |
21.27 |
|
42 |
Frank McCormick |
21.09 |
|
43 |
Norm Siebern |
21.04 |
|
44 |
Gil Hodges |
21.03 |
|
45 |
Mark Grace |
21.02 |
|
46 |
George Sisler |
20.99 |
|
47 |
Joe Adcock |
20.94 |
|
48 |
Harry Davis |
20.90 |
|
49 |
Kent Hrbek |
20.88 |
|
50 |
Mo Vaughn |
20.83 |
|
51 |
Tony Perez |
20.82 |
|
52 |
Ernie Banks |
20.70 |
|
53 |
Ron Fairly |
20.66 |
|
54 |
Rudy York |
20.64 |
|
55 |
Elbie Fletcher |
20.58 |
|
56 |
Mike Hargrove |
20.53 |
|
57 |
|
20.37 |
|
58 |
Bill White |
20.27 |
|
59 |
Wally Joyner |
20.20 |
|
60 |
Jim Bottomley |
20.01 |
|
61 |
John Mayberry |
20.00 |
|
62 |
Phil Cavarretta |
19.94 |
|
63 |
Wes Parker |
19.84 |
|
64 |
John Reilly |
19.83 |
|
65 |
Alvin Davis |
19.79 |
|
66 |
Earl Torgeson |
19.75 |
|
67 |
Cecil Cooper |
19.67 |
|
68 |
Jake Beckley |
19.64 |
|
69 |
Bill Skowron |
19.61 |
|
70 |
Dan McGann |
19.61 |
|
71 |
Jake Daubert |
19.50 |
|
72 |
Mickey Vernon |
19.50 |
|
73 |
Fred Merkle |
19.26 |
|
74 |
Fred Luderus |
19.19 |
|
75 |
Pete Runnels |
19.10 |
|
76 |
Steve Garvey |
19.10 |
|
77 |
Joe Judge |
19.08 |
|
78 |
George Kelly |
19.05 |
|
79 |
Hal Chase |
18.85 |
|
80 |
Jason Thompson |
18.80 |
|
81 |
John Morrill |
18.55 |
|
82 |
Andres Galarraga |
18.55 |
|
83 |
Gus Suhr |
18.39 |
|
84 |
Fred Tenney |
18.32 |
|
85 |
Dan Driessen |
18.28 |
|
86 |
Tino Martinez |
18.04 |
|
87 |
Doc Hoblitzell |
17.98 |
|
88 |
Ted Kluszewski |
17.93 |
|
89 |
George Burns-1b |
17.92 |
|
90 |
Lu Blue |
17.80 |
|
91 |
Lee May |
17.74 |
|
92 |
Cecil Fielder |
17.46 |
|
93 |
Jack Doyle |
17.36 |
|
94 |
Joe Kuhel |
17.31 |
|
95 |
Gregg Jefferies |
17.29 |
|
96 |
Chris Chambliss |
17.24 |
|
97 |
Donn Clendenon |
17.24 |
|
98 |
Bruce Bochte |
17.19 |
|
99 |
Stuffy McInnis |
17.06 |
|
100 |
George McQuinn |
16.99 |
|
101 |
George Scott |
16.93 |
|
102 |
Wally Pipp |
16.82 |
|
103 |
Eric Karros |
16.81 |
|
104 |
Deron Johnson |
16.74 |
|
105 |
Joe Pepitone |
16.45 |
|
106 |
Earl Sheely |
15.88 |
|
107 |
David Segui |
15.86 |
|
108 |
Tommy Tucker |
15.69 |
|
109 |
Dots Miller |
15.51 |
|
110 |
Whitey Lockman |
15.34 |
|
111 |
Vic Power |
15.24 |
|
112 |
Pete O'Brien |
14.81 |
|
113 |
Charlie Grimm |
14.67 |
|
114 |
Bill Buckner |
14.60 |
|
115 |
Kitty Bransfield |
14.44 |
|
116 |
Jim Spencer |
14.38 |
|
117 |
Ed Kranepool |
14.26 |
|
118 |
Willie Montanez |
14.26 |
|
119 |
Candy LaChance |
13.58 |
|
120 |
Patsy Tebeau |
13.55 |
|
121 |
Charles Comiskey |
13.41 |
|
122 |
George Stovall |
12.90 |
|
Rank |
Player |
WS per 648 PA |
|
|||
|
1 |
|
34.33 |
|||
|
2 |
Eddie Collins |
30.90 |
|||
|
3 |
Nap Lajoie |
30.73 |
|||
|
4 |
Joe Morgan |
29.29 |
|||
|
5 |
Jackie Robinson |
28.70 |
|||
|
6 |
Bobby Grich |
25.94 |
|||
|
7 |
Craig Biggio |
25.72 |
|||
|
8 |
Larry Doyle |
25.37 |
|||
|
9 |
Fred Dunlap |
25.08 |
|||
|
10 |
Roberto Alomar |
24.96 |
|||
|
11 |
Hardy |
24.72 |
|||
|
12 |
Charlie Gehringer |
24.24 |
|||
|
13 |
Ryne Sandberg |
24.16 |
|||
|
14 |
Johnny Evers |
24.09 |
|||
|
15 |
Edgardo Alfonzo |
24.01 |
|||
|
16 |
Joe Gordon |
23.99 |
|||
|
17 |
Frankie Frisch |
23.48 |
|||
|
18 |
Danny Murphy |
23.33 |
|||
|
19 |
Gil McDougald |
23.30 |
|||
|
20 |
Jeff Kent |
23.00 |
|||
|
21 |
Lou Whitaker |
22.82 |
|||
|
22 |
Cupid Childs |
22.81 |
|||
|
23 |
Eddie Stanky |
22.77 |
|||
|
24 |
Bobby Doerr |
22.68 |
|||
|
25 |
Tony Lazzeri |
22.36 |
|||
|
26 |
Billy Herman |
22.35 |
|||
|
27 |
Jimmy Williams |
21.95 |
|||
|
28 |
Dick McAuliffe |
21.81 |
|||
|
29 |
Tom Daly |
21.48 |
|||
|
30 |
Willie Randolph |
21.37 |
|||
|
31 |
Bobby Avila |
21.22 |
|||
|
32 |
George Grantham |
21.21 |
|||
|
33 |
Davey Lopes |
21.19 |
|||
|
34 |
Miller Huggins |
21.16 |
|||
|
35 |
Bill Doran |
21.12 |
|||
|
36 |
Lonny Frey |
21.05 |
|||
|
37 |
Chuck Knoblauch |
21.03 |
|||
|
38 |
Bid McPhee |
20.99 |
|||
|
39 |
Max Bishop |
20.64 |
|||
|
40 |
Del Pratt |
20.61 |
|||
|
41 |
Jim Delahanty |
20.60 |
|||
|
42 |
Buddy Myer |
20.42 |
|||
|
43 |
Davey Johnson |
20.28 |
|||
|
44 |
Ron Hunt |
20.10 |
|||
|
45 |
Claude Ritchey |
19.48 |
|||
|
46 |
Jim Gilliam |
19.24 |
|||
|
47 |
Robby Thompson |
19.19 |
|||
|
48 |
Tony Cuccinello |
19.13 |
|||
|
49 |
Nellie Fox |
18.91 |
|||
|
50 |
Phil Garner |
18.42 |
|||
|
51 |
Red Schoendienst |
18.41 |
|||
|
52 |
Fred Pfeffer |
18.38 |
|||
|
53 |
Delino DeShields |
18.31 |
|||
|
54 |
Tom Herr |
18.03 |
|||
|
55 |
Bret Boone |
17.89 |
|||
|
56 |
Glenn Hubbard |
17.71 |
|||
|
57 |
Carlos Baerga |
17.65 |
|||
|
58 |
Dave Cash |
17.65 |
|||
|
59 |
Johnny Ray |
17.53 |
|||
|
60 |
Jerry Priddy |
17.31 |
|||
|
61 |
Marty McManus |
17.31 |
|||
|
62 |
Juan Samuel |
17.11 |
|||
|
63 |
Billy Goodman |
17.09 |
|||
|
64 |
Bill Mazeroski |
16.94 |
|||
|
65 |
Johnny Temple |
16.86 |
|||
|
66 |
Steve Sax |
16.81 |
|||
|
67 |
Jody Reed |
16.79 |
|||
|
68 |
Terry Turner |
16.65 |
|||
|
69 |
Frank White |
16.15 |
|||
|
70 |
Jorge Orta |
16.05 |
|||
|
71 |
Bobby Lowe |
15.72 |
|||
|
72 |
Horace Clarke |
15.70 |
|||
|
73 |
Cass Michaels |
15.62 |
|||
|
74 |
Felix Millan |
15.57 |
|||
|
75 |
Jim Gantner |
15.57 |
|||
|
76 |
Bucky Harris |
15.51 |
|||
|
77 |
Don Blasingame |
15.28 |
|||
|
78 |
Jerry Lumpe |
15.13 |
|||
|
79 |
Sparky |
15.11 |
|||
|
80 |
Tony Taylor |
15.09 |
|||
|
81 |
Mickey Morandini |
15.02 |
|||
|
82 |
Ted Sizemore |
14.92 |
|||
|
83 |
Eric Young |
14.81 |
|||
|
84 |
Otto Knabe |
14.80 |
|||
|
85 |
Harold Reynolds |
14.77 |
|||
|
86 |
Frank Bolling |
14.76 |
|||
|
87 |
Lou Bierbauer |
14.73 |
|||
|
88 |
George Cutshaw |
14.60 |
|||
|
89 |
Glenn Beckert |
14.54 |
|||
|
90 |
Manny Trillo |
14.39 |
|||
|
91 |
Hobe Ferris |
14.35 |
|||
|
92 |
Hughie Critz |
14.24 |
|||
|
93 |
Julian Javier |
14.16 |
|||
|
94 |
Mark McLemore |
14.14 |
|||
|
95 |
Tito Fuentes |
14.08 |
|||
|
96 |
Tommy Helms |
13.85 |
|||
|
97 |
Cookie Rojas |
13.58 |
|||
|
98 |
Bobby Richardson |
13.45 |
|||
|
99 |
Derrel Thomas |
13.41 |
|||
|
100 |
Frankie Gustine |
13.12 |
|||
|
101 |
Sandy Alomar Sr. |
13.06 |
|||
|
102 |
Cub Stricker |
13.00 |
|||
|
103 |
Bill Hallman |
12.63 |
|||
|
104 |
Bill Wambsganss |
11.26 |
|||
|
105 |
Joe Quinn |
10.58 |
|||
|
106 |
Ski Melillo |
10.30 |
|||
|
107 |
Pete Suder |
9.83 |
|||
Rank |
Player |
WS per 648 PA |
|
|||
|
1 |
Mike Schmidt |
30.08 |
|||
|
2 |
Home Run Baker |
29.29 |
|||
|
3 |
Eddie Mathews |
28.87 |
|||
|
4 |
Al Rosen |
27.41 |
|||
|
5 |
John McGraw |
27.16 |
|||
|
6 |
Chipper Jones |
25.38 |
|||
|
7 |
Heine Groh |
25.05 |
|||
|
8 |
Denny |
24.52 |
|||
|
9 |
Bill Joyce |
24.49 |
|||
|
10 |
Art Devlin |
24.48 |
|||
|
11 |
Heinie Zimmerman |
24.16 |
|||
|
12 |
George Brett |
24.08 |
|||
|
13 |
Stan Hack |
24.07 |
|||
|
14 |
Jimmy Collins |
23.80 |
|||
|
15 |
Wade Boggs |
23.77 |
|||
|
16 |
Red Smith |
23.10 |
|||
|
17 |
Ezra Sutton |
22.99 |
|||
|
18 |
Bob Elliott |
22.71 |
|||
|
19 |
Jim Ray Hart |
22.64 |
|||
|
20 |
Ron Santo |
22.34 |
|||
|
21 |
Sal Bando |
22.13 |
|||
|
22 |
Ned Williamson |
22.06 |
|||
|
23 |
Ken Caminiti |
22.01 |
|||
|
24 |
Howard Johnson |
22.00 |
|||
|
25 |
Darrell Evans |
21.91 |
|||
|
26 |
Ken Boyer |
21.87 |
|||
|
27 |
Larry Gardner |
21.77 |
|||
|
28 |
Ron Cey |
21.74 |
|||
|
29 |
Deacon White |
21.72 |
|||
|
30 |
Robin Ventura |
21.60 |
|||
|
31 |
Larry Parrish |
21.57 |
|||
|
32 |
Pie Traynor |
21.41 |
|||
|
33 |
Billy Nash |
21.40 |
|||
|
34 |
Bill Madlock |
21.27 |
|||
|
35 |
Toby Harrah |
21.22 |
|||
|
36 |
Bobby Bonilla |
20.96 |
|||
|
37 |
Matt Williams |
20.88 |
|||
|
38 |
Freddy Lindstrom |
20.49 |
|||
|
39 |
Bill Bradley |
20.48 |
|||
|
40 |
Ken Keltner |
20.43 |
|||
|
41 |
Graig Nettles |
20.34 |
|||
|
42 |
Doug DeCinces |
20.33 |
|||
|
43 |
Ray Boone |
20.31 |
|||
|
44 |
Harlond Clift |
20.30 |
|||
|
45 |
Richie Hebner |
20.23 |
|||
|
46 |
Harry Steinfeldt |
20.14 |
|||
|
47 |
Carney Lansford |
20.00 |
|||
|
48 |
Ken McMullen |
19.79 |
|||
|
49 |
George Kell |
19.71 |
|||
|
50 |
George Pinckney |
19.61 |
|||
|
51 |
Brooks Robinson |
19.58 |
|||
|
52 |
Buddy Lewis |
19.54 |
|||
|
53 |
Buddy |
19.49 |
|||
|
54 |
Hans Lobert |
19.46 |
|||
|
55 |
Red Rolfe |
19.42 |
|||
|
56 |
Tom Burns |
19.20 |
|||
|
57 |
Dave Magadan |
19.19 |
|||
|
58 |
Arlie Latham |
19.06 |
|||
|
59 |
Eddie Yost |
18.86 |
|||
|
60 |
Willie Kamm |
18.78 |
|||
|
61 |
Kevin Seitzer |
18.60 |
|||
|
62 |
Lave Cross |
18.53 |
|||
|
63 |
Doug Rader |
18.44 |
|||
|
64 |
Travis Fryman |
18.36 |
|||
|
65 |
Buck Herzog |
18.32 |
|||
|
66 |
Don Money |
18.24 |
|||
|
67 |
Puddin' Head Jones |
18.24 |
|||
|
68 |
Jimmy Johnston |
18.08 |
|||
|
69 |
Tim Wallach |
18.04 |
|||
|
70 |
Bill Werber |
17.96 |
|||
|
71 |
Wid Conroy |
17.73 |
|||
|
72 |
Jerry Denny |
17.65 |
|||
|
73 |
Todd Zeile |
17.59 |
|||
|
74 |
Eddie Foster |
17.54 |
|||
|
75 |
Milt Stock |
17.53 |
|||
|
76 |
Bob Bailey |
17.39 |
|||
|
77 |
Terry Pendleton |
17.14 |
|||
|
78 |
Billy Shindle |
17.06 |
|||
|
79 |
Jimmy Dykes |
17.00 |
|||
|
80 |
Mike Higgins |
16.73 |
|||
|
81 |
Ken Oberkfell |
16.53 |
|||
|
82 |
Gary Gaetti |
16.44 |
|||
|
83 |
Clete Boyer |
16.29 |
|||
|
84 |
Bobby Byrne |
16.16 |
|||
|
85 |
Ossie Bluege |
15.91 |
|||
|
86 |
Dean Palmer |
15.47 |
|||
|
87 |
Brook Jacoby |
15.47 |
|||
|
88 |
Pinky Whitney |
15.28 |
|||
|
89 |
Ray Knight |
15.06 |
|||
|
90 |
Frank Malzone |
14.91 |
|||
|
91 |
Jimmy Austin |
14.71 |
|||
|
92 |
Enos Cabell |
13.26 |
|||
|
93 |
Charlie Hayes |
13.04 |
|||
|
94 |
Joe Dugan |
12.79 |
|||
|
95 |
Aurelio Rodriguez |
11.35 |
|||
|
96 |
Ken Reitz |
10.72 |
|||
1 |
Mike Piazza |
31.82 |
2 |
Yogi Berra |
29.06 |
3 |
Gabby Hartnett |
28.86 |
4 |
Bill Dickey |
28.82 |
5 |
Mickey Cochrane |
28.71 |
6 |
Roger Bresnahan |
27.86 |
7 |
Roy Campanella |
27.85 |
8 |
Gene Tenace |
27.09 |
9 |
Buck Ewing |
27.06 |
10 |
Johnny Bench |
26.61 |
11 |
Tom Haller |
25.67 |
12 |
Bill Freehan |
25.08 |
13 |
Wally Schang |
24.72 |
14 |
Gary Carter |
24.21 |
15 |
|
24.20 |
16 |
Darren Daulton |
23.76 |
17 |
Ivan Rodriguez |
23.74 |
18 |
Charlie Bennett |
23.60 |
19 |
Joe Torre |
23.19 |
20 |
Thurman Munson |
22.61 |
21 |
Elston Howard |
22.51 |
22 |
Earl Battey |
22.42 |
23 |
Ed Bailey |
22.33 |
24 |
Smoky Burgess |
22.23 |
25 |
Ernie Lombardi |
22.15 |
26 |
Walker Cooper |
22.08 |
27 |
Bob O'Farrell |
22.00 |
28 |
Darrell Porter |
21.90 |
29 |
Johnny Kling |
21.66 |
30 |
Mike Scioscia |
21.53 |
31 |
Tim McCarver |
21.30 |
32 |
John Roseboro |
21.22 |
33 |
Ted Simmons |
21.08 |
34 |
Del Crandall |
20.78 |
35 |
Mickey Tettleton |
20.75 |
36 |
Spud |
20.49 |
37 |
Andy Seminick |
20.13 |
38 |
Jack Clements |
20.10 |
39 |
Ray Schalk |
19.91 |
40 |
Chief Zimmer |
19.52 |
41 |
Muddy Ruel |
19.10 |
42 |
Terry Steinbach |
19.01 |
43 |
Rick Dempsey |
18.94 |
44 |
Duke Farrell |
18.93 |
45 |
Manny Sanguillen |
18.91 |
46 |
Rick Ferrell |
18.88 |
47 |
Mike Stanley |
18.83 |
48 |
Johnny Edwards |
18.81 |
49 |
Jim Sundberg |
18.79 |
50 |
Sherm Lollar |
18.45 |
51 |
Terry Kennedy |
17.93 |
52 |
Deacon McGuire |
17.75 |
53 |
Steve O'Neill |
17.71 |
54 |
Gus Mancuso |
17.41 |
55 |
Butch Wynegar |
17.39 |
56 |
Al Lopez |
16.97 |
57 |
Bob Boone |
16.70 |
58 |
Jim Hegan |
16.69 |
59 |
Frankie Hayes |
16.45 |
60 |
Benito Santiago |
16.22 |
61 |
Tony Pena |
16.03 |
62 |
Doggie Miller |
15.37 |
63 |
Jimmie Wilson |
15.30 |
64 |
Rollie Hemsley |
15.29 |
65 |
Jack O'Connor |
13.89 |
66 |
Wilbert Robinson |
13.84 |
67 |
Luke Sewell |
13.73 |
68 |
Lance Parrish |
12.88 |
Rank |
Player |
WS per 648 PA |
1 |
Edgar Martinez |
24.05 |
2 |
Paul Molitor |
22.06 |
3 |
Brian Downing |
20.74 |
4 |
Andre Thornton |
19.15 |
5 |
Hal McRae |
18.50 |
6 |
Don Baylor |
18.06 |
7 |
Harold Baines |
17.94 |
Rank |
Player |
WS per 648 PA |
||||
|
1 |
Babe Ruth |
39.92 |
|
||
|
2 |
Mickey
Mantle |
36.95 |
|
||
|
3 |
Ted
Williams |
36.74 |
|
||
|
4 |
Ty Cobb |
35.79 |
|
||
|
5 |
Barry
Bonds |
34.56 |
|
||
|
6 |
Tris
Speaker |
34.05 |
|
||
|
7 |
Joe
Jackson |
33.48 |
|
||
|
8 |
Willie
Mays |
33.30 |
|
||
|
9 |
Joe
DiMaggio |
32.69 |
|
||
|
10 |
Benny
Kauff |
31.82 |
|
||
|
11 |
Stan
Musial |
30.79 |
|
||
|
12 |
Charlie
Keller |
30.68 |
|
||
|
13 |
Mel Ott |
30.18 |
|
||
|
14 |
Hank
Aaron |
29.89 |
|
||
|
15 |
Elmer
Flick |
29.42 |
|
||
|
16 |
Billy
Hamilton |
28.77 |
|
||
|
17 |
Frank
Robinson |
28.64 |
|
||
|
18 |
King
Kelly |
27.91 |
|
||
|
19 |
Duke
Snider |
27.69 |
|
||
|
20 |
Wally
Berger |
27.58 |
|
||
|
21 |
Larry
Doby |
27.56 |
|
||
|
22 |
Pete
Browning |
27.43 |
|
||
|
23 |
Ed
Delahanty |
27.41 |
|
||
|
24 |
Sam
Crawford |
27.28 |
|
||
|
25 |
Sherry
Magee |
26.84 |
|
||
|
26 |
Willie
Stargell |
26.56 |
|
||
|
27 |
George
Gore |
26.54 |
|
||
|
28 |
Fred
Clarke |
26.40 |
|
||
|
29 |
Gary
Sheffield |
26.39 |
|
||
|
30 |
Manny
Ramirez |
26.39 |
|
||
|
31 |
Charley
Jones |
26.36 |
|
||
|
32 |
Rickey |
26.34 |
|
||
|
33 |
Mike
Donlin |
26.33 |
|
||
|
34 |
Jesse
Burkett |
26.22 |
|
||
|
35 |
Ken
Griffey Jr. |
26.22 |
|
||
|
36 |
Frank
Howard |
26.17 |
|
||
|
37 |
Reggie
Smith |
26.16 |
|
||
|
38 |
Hack |
26.13 |
|
||
|
39 |
George
Stone |
25.81 |
|
||
|
40 |
Darryl
Strawberry |
25.81 |
|
||
|
41 |
Harry
Heilmann |
25.75 |
|
||
|
42 |
Roy
Thomas |
25.62 |
|
||
|
43 |
Al
Simmons |
25.53 |
|
||
|
44 |
Lefty
O'Doul |
25.50 |
|
||
|
45 |
Paul
Waner |
25.47 |
|
||
|
46 |
Jeff
Heath |
25.29 |
|
||
|
47 |
Tony
Gwynn |
25.21 |
|
||
|
48 |
Reggie
Jackson |
25.20 |
|
||
|
49 |
Harry
Stovey |
25.14 |
|
||
|
50 |
Earl
Averill |
25.12 |
|
||
|
51 |
Ralph
Kiner |
25.07 |
|
||
|
52 |
Ross
Youngs |
25.03 |
|
||
|
53 |
Topsy
Hartsel |
24.97 |
|
||
|
54 |
Larry
Walker |
24.96 |
|
||
|
55 |
Edd Roush |
24.95 |
|
||
|
56 |
Tommy
Henrich |
24.92 |
|
||
|
57 |
Jack
Clark |
24.90 |
|
||
|
58 |
Jim
O'Rourke |
24.85 |
|
||
|
59 |
Joe
Medwick |
24.83 |
|
||
|
60 |
George
Van Haltren |
24.79 |
|
||
|
61 |
Al Kaline |
24.75 |
|
||
|
62 |
Roger
Maris |
24.72 |
|
||
|
63 |
Jimmy
Wynn |
24.67 |
|
||
|
64 |
Tim
Raines |
24.67 |
|
||
|
65 |
Lenny
Dykstra |
24.66 |
|
||
|
66 |
Oyster
Burns |
24.65 |
|
||
|
67 |
Zack
Wheat |
24.65 |
|
||
|
68 |
Roy
Cullenbine |
24.64 |
|
||
|
69 |
Stan
Spence |
24.63 |
|
||
|
70 |
Kevin
Mitchell |
24.56 |
|
||
|
71 |
Bernie
Williams |
24.45 |
|
||
|
72 |
Hugh
Duffy |
24.39 |
|
||
|
73 |
Augie
Galan |
24.34 |
|
||
|
74 |
Joe
Kelley |
24.28 |
|
||
|
75 |
Paul
Hines |
24.25 |
|
||
|
76 |
Moises
Alou |
24.25 |
|
||
|
77 |
Mike
Tiernan |
24.20 |
|
||
|
78 |
Bobby
Bonds |
24.19 |
|
||
|
79 |
Jimmy
Sheckard |
24.09 |
|
||
|
80 |
Riggs
Stephenson |
23.98 |
|
||
|
81 |
Chick
Stahl |
23.95 |
|
||
|
82 |
Roberto
Clemente |
23.92 |
|
||
|
83 |
Fielder
Jones |
23.81 |
|
||
|
84 |
Minnie
Minoso |
23.79 |
|
||
|
85 |
Jim
Edmonds |
23.75 |
|
||
|
86 |
Danny
Green |
23.70 |
|
||
|
87 |
Patsy
Dougherty |
23.69 |
|
||
|
88 |
Ryan
Klesko |
23.65 |
|
||
|
89 |
Ginger
Beaumont |
23.63 |
|
||
|
90 |
Eric
Davis |
23.61 |
|
||
|
91 |
Albert
Belle |
23.60 |
|
||
|
92 |
Cesar
Cedeno |
23.58 |
|
||
|
93 |
Chick
Hafey |
23.57 |
|
||
|
94 |
Don
Buford |
23.51 |
|
||
|
95 |
Socks
Seybold |
23.50 |
|
||
|
96 |
Dixie |
23.50 |
|
||
|
97 |
Sam
Thompson |
23.49 |
|
||
|
98 |
Tommy
Leach |
23.48 |
|
||
|
99 |
David
Justice |
23.47 |
|
||
|
100 |
Goose
Goslin |
23.42 |
|
||
|
101 |
Rocky
Colavito |
23.40 |
|
||
|
102 |
Kiki
Cuyler |
23.37 |
|
||
|
103 |
Rick
Monday |
23.34 |
|
||
|
104 |
Sam
Mertes |
23.33 |
|
||
|
105 |
Ken
Williams |
23.32 |
|
||
|
106 |
Bobby
Murcer |
23.26 |
|
||
|
107 |
Kirby
Puckett |
23.25 |
|
||
|
108 |
Mike
Griffin |
23.22 |
|
||
|
109 |
Andy Van
Slyke |
23.11 |
|
||
|
110 |
Bob
Johnson |
23.11 |
|
||
|
111 |
Tony
Oliva |
23.08 |
|
||
|
112 |
Billy
Williams |
23.04 |
|
||
|
113 |
Enos
Slaughter |
23.04 |
|
||
|
114 |
Fred Lynn |
22.90 |
|
||
|
115 |
Ken
Singleton |
22.87 |
|
||
|
116 |
Ray
Lankford |
22.79 |
|
||
|
117 |
George
Burns |
22.78 |
|
||
|
118 |
Bobby
Veach |
22.71 |
|
||
|
119 |
Jose Cruz |
22.71 |
|
||
|
120 |
Carl
Yastrzemski |
22.60 |
|
||
|
121 |
Earle
Combs |
22.60 |
|
||
|
122 |
Bill
Nicholson |
22.52 |
|
||
|
123 |
Amos Otis |
22.47 |
|
||
|
124 |
Jimmy
Ryan |
22.47 |
|
||
|
125 |
Willie
Keeler |
22.45 |
|
||
|
126 |
Buck
Freeman |
22.45 |
|
||
|
127 |
Tim
Salmon |
22.44 |
|
||
|
128 |
John
Titus |
22.39 |
|
||
|
129 |
Pete Rose |
22.35 |
|
||
|
130 |
Gene
Woodling |
22.34 |
|
||
|
131 |
George
Foster |
22.31 |
|
||
|
132 |
Bob
Allison |
22.22 |
|
||
|
133 |
Sid
Gordon |
22.19 |
|
||
|
134 |
Abner
Dalrymple |
22.17 |
|
||
|
135 |
Sammy
Sosa |
22.07 |
|
||
|
136 |
Oscar
Gamble |
22.07 |
|
||
|
137 |
Roy White |
22.03 |
|
||
|
138 |
Dom
DiMaggio |
22.01 |
|
||
|
139 |
Heinie
Manush |
21.95 |
|
||
|
140 |
Richie
Ashburn |
21.90 |
|
||
|
141 |
Tommy
Holmes |
21.89 |
|
||
|
142 |
Juan
Gonzalez |
21.86 |
|
||
|
143 |
Solly
Hofman |
21.82 |
|
||
|
144 |
Chet
Lemon |
21.81 |
|
||
|
145 |
Dave
Winfield |
21.76 |
|
||
|
146 |
Jose
Canseco |
21.68 |
|
||
|
147 |
Kevin
McReynolds |
21.68 |
|
||
|
148 |
Curt
Welch |
21.65 |
|
||
|
149 |
Pepper
Martin |
21.64 |
|
||
|
150 |
Chuck
Klein |
21.52 |
|
||
|
151 |
Rico
Carty |
21.44 |
|
||
|
152 |
Sixto
Lezcano |
21.40 |
|
||
|
153 |
Dwayne
Murphy |
21.39 |
|
||
|
154 |
John
Briggs |
21.30 |
|
||
|
155 |
Greg
Luzinski |
21.30 |
|
||
|
156 |
Dwight
Evans |
21.28 |
|
||
|
157 |
Matty
McIntyre |
21.28 |
|
||
|
158 |
Willie
Davis |
21.24 |
|
||
|
159 |
Kirk
Gibson |
21.22 |
|
||
|
160 |
Tom Tresh |
21.18 |
|
||
|
161 |
Casey
Stengel |
21.16 |
|
||
|
162 |
Max Carey |
21.12 |
|
||
|
163 |
Johnny
Grubb |
21.09 |
|
||
|
164 |
Dale
Murphy |
21.07 |
|
||
|
165 |
Kenny
Lofton |
21.07 |
|
||
|
166 |
Dode
Paskert |
21.02 |
|
||
|
167 |
Ival
Goodman |
21.02 |
|
||
|
168 |
Raul
Mondesi |
21.00 |
|
||
|
169 |
Johnny
Callison |
21.00 |
|
||
|
170 |
Johnny
Hopp |
20.90 |
|
||
|
171 |
Wildfire
Schulte |
20.89 |
|
||
|
172 |
Danny
Tartabull |
20.85 |
|
||
|
173 |
Ken
Griffey Sr. |
20.85 |
|
||
|
174 |
Hank
Sauer |
20.83 |
|
||
|
175 |
Terry
Puhl |
20.82 |
|
||
|
176 |
Dave
Parker |
20.81 |
|
||
|
177 |
Clyde |
20.74 |
|
||
|
178 |
Lonnie
Smith |
20.69 |
|
||
|
179 |
Sam Rice |
20.68 |
|
||
|
180 |
Ellis
Burks |
20.66 |
|
||
|
181 |
Rusty
Staub |
20.66 |
|
||
|
182 |
Johnny
Bates |
20.61 |
|
||
|
183 |
Curt
Flood |
20.58 |
|
||
|
184 |
Tony
Gonzalez |
20.47 |
|
||
|
185 |
Andre
Dawson |
20.46 |
|
||
|
186 |
Luis
Gonzalez |
20.39 |
|
||
|
187 |
Mike
Mitchell |
20.38 |
|
||
|
188 |
Wally
Moon |
20.37 |
|
||
|
189 |
Al Smith |
20.37 |
|
||
|
190 |
Ben
Chapman |
20.35 |
|
||
|
191 |
Gary
Matthews |
20.34 |
|
||
|
192 |
Harry
Hooper |
20.30 |
|
||
|
193 |
Andy
Pafko |
20.29 |
|
||
|
194 |
Al Oliver |
20.21 |
|
||
|
195 |
Vic Wertz |
20.21 |
|
||
|
196 |
Hank
Bauer |
20.19 |
|
||
|
197 |
Jim Rice |
20.17 |
|
||
|
198 |
Leon
Wagner |
20.16 |
|
||
|
199 |
Paul
O'Neill |
20.15 |
|
||
|
200 |
Richie
Zisk |
20.11 |
|
||
|
201 |
Lou Brock |
20.07 |
|
||
|
202 |
Bill
North |
20.05 |
|
||
|
203 |
Brett
Butler |
20.03 |
|
||
|
204 |
Carl
Furillo |
20.03 |
|
||
|
205 |
John
Anderson |
20.01 |
|
||
|
206 |
Jim
Northrup |
20.01 |
|
||
|
207 |
Vada
Pinson |
20.00 |
|
||
|
208 |
Jesse
Barfield |
19.94 |
|
||
|
209 |
Jackie
Jensen |
19.93 |
|
||
|
210 |
Mickey
Rivers |
19.89 |
|
||
|
211 |
Elmer
Valo |
19.89 |
|
||
|
212 |
Jimmy
Slagle |
19.88 |
|
||
|
213 |
Barney
McCosky |
19.88 |
|
||
|
214 |
Larry
Hisle |
19.79 |
|
||
|
215 |
Reggie
Sanders |
19.79 |
|
||
|
216 |
Dusty
Baker |
19.79 |
|
||
|
217 |
Bob
Meusel |
19.78 |
|
||
|
218 |
Felipe
Alou |
19.75 |
|
||
|
219 |
Cy
Williams |
19.73 |
|
||
|
220 |
Jeff
Burroughs |
19.69 |
|
||
|
221 |
Irish
Meusel |
19.65 |
|
||
|
222 |
Dummy Hoy |
19.64 |
|
||
|
223 |
Kip
Selbach |
19.64 |
|
||
|
224 |
George
Hendrick |
19.63 |
|
||
|
225 |
Les Mann |
19.56 |
|
||
|
226 |
Al Bumbry |
19.49 |
|
||
|
227 |
Jim
Landis |
19.47 |
|
||
|
228 |
Amos
Strunk |
19.45 |
|
||
|
229 |
Duffy
Lewis |
19.42 |
|
||
|
230 |
Garry
Maddox |
19.42 |
|
||
|
231 |
Cleon
Jones |
19.32 |
|
||
|
232 |
John
Stone |
19.30 |
|
||
|
233 |
Tommy
McCarthy |
19.16 |
|
||
|
234 |
Bobby
Thomson |
19.09 |
|
||
|
235 |
Lloyd
Waner |
19.07 |
|
||
|
236 |
Tony
Phillips |
19.06 |
|
||
|
237 |
Ben
Oglivie |
19.05 |
|
||
|
238 |
Jay
Buhner |
19.02 |
|
||
|
239 |
Del Ennis |
19.02 |
|
||
|
240 |
Baby Doll
Jacobson |
19.00 |
|
||
|
241 |
Steve
Finley |
19.00 |
|
||
|
242 |
Greg
Vaughn |
18.98 |
|
||
|
243 |
Harvey
Kuenn |
18.97 |
|
||
|
244 |
Von Hayes |
18.95 |
|
||
|
245 |
Terry
Moore |
18.93 |
|
||
|
246 |
Bob
Bescher |
18.91 |
|
||
|
247 |
Jo-Jo
Moore |
18.84 |
|
||
|
248 |
Tilly
Walker |
18.76 |
|
||
|
249 |
Willie
Horton |
18.75 |
|
||
|
250 |
Jerry
Mumphrey |
18.70 |
|
||
|
251 |
Chicken
Wolf |
18.68 |
|
||
|
252 |
Cesar
Tovar |
18.67 |
|
||
|
253 |
Matty
Alou |
18.65 |
|
||
|
254 |
Wally
Moses |
18.61 |
|
||
|
255 |
Charlie
Hemphill |
18.58 |
|
||
|
256 |
Billy
Southworth |
18.54 |
|
||
|
257 |
Tito
Francona |
18.51 |
|
||
|
258 |
Chili |
18.48 |
|
||
|
259 |
George
Wood |
18.48 |
|
||
|
260 |
Willie
Wilson |
18.47 |
|
||
|
261 |
Bill
Bruton |
18.46 |
|
||
|
262 |
Bing
Miller |
18.45 |
|
||
|
263 |
Joe Rudi |
18.45 |
|
||
|
264 |
Tommy
Harper |
18.45 |
|
||
|
265 |
Mike
Greenwell |
18.31 |
|
||
|
266 |
Dave
Henderson |
18.26 |
|
||
|
267 |
Bibb Falk |
18.20 |
|
||
|
268 |
Brady
Anderson |
18.16 |
|
||
|
269 |
Ron Gant |
18.16 |
|
||
|
270 |
Burt
Shotton |
18.15 |
|
||
|
271 |
Kevin
Bass |
18.13 |
|
||
|
272 |
Hi Myers |
18.04 |
|
||
|
273 |
Mike
Kreevich |
18.03 |
|
||
|
274 |
Mookie
Wilson |
17.98 |
|
||
|
275 |
Gorman
Thomas |
17.95 |
|
||
|
276 |
Ruppert
Jones |
17.88 |
|
||
|
277 |
Lee Lacy |
17.87 |
|
||
|
278 |
Jose
Cardenal |
17.85 |
|
||
|
279 |
Sammy
West |
17.85 |
|
||
|
280 |
Rube
Oldring |
17.80 |
|
||
|
281 |
Curt
Walker |
17.79 |
|
||
|
282 |
Paul
Blair |
17.77 |
|
||
|
283 |
Chief
Wilson |
17.74 |
|
||
|
284 |
Willie
McGee |
17.73 |
|
||
|
285 |
Marquis
Grissom |
17.69 |
|
||
|
286 |
Ken
Henderson |
17.60 |
|
||
|
287 |
Jay
Johnstone |
17.47 |
|
||
|
288 |
Ralph
Garr |
17.46 |
|
||
|
289 |
Pat Kelly |
17.46 |
|
||
|
290 |
Lloyd
Moseby |
17.45 |
|
||
|
291 |
Ruben
Sierra |
17.41 |
|
||
|
292 |
Steve
Brodie |
17.38 |
|
||
|
293 |
Tommy
Davis |
17.33 |
|
||
|
294 |
Lance
Johnson |
17.32 |
|
||
|
295 |
Tom Brown |
17.24 |
|
||
|
296 |
Max Flack |
17.12 |
|
||
|
297 |
Claudell |
17.06 |
|
||
|
298 |
Hector
Lopez |
17.02 |
|
||
|
299 |
Dave
Kingman |
17.01 |
|
||
|
300 |
Ned
Hanlon |
17.01 |
|
||
|
301 |
Joe
Carter |
16.99 |
|
||
|
302 |
Roberto
Kelly |
16.99 |
|
||
|
303 |
Joe
Vosmik |
16.93 |
|
||
|
304 |
Jack
Tobin |
16.90 |
|
||
|
305 |
George
Bell |
16.82 |
|
||
|
306 |
Sam
Chapman |
16.78 |
|
||
|
307 |
B.J.
Surhoff |
16.75 |
|
||
|
308 |
Lou
Piniella |
16.70 |
|
||
|
309 |
George
Case |
16.68 |
|
||
|
310 |
Bruce
Campbell |
16.66 |
|
||
|
311 |
|
16.60 |
|
||
|
312 |
Darryl
Hamilton |
16.28 |
|
||
|
313 |
Jack
Smith |
16.12 |
|
||
|
314 |
Gus Bell |
16.03 |
|
||
|
315 |
Gee |
16.00 |
|
||
|
316 |
Patsy
Donovan |
15.96 |
|
||
|
317 |
Duff
Cooley |
15.95 |
|
||
|
318 |
Jimmy
Piersall |
15.93 |
|
||
|
319 |
Tommy
Griffith |
15.93 |
|
||
|
320 |
Jack
Graney |
15.92 |
|
||
|
321 |
Dante
Bichette |
15.88 |
|
||
|
322 |
Larry
Herndon |
15.85 |
|
||
|
323 |
Charlie
Jamieson |
15.84 |
|
||
|
324 |
Frank
Thomas |
15.83 |
|
||
|
325 |
Tom
Brunansky |
15.82 |
|
||
|
326 |
Pete Fox |
15.65 |
|
||
|
327 |
Dave
Collins |
15.65 |
|
||
|
328 |
Bill
Virdon |
15.60 |
|
||
|
329 |
Tony
Armas |
15.43 |
|
||
|
330 |
Stan
Javier |
15.43 |
|
||
|
331 |
Del Unser |
15.38 |
|
||
|
332 |
Paul
Radford |
15.36 |
|
||
|
333 |
Luis
Polonia |
15.17 |
|
||
|
334 |
Jeffrey
Leonard |
15.03 |
|
||
|
335 |
Vince
Coleman |
14.98 |
|
||
|
336 |
Hubie
Brooks |
14.91 |
|
||
|
337 |
Brian
McRae |
14.91 |
|
||
|
338 |
Al Cowens |
14.81 |
|
||
|
339 |
Dave
Martinez |
14.70 |
|
||
|
340 |
Keith
Moreland |
14.66 |
|
||
|
341 |
Mickey
Stanley |
14.43 |
|
||
|
342 |
Doc
Cramer |
14.29 |
|
||
|
343 |
Derek
Bell |
14.19 |
|
||
|
344 |
Otis
Nixon |
14.19 |
|
||
|
345 |
Roy
Hartzell |
14.15 |
|
||
|
346 |
Omar
Moreno |
14.07 |
|
||
|
347 |
Shano
Collins |
13.72 |
|
||
|
348 |
Juan
Beniquez |
13.71 |
|
||
|
349 |
Howard
Shanks |
13.54 |
|
||
|
350 |
Dave
Philley |
13.15 |
|
||
|
351 |
Rick
Manning |
12.67 |
|
||
|
352 |
Lou
Finney |
11.59 |
|
||
|
353 |
Bob
Kennedy |
11.13 |
|
||
|
354 |
Tommy
Dowd |
8.91 |
|
||
Rank |
Player |
WS per 648 PA |
|||
|
1 |
Honus Wagner |
36.16 |
||
|
2 |
Arky |
29.88 |
||
|
3 |
Alex Rodriguez |
28.23 |
||
|
4 |
Barry Larkin |
26.45 |
||
|
5 |
Lou Boudreau |
25.56 |
||
|
6 |
George Davis |
25.39 |
||
|
7 |
Bill Dahlen |
24.55 |
||
|
8 |
Hughie Jennings |
24.52 |
||
|
9 |
Joe Cronin |
24.42 |
||
|
10 |
Luke Appling |
23.91 |
||
|
11 |
Vern Stephens |
23.72 |
||
|
12 |
Art Fletcher |
23.39 |
||
|
13 |
Joe Tinker |
23.37 |
||
|
14 |
Bobby Wallace |
23.26 |
||
|
15 |
Derek Jeter |
23.02 |
||
|
16 |
Jim Fregosi |
22.85 |
||
|
17 |
Kid Elberfeld |
22.62 |
||
|
18 |
Jack Glasscock |
22.41 |
||
|
19 |
Robin Yount |
22.38 |
||
|
20 |
Phil Rizzuto |
22.31 |
||
|
21 |
Alan Trammell |
21.98 |
||
|
22 |
Johnny Pesky |
21.97 |
||
|
23 |
Joe Sewell |
21.55 |
||
|
24 |
Rico Petrocelli |
21.53 |
||
|
25 |
Pee Wee Reese |
21.49 |
||
|
26 |
Cal Ripken |
21.48 |
||
|
27 |
Woodie Held |
21.34 |
||
|
28 |
Dave Bancroft |
21.14 |
||
|
29 |
Ray Chapman |
20.87 |
||
|
30 |
Tony Fernandez |
20.64 |
||
|
31 |
Travis Jackson |
20.47 |
||
|
32 |
Cecil Travis |
20.23 |
||
|
33 |
Herman Long |
20.21 |
||
|
34 |
Jack Rowe |
20.17 |
||
|
35 |
Eddie Joost |
19.97 |
||
|
36 |
Johnny Logan |
19.90 |
||
|
37 |
Sam Wise |
19.79 |
||
|
38 |
Maury Wills |
19.74 |
||
|
39 |
Dickie Thon |
19.56 |
||
|
40 |
Freddy Parent |
19.54 |
||
|
41 |
Ozzie Smith |
19.54 |
||
|
42 |
Julio Franco |
19.25 |
||
|
43 |
Denis Menke |
19.22 |
||
|
44 |
Ron Hansen |
18.94 |
||
|
45 |
Jeff Blauser |
18.93 |
||
|
46 |
Bert Campaneris |
18.85 |
||
|
47 |
Ed McKean |
18.79 |
||
|
48 |
Jay Bell |
18.78 |
||
|
49 |
Al Dark |
18.71 |
||
|
50 |
Dick Bartell |
18.68 |
||
|
51 |
Marty |
18.68 |
||
|
52 |
Buck Weaver |
18.61 |
||
|
53 |
Roger Peckinpaugh |
18.47 |
||
|
54 |
Woody English |
18.37 |
||
|
55 |
Dave Concepcion |
18.08 |
||
|
56 |
Dick Groat |
17.83 |
||
|
57 |
Roy Smalley |
17.79 |
||
|
58 |
Billy Rogell |
17.63 |
||
|
59 |
Leo Cardenas |
17.42 |
||
|
60 |
Rabbit Maranville |
17.39 |
||
|
61 |
Lyn Lary |
17.32 |
||
|
62 |
Rick Burleson |
17.23 |
||
|
63 |
Donie Bush |
17.21 |
||
|
64 |
Luis Aparicio |
16.91 |
||
|
65 |
Frankie Crosetti |
16.84 |
||
|
66 |
Bud Harrelson |
16.56 |
||
|
67 |
Garry Templeton |
16.50 |
||
|
68 |
Greg Gagne |
16.39 |
||
|
69 |
Chris Speier |
16.37 |
||
|
70 |
|
16.26 |
||
|
71 |
|
16.20 |
||
|
72 |
Scott Fletcher |
16.05 |
||
|
73 |
Shawon Dunston |
15.98 |
||
|
74 |
Red Kress |
15.91 |
||
|
75 |
Mark Belanger |
15.90 |
||
|
76 |
Jose Offerman |
15.83 |
||
|
77 |
Mickey Doolan |
15.82 |
||
|
78 |
Billy Jurges |
15.71 |
||
|
79 |
Zoilo Versalles |
15.57 |
||
|
80 |
Freddie Patek |
15.56 |
||
|
81 |
Eddie Miller |
15.38 |
||
|
82 |
Bucky Dent |
14.96 |
||
|
83 |
Bill Russell |
14.95 |
||
|
84 |
Granny Hamner |
14.83 |
||
|
85 |
Tommy Corcoran |
14.79 |
||
|
86 |
Monte Cross |
14.78 |
||
|
87 |
Omar Vizquel |
14.74 |
||
|
88 |
Mike Bordick |
14.69 |
||
|
89 |
Roy McMillan |
14.56 |
||
|
90 |
Walt Weiss |
14.45 |
||
|
91 |
|
14.44 |
||
|
92 |
Spike Owen |
14.08 |
||
|
93 |
Royce Clayton |
13.57 |
||
|
94 |
Leo Durocher |
13.46 |
||
|
95 |
Ozzie Guillen |
13.45 |
||
|
96 |
Ivan DeJesus |
13.23 |
||
|
97 |
George McBride |
13.20 |
||
|
98 |
Hod Ford |
12.88 |
||
|
99 |
Bones Ely |
12.87 |
||
|
100 |
Larry Bowa |
12.74 |
||
|
101 |
Rafael Ramirez |
12.44 |
||
|
102 |
Wally Gerber |
12.37 |
||
|
103 |
Ivy Olson |
12.22 |
||
|
104 |
Don Kessinger |
12.08 |
||
|
105 |
Alfredo Griffin |
11.85 |
||
|
106 |
Ed Brinkman |
11.52 |
||
|
107 |
Tim Foli |
10.55 |
||
Here I look at the position break down for the American League in 1960 and the National League in 1950. The patterns are similar to what I have found for the greatest players of all time above.
American League 1960:
|
AVG |
Simple AVG |
POS |
Per 648 |
Per 648 |
1B |
20.13 |
18.61 |
OF |
19.36 |
17.40 |
C |
16.62 |
15.05 |
SS |
16.30 |
15.19 |
2B |
15.86 |
15.51 |
3B |
15.86 |
14.74 |
A player’s position was based on the one given in the Win Shares book for that season. The first average was obtained by adding up all the Win Shares and all plate appearances for all the players at each position and then dividing. The second average is a simple average of all the players at each position. Again, first basemen, outfielders, and catchers tend to rank the highest, although the average falls for catchers when a simple average is taken. It seems that there are many low WS per PA catchers who did not play much who drag down the average.
POS |
#intop24 |
#inbottom24 |
total |
1B |
5 |
2 |
12 |
OF |
13 |
8 |
41 |
C |
3 |
6 |
19 |
SS |
2 |
4 |
11 |
2B |
1 |
1 |
10 |
3B |
0 |
3 |
11 |
|
24 |
24 |
104 |
I used a break down of the top 24 players in WS per PA and the bottom 24 since that represents three teams of 8 position players. Notice that there are more outfielders than expected and fewer 2B, 3B, and SS than expected in the top 24.
National League 1950:
|
AVG |
SIMPLE AVG |
POS |
Per 648 |
Per 648 |
C |
19.55 |
15.70 |
OF |
18.58 |
16.04 |
2B |
17.84 |
14.50 |
3B |
17.81 |
15.24 |
1B |
17.71 |
15.75 |
SS |
14.76 |
13.43 |
Here, 1B men are not in the top 3 under the first average (the cumulative). But again, in the simple average, 1B, C, and OF are the three highest.
POS |
#intop24 |
#inbottom24 |
total |
C |
4 |
3 |
15 |
OF |
12 |
8 |
42 |
2B |
2 |
4 |
14 |
3B |
3 |
5 |
13 |
1B |
3 |
2 |
12 |
SS |
0 |
2 |
12 |
|
24 |
24 |
108 |
Notice again, that outfielders are over reprsented in the top 24 and 2B and SS are underrepresented.
I also looked at the 1940AL and the 1930NL. Both of those cases followed the same pattern seen before. Below is table that shows the how many players at each position were in the top and bottom 24 for each of the following combined: 1930NL, 1940AL, 1950NL and 1960AL:
|
#intop24 |
#inbottom24 |
|
1B |
12 |
8 |
|
2B |
7 |
14 |
|
3B |
8 |
13 |
|
C |
12 |
17 |
|
OF |
50 |
28 |
|
SS |
7 |
16 |
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
Again, notice that OF is over-represented in the top 24. We would expect 36 outfielders since there are four cases and 9 OF slots in each top 24 for a case. We would expect 12 shortstops and 12 second basemen, but there are only seven of each.
I also combined the simple average for all the positions for all four cases.
|
SIMPLE |
|
POS |
AVG |
PER648 |
OF |
0.0268 |
17.35 |
1B |
0.0257 |
16.64 |
C |
0.0240 |
15.53 |
3B |
0.0239 |
15.51 |
2B |
0.0225 |
14.60 |
SS |
0.0217 |
14.09 |
Rank |
Player |
WS per 648 PA |
POS |
1 |
Babe Ruth |
39.92 |
OF |
2 |
Mickey Mantle |
36.95 |
OF |
3 |
Ted Williams |
36.74 |
OF |
4 |
Honus Wagner |
36.16 |
SS |
5 |
Ty Cobb |
35.79 |
OF |
6 |
Barry Bonds |
34.56 |
OF |
7 |
|
34.33 |
2B |
8 |
Tris Speaker |
34.05 |
OF |
9 |
Willie Mays |
33.3 |
OF |
10 |
Lou Gehrig |
32.8 |
1B |
11 |
Joe DiMaggio |
32.69 |
OF |
12 |
Eddie Collins |
30.9 |
2B |
13 |
Stan Musial |
30.79 |
OF |
14 |
Nap Lajoie |
30.73 |
2B |
15 |
Mel Ott |
30.18 |
OF |
16 |
Mike Schmidt |
30.08 |
3B |
17 |
Dan Brouthers |
29.97 |
1B |
18 |
Hank Aaron |
29.89 |
OF |
19 |
Arky |
29.88 |
SS |
20 |
Joe Morgan |
29.29 |
2B |
21 |
Jimmie Foxx |
29.15 |
1B |
22 |
Yogi Berra |
29.06 |
C |
23 |
Mark McGwire |
28.93 |
1B |
24 |
Eddie Mathews |
28.87 |
3B |
25 |
Billy Hamilton |
28.77 |
OF |
26 |
Frank Robinson |
28.64 |
OF |
27 |
Duke Snider |
27.69 |
OF |
28 |
Ed Delahanty |
27.41 |
OF |
29 |
Willie McCovey |
27.3 |
1B |
30 |
Sam Crawford |
27.28 |
OF |
31 |
Sherry Magee |
26.84 |
OF |
32 |
Johnny Bench |
26.61 |
C |
33 |
Roger Connor |
26.6 |
1B |
34 |
Willie Stargell |
26.56 |
OF |
35 |
Barry Larkin |
26.45 |
SS |
36 |
Fred Clarke |
26.4 |
OF |
37 |
Rickey |
26.34 |
OF |
38 |
Jesse Burkett |
26.22 |
OF |
39 |
Ken Griffey Jr. |
26.22 |
OF |
40 |
Reggie Smith |
26.16 |
OF |
41 |
Bobby Grich |
25.94 |
2B |
42 |
Will |
25.89 |
1B |
43 |
Norm Cash |
25.81 |
1B |
44 |
Harry Heilmann |
25.75 |
OF |
45 |
Craig Biggio |
25.72 |
2B |
46 |
Al Simmons |
25.53 |
OF |
47 |
Paul Waner |
25.47 |
OF |
48 |
George Davis |
25.39 |
SS |
49 |
Tony Gwynn |
25.21 |
OF |
50 |
Reggie Jackson |
25.2 |
OF |
51 |
Roberto Alomar |
24.96 |
2B |
52 |
Edd Roush |
24.95 |
OF |
53 |
Jack Clark |
24.9 |
OF |
54 |
Jim O'Rourke |
24.85 |
OF |
55 |
Joe Medwick |
24.83 |
OF |
56 |
George Van Haltren |
24.79 |
OF |
57 |
Al Kaline |
24.75 |
OF |
58 |
Jimmy Wynn |
24.67 |
OF |
59 |
Tim Raines |
24.67 |
OF |
60 |
Zack Wheat |
24.65 |
OF |
61 |
Bill Dahlen |
24.55 |
SS |
62 |
Harmon Killebrew |
24.45 |
1B |
63 |
Joe Cronin |
24.42 |
SS |
64 |
Cap Anson |
24.4 |
1B |
65 |
Hugh Duffy |
24.39 |
OF |
66 |
Joe Kelley |
24.28 |
OF |
67 |
Charlie Gehringer |
24.24 |
2B |
68 |
Gary Carter |
24.21 |
C |
69 |
|
24.2 |
C |
70 |
Bobby Bonds |
24.19 |
OF |
71 |
Ryne Sandberg |
24.16 |
2B |
72 |
Jimmy Sheckard |
24.09 |
OF |
73 |
George Brett |
24.08 |
3B |
74 |
Stan Hack |
24.07 |
3B |
75 |
Roberto Clemente |
23.92 |
OF |
76 |
Luke Appling |
23.91 |
SS |
77 |
Fielder Jones |
23.81 |
OF |
78 |
Minnie Minoso |
23.79 |
OF |
79 |
Wade Boggs |
23.77 |
3B |
80 |
Rod Carew |
23.59 |
1B |
81 |
Cesar Cedeno |
23.58 |
OF |
82 |
Keith Hernandez |
23.56 |
1B |
83 |
Dixie |
23.5 |
OF |
84 |
Frankie Frisch |
23.48 |
2B |
85 |
Tommy Leach |
23.48 |
OF |
86 |
Goose Goslin |
23.42 |
OF |
87 |
Boog Powell |
23.4 |
1B |
88 |
Rocky Colavito |
23.4 |
OF |
89 |
Kiki Cuyler |
23.37 |
OF |
90 |
Bobby Murcer |
23.26 |
OF |
91 |
Bobby Wallace |
23.26 |
SS |
92 |
Kirby Puckett |
23.25 |
OF |
93 |
Joe Torre |
23.19 |
C |
94 |
Bob Johnson |
23.11 |
OF |
95 |
|
23.1 |
1B |
96 |
Billy Williams |
23.04 |
OF |
97 |
Enos Slaughter |
23.04 |
OF |
98 |
Fred Lynn |
22.9 |
OF |
99 |
Ken Singleton |
22.87 |
OF |
100 |
Lou Whitaker |
22.82 |
2B |
101 |
Bob Elliott |
22.71 |
3B |
102 |
Bobby Veach |
22.71 |
OF |
103 |
Jose Cruz |
22.71 |
OF |
104 |
Bobby Doerr |
22.68 |
2B |
105 |
Carl Yastrzemski |
22.6 |
OF |
106 |
Amos Otis |
22.47 |
OF |
107 |
Jimmy Ryan |
22.47 |
OF |
108 |
Willie Keeler |
22.45 |
OF |
109 |
Jack Glasscock |
22.41 |
SS |
110 |
Rafael Palmeiro |
22.41 |
1B |
111 |
Robin Yount |
22.38 |
SS |
112 |
Billy Herman |
22.35 |
2B |
113 |
Pete Rose |
22.35 |
OF |
114 |
Ron Santo |
22.34 |
3B |
115 |
Fred McGriff |
22.33 |
1B |
116 |
George Foster |
22.31 |
OF |
117 |
Sal Bando |
22.13 |
3B |
118 |
Eddie Murray |
22.09 |
1B |
119 |
Don Mattingly |
22.07 |
1B |
120 |
Paul Molitor |
22.06 |
DH |
121 |
Roy White |
22.03 |
OF |
122 |
Alan Trammell |
21.98 |
SS |
123 |
Heinie Manush |
21.95 |
OF |
124 |
Darrell Evans |
21.91 |
3B |
125 |
Richie Ashburn |
21.9 |
OF |
126 |
Ken Boyer |
21.87 |
3B |
127 |
Chet Lemon |
21.81 |
OF |
128 |
Larry Gardner |
21.77 |
3B |
129 |
Dave Winfield |
21.76 |
OF |
130 |
Ron Cey |
21.74 |
3B |
131 |
Jose Canseco |
21.68 |
OF |
132 |
Joe Sewell |
21.55 |
SS |
133 |
Pee Wee Reese |
21.49 |
SS |
134 |
Cal Ripken |
21.48 |
SS |
135 |
Ed Konetchy |
21.47 |
1B |
136 |
Pie Traynor |
21.41 |
3B |
137 |
Willie Randolph |
21.37 |
2B |
138 |
Greg Luzinski |
21.3 |
OF |
139 |
Dwight Evans |
21.28 |
OF |
140 |
Willie Davis |
21.24 |
OF |
141 |
Toby Harrah |
21.22 |
3B |
142 |
Dave Bancroft |
21.14 |
SS |
143 |
Max Carey |
21.12 |
OF |
144 |
Ted Simmons |
21.08 |
C |
145 |
Dale Murphy |
21.07 |
OF |
146 |
Gil Hodges |
21.03 |
1B |
147 |
Mark Grace |
21.02 |
1B |
148 |
Bid McPhee |
20.99 |
2B |
149 |
George Sisler |
20.99 |
1B |
150 |
Bobby Bonilla |
20.96 |
3B |
151 |
Ken Griffey Sr. |
20.85 |
OF |
152 |
Tony Perez |
20.82 |
1B |
153 |
Dave Parker |
20.81 |
OF |
154 |
Brian Downing |
20.74 |
DH |
155 |
Clyde |
20.74 |
OF |
156 |
Ernie Banks |
20.7 |
1B |
157 |
Sam Rice |
20.68 |
OF |
158 |
Ron Fairly |
20.66 |
1B |
159 |
Rusty Staub |
20.66 |
OF |
160 |
Tony Fernandez |
20.64 |
SS |
161 |
Del Pratt |
20.61 |
2B |
162 |
Freddy Lindstrom |
20.49 |
3B |
163 |
Freddy Lindstrom |
20.49 |
3B |
164 |
Andre Dawson |
20.46 |
OF |
165 |
Buddy Myer |
20.42 |
2B |
166 |
Gary Matthews |
20.34 |
OF |
167 |
Graig Nettles |
20.34 |
3B |
168 |
Harry Hooper |
20.3 |
OF |
169 |
Al Oliver |
20.21 |
OF |
170 |
Herman Long |
20.21 |
SS |
171 |
Wally Joyner |
20.2 |
1B |
172 |
Jim Rice |
20.17 |
OF |
173 |
Paul O'Neill |
20.15 |
OF |
174 |
Lou Brock |
20.07 |
OF |
175 |
Brett Butler |
20.03 |
OF |
176 |
Jim Bottomley |
20.01 |
1B |
177 |
Carney Lansford |
20 |
3B |
178 |
Vada Pinson |
20 |
OF |
179 |
Phil Cavarretta |
19.94 |
1B |
180 |
Dusty Baker |
19.79 |
OF |
181 |
Felipe Alou |
19.75 |
OF |
182 |
Maury Wills |
19.74 |
SS |
183 |
Cy Williams |
19.73 |
OF |
184 |
George Kell |
19.71 |
3B |
185 |
Cecil Cooper |
19.67 |
1B |
186 |
Dummy Hoy |
19.64 |
OF |
187 |
Jake Beckley |
19.64 |
1B |
188 |
George Hendrick |
19.63 |
OF |
189 |
Brooks Robinson |
19.58 |
3B |
190 |
Ozzie Smith |
19.54 |
SS |
191 |
Jake Daubert |
19.5 |
1B |
192 |
Mickey Vernon |
19.5 |
1B |
193 |
Buddy |
19.49 |
3B |
194 |
Julio Franco |
19.25 |
SS |
195 |
Jim Gilliam |
19.24 |
2B |
196 |
Steve Garvey |
19.1 |
1B |
197 |
Joe Judge |
19.08 |
1B |
198 |
Lloyd Waner |
19.07 |
OF |
199 |
Arlie Latham |
19.06 |
3B |
200 |
Tony Phillips |
19.06 |
OF |
201 |
Del Ennis |
19.02 |
OF |
202 |
Steve Finley |
19 |
OF |
203 |
Harvey Kuenn |
18.97 |
OF |
204 |
Nellie Fox |
18.91 |
2B |
205 |
Eddie Yost |
18.86 |
3B |
206 |
Bert Campaneris |
18.85 |
SS |
207 |
Ed McKean |
18.79 |
SS |
208 |
Jay Bell |
18.78 |
SS |
209 |
Willie Horton |
18.75 |
OF |
210 |
Al Dark |
18.71 |
SS |
211 |
Dick Bartell |
18.68 |
SS |
212 |
Wally Moses |
18.61 |
OF |
213 |
Andres Galarraga |
18.55 |
1B |
214 |
Lave Cross |
18.53 |
3B |
215 |
Hal McRae |
18.5 |
DH |
216 |
Chili |
18.48 |
OF |
217 |
Roger Peckinpaugh |
18.47 |
SS |
218 |
Willie Wilson |
18.47 |
OF |
219 |
Red Schoendienst |
18.41 |
2B |
220 |
Fred Tenney |
18.32 |
1B |
221 |
Brady Anderson |
18.16 |
OF |
222 |
Dave Concepcion |
18.08 |
SS |
223 |
Don Baylor |
18.06 |
DH |
224 |
Tim Wallach |
18.04 |
3B |
225 |
Harold Baines |
17.94 |
DH |
226 |
Jose Cardenal |
17.85 |
OF |
227 |
Dick Groat |
17.83 |
SS |
228 |
Lee May |
17.74 |
1B |
229 |
Willie McGee |
17.73 |
OF |
230 |
Rabbit Maranville |
17.39 |
SS |
231 |
Tommy Davis |
17.33 |
OF |
232 |
Joe Kuhel |
17.31 |
1B |
233 |
Marty McManus |
17.31 |
2B |
234 |
Chris Chambliss |
17.24 |
1B |
235 |
Tom Brown |
17.24 |
OF |
236 |
Donie Bush |
17.21 |
SS |
237 |
Terry Pendleton |
17.14 |
3B |
238 |
Stuffy McInnis |
17.06 |
1B |
239 |
Jimmy Dykes |
17 |
3B |
240 |
Joe Carter |
16.99 |
OF |
241 |
Bill Mazeroski |
16.94 |
2B |
242 |
George Scott |
16.93 |
1B |
243 |
Luis Aparicio |
16.91 |
SS |
244 |
Wally Pipp |
16.82 |
1B |
245 |
Steve Sax |
16.81 |
2B |
246 |
B.J. Surhoff |
16.75 |
OF |
247 |
Mike Higgins |
16.73 |
3B |
248 |
Bob Boone |
16.7 |
C |
249 |
|
16.6 |
OF |
250 |
Garry Templeton |
16.5 |
SS |
251 |
Gary Gaetti |
16.44 |
3B |
252 |
Chris Speier |
16.37 |
SS |
253 |
Frank White |
16.15 |
2B |
254 |
Patsy Donovan |
15.96 |
OF |
255 |
Bobby Lowe |
15.72 |
2B |
256 |
Tony Taylor |
15.09 |
2B |
257 |
Bill Russell |
14.95 |
SS |
258 |
Tommy Corcoran |
14.79 |
SS |
259 |
Charlie Grimm |
14.67 |
1B |
260 |
Bill Buckner |
14.6 |
1B |
261 |
Roy McMillan |
14.56 |
SS |
262 |
Doc Cramer |
14.29 |
OF |
263 |
Lance Parrish |
12.88 |
C |
264 |
Larry Bowa |
12.74 |
SS |
265 |
Don Kessinger |
12.08 |
SS |