Ranking Hitters by Their Performance Above a .600 Offensive Winning Percentage

by Cyril Morong

Email

Click here to see my sabermetric blog called Cybermetrics

On this list, hitters are ranked by how often and by how much they exceeded a .600 offensive winning percentage (OWP). OWP is a stat created by Bill James. It tells you what team’s winning percentage would have been if every hitter in a lineup was identical to one particular guy and your team gave up an average number of runs. I used data from the Lee Sinins Sabermetric Encyclopedia, so OWP is also park adjusted.

A player was given points for going above a .600 OWP for a season depending upon how many plate appearances (PA) he had. So if a player had 600 PA and a .700 OWP, he got 60 points (or 600*(.700-.600)). I only counted data from seasons with at least 100 PAs.

The idea here is to combine quantity and quality. A player could have a high career OWP, but if his career was short, then he may not have played long enough to see his OWP decline. But if a player did have a short career and he exceeded a .600 OWP fairly often and by a wide margin, he would still rank high. No one gets penalized for playing a long career.

I chose .600 since that is probably close to the winning percentage league champions usually have.

Now some positions are not known for hitting, so I also found a historical average OWP for each position and added .100 to it. These historical averages were

1B .544

2B .444

SS .409

3B .475

LF .549

CF .518

RF .537

C .416

SS .409

DH .528

If everyone on a team went .100 over their positional average, you should have about a .600 OWP. So a catcher who had a .616 OWP for 600 PA would get 60 points since .616 is .100 over .516 which in turn is .100 over the position average.

The players are arranged below by position. The left side is how they ranked using the positional adjustment. After all the positions are listed, the top 250 amongst all players are listed.

1B Rank	Player-Positional Scale	Pts	Player-.600 Scale	Pts
1	Lou Gehrig	1399.21	Lou Gehrig	1804.77
2	Dan Brouthers	922.10	Jimmie Foxx	1251.94
3	Jimmie Foxx	911.02	Dan Brouthers	1233.09
4	Johnny Mize	742.54	Johnny Mize	1018.02
5	Mark McGwire	734.67	Mark McGwire	1001.57
6	Roger Connor	667.95	Roger Connor	940.13
7	Frank Thomas	659.43	Jeff Bagwell	921.75
8	Willie McCovey	638.97	Willie McCovey	880.97
9	Jeff Bagwell	572.96	Frank Thomas	839.50
10	Cap Anson	492.82	Cap Anson	739.42
11	Jason Giambi	475.78	Eddie Murray	699.03
12	Jim Thome	436.10	Jim Thome	658.30
13	Will Clark	403.13	Jason Giambi	654.69
14	Frank Chance	398.86	Will Clark	637.14
15	Stan Musial	398.48	Fred McGriff	637.09
16	Fred McGriff	391.89	Stan Musial	596.04
17	Eddie Murray	388.41	George Sisler	562.53
18	George Sisler	385.20	Frank Chance	557.78
19	Hank Greenberg	371.90	Dolph Camilli	553.36
20	Dolph Camilli	359.49	Hank Greenberg	550.53
21	Jack Fournier	338.13	Bill Terry	536.07
22	Carlos Delgado	332.05	Rafael Palmeiro	532.92
23	Todd Helton	331.12	Carlos Delgado	524.86
24	Bill Terry	285.27	Jack Fournier	512.12
25	Norm Cash	264.06	Norm Cash	508.69
2B Rank	Player-Positional Scale	Pts	Player-.600 Scale	Pts
1	Eddie Collins	1834.30	Rogers Hornsby	1406.07
2	Rogers Hornsby	1787.26	Eddie Collins	1229.53
3	Nap Lajoie	1620.87	Nap Lajoie	1177.97
4	Joe Morgan	1512.01	Joe Morgan	983.52
5	Charlie Gehringer	917.25	Charlie Gehringer	477.51
6	Craig Biggio	712.59	Craig Biggio	388.33
7	Larry Doyle	667.20	Roberto Alomar	379.06
8	Roberto Alomar	663.10	Larry Doyle	351.29
9	Lou Whitaker	589.64	Rod Carew	324.74
10	Bobby Grich	569.91	Jackie Robinson	321.10
11	Cupid Childs	567.32	Cupid Childs	309.50
12	Rod Carew	506.78	Bobby Grich	301.23
13	Ryne Sandberg	500.29	Fred Dunlap	281.91
14	Jackie Robinson	493.55	Lou Whitaker	251.35
15	Jeff Kent	450.79	Ryne Sandberg	250.64
16	Fred Dunlap	445.40	Jeff Kent	242.42
17	Tony Lazzeri	442.90	Tony Lazzeri	209.08
18	Joe Gordon	382.36	Joe Gordon	171.93
19	Chuck Knoblauch	376.09	Chuck Knoblauch	168.08
20	Billy Herman	349.39	Billy Herman	155.59
21	Eddie Stanky	337.51	Tom Daly	155.29
22	Tom Daly	320.43	Johnny Evers	153.41
23	Johnny Evers	313.98	Eddie Stanky	143.44
24	Frankie Frisch	300.77	Hardy Richardson	142.20
25	Hardy Richardson	297.71	Julio Franco	134.88
SS Rank	Player-Positional Scale	Pts	Player-.600 Scale	Pts
1	Honus Wagner	2178.63	Honus Wagner	1394.66
2	Arky Vaughan	1275.63	Arky Vaughan	670.25
3	Alex Rodriguez	1012.44	Alex Rodriguez	526.61
4	Barry Larkin	877.86	Hughie Jennings	335.71
5	Luke Appling	734.41	Barry Larkin	329.32
6	Alan Trammell	713.69	Alan Trammell	318.49
7	Joe Cronin	703.49	Lou Boudreau	284.90
8	Derek Jeter	693.30	Ernie Banks	279.56
9	Lou Boudreau	679.51	Cal Ripken	259.44
10	Bill Dahlen	679.31	Jack Glasscock	256.38
11	Ernie Banks	677.43	Derek Jeter	255.06
12	Cal Ripken	669.51	Robin Yount	253.46
13	George Davis	638.08	Nomar Garciaparra	252.76
14	Jack Glasscock	637.74	Luke Appling	203.41
15	Nomar Garciaparra	631.25	George Davis	194.61
16	Hughie Jennings	608.90	Joe Cronin	191.79
17	Robin Yount	546.60	Bill Dahlen	161.25
18	Vern Stephens	486.40	Vern Stephens	139.98
19	Ed McKean	468.32	Frank Fennelly	134.21
20	Jim Fregosi	446.56	Ed McKean	123.23
21	Joe Sewell	368.49	Jim Fregosi	116.29
22	Bobby Wallace	356.58	Rogers Hornsby	114.30
23	Eddie Joost	327.09	Candy Nelson	113.31
24	Pee Wee Reese	285.45	Eddie Joost	101.52
25	Dave Bancroft	284.33	Joe Sewell	91.92
3B Rank	Player-Positional Scale	Pts	Player-.600 Scale	Pts
1	Eddie Mathews	1197.46	Eddie Mathews	1003.44
2	Mike Schmidt	1088.85	Mike Schmidt	881.08
3	Wade Boggs	996.03	Wade Boggs	814.13
4	George Brett	887.64	George Brett	722.70
5	John McGraw	648.63	John McGraw	560.08
6	Home Run Baker	606.86	Home Run Baker	487.71
7	Stan Hack	567.93	Dick Allen	459.13
8	Dick Allen	539.20	Stan Hack	443.21
9	Ron Santo	511.03	Chipper Jones	404.83
10	Chipper Jones	505.01	Ron Santo	394.03
11	Denny Lyons	442.88	Bill Joyce	351.75
12	Al Rosen	428.34	Al Rosen	347.54
13	Bill Joyce	424.52	Denny Lyons	333.47
14	Bob Elliott	418.23	Harmon Killebrew	308.24
15	Sal Bando	413.89	Sal Bando	298.91
16	Harmon Killebrew	375.69	Bob Elliott	297.76
17	Heine Groh	353.04	Heine Groh	263.03
18	Ken Caminiti	349.67	Ken Caminiti	257.63
19	Scott Rolen	346.30	Scott Rolen	226.87
20	Ron Cey	302.44	Ron Cey	214.84
21	Eddie Yost	302.35	Jim Thome	208.61
22	Howard Johnson	272.36	Howard Johnson	197.91
23	Bill Madlock	250.30	Ezra Sutton	186.19
24	Jim Thome	243.23	Eddie Yost	186.15
25	Ezra Sutton	229.89	George Davis	174.65
LF Rank	Player-Positional Scale	Pts	Player-.600 Scale	Pts
1	Barry Bonds	1704.13	Barry Bonds	2208.59
2	Ted Williams	1649.36	Ted Williams	2079.05
3	Ed Delahanty	838.01	Ed Delahanty	1111.38
4	Rickey Henderson	591.22	Rickey Henderson	996.47
5	Babe Ruth	583.07	Jesse Burkett	886.34
6	Jesse Burkett	547.85	Fred Clarke	729.28
7	Willie Stargell	392.73	Babe Ruth	718.40
8	Charlie Keller	379.22	Tim Raines	617.39
9	Fred Clarke	370.27	Willie Stargell	578.24
10	Tim Raines	355.95	Sherry Magee	575.08
11	Sherry Magee	352.49	Ralph Kiner	556.86
12	Ralph Kiner	339.29	Zack Wheat	556.00
13	Joe Kelley	332.92	Joe Kelley	536.58
14	Albert Belle	295.94	Charlie Keller	522.94
15	Stan Musial	289.92	Goose Goslin	475.34
16	Al Simmons	278.20	Albert Belle	453.87
17	Tip O'Neill	277.19	Carl Yastrzemski	432.91
18	Carl Yastrzemski	274.20	Al Simmons	432.54
19	Zack Wheat	255.69	Tip O'Neill	418.40
20	George Stone	251.90	Frank Howard	416.80
21	Joe Jackson	238.85	Joe Medwick	412.11
22	Billy Hamilton	229.70	Stan Musial	409.49
23	Topsy Hartsel	228.06	Topsy Hartsel	409.25
24	Goose Goslin	227.64	Bob Johnson	395.31
25	Jimmy Sheckard	221.01	Jimmy Sheckard	386.43
CF Rank	Player-Positional Scale	Pts	Player-.600 Scale	Pts
1	Ty Cobb	1591.91	Ty Cobb	1770.12
2	Mickey Mantle	1551.31	Tris Speaker	1725.88
3	Tris Speaker	1516.52	Mickey Mantle	1695.09
4	Willie Mays	1397.12	Willie Mays	1597.22
5	Joe DiMaggio	864.05	Joe DiMaggio	981.91
6	Billy Hamilton	579.64	Ken Griffey Jr.	691.51
7	Ken Griffey Jr.	561.16	Billy Hamilton	661.12
8	Duke Snider	416.99	Larry Doby	507.00
9	Jimmy Wynn	404.96	Duke Snider	499.09
10	Larry Doby	396.39	Jimmy Wynn	485.92
11	Hack Wilson	387.52	Jim Edmonds	462.88
12	Jim Edmonds	385.42	Hack Wilson	454.03
13	George Gore	353.59	Bernie Williams	444.36
14	Bernie Williams	350.13	Edd Roush	440.38
15	Edd Roush	339.74	George Gore	435.62
16	Fred Lynn	304.41	Earl Averill	385.64
17	Earl Averill	292.33	Fred Lynn	380.40
18	Pete Browning	287.56	Pete Browning	330.60
19	Jake Stenzel	270.16	Ginger Beaumont	329.84
20	Ginger Beaumont	268.10	Paul Hines	329.39
21	Paul Hines	263.00	Roy Thomas	326.98
22	Lenny Dykstra	248.96	Richie Ashburn	317.77
23	Bobby Murcer	238.72	Jake Stenzel	311.65
24	Jimmy Ryan	237.93	Lenny Dykstra	310.04
25	Roy Thomas	233.21	Wally Berger	301.50
RF Rank	Player-Positional Scale	Pts	Player-.600 Scale	Pts
1	Babe Ruth	1520.29	Babe Ruth	1792.50
2	Mel Ott	1043.22	Mel Ott	1405.16
3	Hank Aaron	968.27	Hank Aaron	1336.38
4	Frank Robinson	713.07	Frank Robinson	954.13
5	Harry Heilmann	646.06	Harry Heilmann	878.59
6	Elmer Flick	571.14	Reggie Jackson	804.74
7	Stan Musial	569.61	Elmer Flick	761.08
8	Reggie Jackson	555.87	Paul Waner	757.50
9	Joe Jackson	470.39	Stan Musial	698.67
10	Paul Waner	467.08	Sam Crawford	695.61
11	Sam Crawford	461.32	Roberto Clemente	684.20
12	Roberto Clemente	449.64	Al Kaline	620.25
13	Gary Sheffield	400.08	Larry Walker	594.77
14	Al Kaline	396.65	Tony Gwynn	587.71
15	Larry Walker	383.61	Joe Jackson	572.59
16	Ken Singleton	374.66	Gary Sheffield	554.31
17	Tony Gwynn	371.21	Sam Thompson	544.56
18	Ty Cobb	364.36	Ken Singleton	532.01
19	Sam Thompson	362.83	Mike Tiernan	500.69
20	Gavvy Cravath	360.68	Sammy Sosa	491.49
21	Sammy Sosa	349.54	Willie Keeler	484.24
22	Mike Tiernan	343.05	Gavvy Cravath	478.93
23	Manny Ramirez	316.06	Bobby Abreu	472.04
24	Bobby Abreu	297.11	Ty Cobb	457.08
25	Dave Winfield	285.99	Manny Ramirez	453.10
OF Rank	Player-Positional Scale	Pts	Player-.600 Scale	Pts
1	Babe Ruth	2103.36	Babe Ruth	2510.90
2	Ty Cobb	1956.27	Ty Cobb	2227.20
3	Ted Williams	1716.39	Barry Bonds	2208.59
4	Barry Bonds	1704.13	Ted Williams	2171.12
5	Mickey Mantle	1552.18	Tris Speaker	1725.88
6	Tris Speaker	1516.52	Mickey Mantle	1724.23
7	Willie Mays	1397.12	Willie Mays	1597.22
8	Hank Aaron	1105.07	Hank Aaron	1514.09
9	Mel Ott	1102.96	Mel Ott	1475.34
10	Stan Musial	978.50	Stan Musial	1239.30
11	Ed Delahanty	879.88	Rickey Henderson	1205.61
12	Joe DiMaggio	864.05	Ed Delahanty	1162.56
13	Billy Hamilton	830.92	Frank Robinson	1059.11
14	Rickey Henderson	768.05	Billy Hamilton	1027.39
15	Frank Robinson	723.72	Joe DiMaggio	1009.97
16	Joe Jackson	709.24	Sam Crawford	938.97
17	Sam Crawford	669.62	Joe Jackson	935.21
18	Elmer Flick	661.44	Jesse Burkett	919.55
19	Harry Heilmann	646.06	Reggie Jackson	908.74
20	Reggie Jackson	638.02	Harry Heilmann	878.59
21	Gary Sheffield	571.54	Elmer Flick	863.98
22	Jesse Burkett	564.89	Gary Sheffield	818.52
23	Ken Griffey Jr.	561.16	Al Kaline	802.27
24	Al Kaline	549.13	Paul Waner	757.50
25	Manny Ramirez	495.63	Tim Raines	730.12
C Rank	Player-Positional Scale	Pts	Player-.600 Scale	Pts
1	Mike Piazza	1091.39	Mike Piazza	601.21
2	Yogi Berra	881.15	Bill Dickey	412.07
3	Bill Dickey	875.18	Mickey Cochrane	326.31
4	Mickey Cochrane	795.92	Yogi Berra	321.63
5	Carlton Fisk	744.43	Carlton Fisk	301.47
6	Johnny Bench	727.19	Buck Ewing	268.16
7	Gabby Hartnett	662.58	Fred Carroll	266.11
8	Ted Simmons	657.05	Gene Tenace	265.57
9	Gary Carter	561.10	Johnny Bench	259.78
10	Wally Schang	533.70	Roger Bresnahan	255.04
11	Ernie Lombardi	517.26	Gabby Hartnett	228.34
12	Gene Tenace	507.49	Ted Simmons	224.74
13	Roger Bresnahan	498.57	Roy Campanella	221.77
14	Buck Ewing	497.48	Ernie Lombardi	219.08
15	Fred Carroll	476.74	Wally Schang	195.91
16	Roy Campanella	459.87	Gary Carter	183.62
17	Joe Torre	434.06	Mike Grady	176.43
18	Darrell Porter	409.79	Bill Freehan	174.02
19	Bill Freehan	399.34	Art Wilson	173.75
20	Jason Kendall	384.19	Darren Daulton	163.31
21	Charlie Bennett	364.74	Charlie Bennett	157.41
22	Mickey Tettleton	364.12	Jack Clements	148.37
23	Mike Grady	362.50	Joe Torre	144.93
24	Ivan Rodriguez	358.52	Mickey Tettleton	134.05
25	Thurman Munson	354.15	Todd Hundley	125.75
DH Rank	Player-Positional Scale	Pts	Player-.600 Scale	Pts
1	Edgar Martinez	665.92	Edgar Martinez	819.55
2	Paul Molitor	316.32	Paul Molitor	406.79
3	Frank Thomas	286.31	Frank Thomas	380.15
4	Oscar Gamble	187.54	Hal McRae	260.31
5	Hal McRae	166.60	Oscar Gamble	240.71
6	Harold Baines	105.88	Harold Baines	201.80
7	Chili Davis	105.05	Chili Davis	164.88
8	Ken Phelps	94.21	Brian Downing	145.09
9	Frank Robinson	87.08	Ken Phelps	130.05
10	Rafael Palmeiro	75.49	Frank Robinson	125.11
11	Manny Ramirez	73.16	Rico Carty	110.69
12	Brian Downing	69.48	Cliff Johnson	102.69
13	Ron Blomberg	67.94	David Ortiz	101.25
14	Cliff Johnson	67.28	Rafael Palmeiro	94.36
15	David Ortiz	65.94	Jose Canseco	90.63
16	Travis Hafner	65.32	Manny Ramirez	90.52
17	Rico Carty	64.29	Ron Blomberg	89.16
18	John Grubb	61.32	Greg Luzinski	82.91
19	Tim Salmon	53.20	Travis Hafner	81.37
20	John Jaha	43.89	John Grubb	74.17
21	Dave Winfield	41.54	Tim Salmon	69.05
22	Jose Canseco	38.74	Don Baylor	63.32
23	Erubiel Durazo	36.41	Dave Winfield	60.30
24	Greg Luzinski	34.75	John Jaha	59.85
25	Don Baylor	30.98	Erubiel Durazo	52.60
Rank	Player-Positional Scale	Pts	Player-.600 Scale	Pts
1	Honus Wagner	2358.02	Babe Ruth	2510.90
2	Rogers Hornsby	2159.93	Ty Cobb	2227.20
3	Babe Ruth	2103.36	Barry Bonds	2208.59
4	Ty Cobb	1956.27	Ted Williams	2171.12
5	Eddie Collins	1834.30	Stan Musial	1835.34
6	Ted Williams	1716.39	Mickey Mantle	1833.25
7	Barry Bonds	1704.13	Lou Gehrig	1804.77
8	Nap Lajoie	1686.93	Tris Speaker	1725.88
9	Mickey Mantle	1612.80	Hank Aaron	1671.78
10	Tris Speaker	1516.52	Rogers Hornsby	1654.56
11	Joe Morgan	1512.01	Mel Ott	1610.30
12	Lou Gehrig	1399.21	Willie Mays	1597.22
13	Willie Mays	1397.12	Honus Wagner	1584.51
14	Stan Musial	1376.99	Frank Robinson	1324.79
15	Arky Vaughan	1283.28	Jimmie Foxx	1298.29
16	Mel Ott	1254.23	Nap Lajoie	1284.95
17	Hank Aaron	1213.62	Dan Brouthers	1276.87
18	Eddie Mathews	1197.46	Eddie Collins	1229.53
19	Mike Schmidt	1121.75	Frank Thomas	1225.22
20	Mike Piazza	1091.39	Rickey Henderson	1205.61
21	Alex Rodriguez	1067.58	Ed Delahanty	1162.56
22	Wade Boggs	996.03	Roger Connor	1042.64
23	George Brett	973.79	Billy Hamilton	1027.39
24	Jimmie Foxx	969.20	Johnny Mize	1018.02
25	Dan Brouthers	951.76	Joe DiMaggio	1009.97
26	Frank Thomas	945.73	Eddie Mathews	1003.44
27	Charlie Gehringer	917.25	Mark McGwire	1001.57
28	Frank Robinson	899.10	Willie McCovey	992.03
29	Edgar Martinez	892.05	Edgar Martinez	990.91
30	Ed Delahanty	883.18	Joe Morgan	983.52
31	Yogi Berra	881.15	Mike Schmidt	942.35
32	Barry Larkin	877.86	Sam Crawford	938.97
33	Bill Dickey	875.18	Joe Jackson	935.21
34	George Davis	867.73	Harry Heilmann	923.14
35	Joe DiMaggio	864.05	Jeff Bagwell	921.75
36	Billy Hamilton	830.92	Jesse Burkett	919.55
37	Dick Allen	818.02	Reggie Jackson	908.74
38	Roger Connor	808.13	George Brett	892.26
39	Mickey Cochrane	795.92	Gary Sheffield	890.15
40	Craig Biggio	781.56	Dick Allen	875.88
41	Rickey Henderson	768.05	Jim Thome	866.91
42	Carlton Fisk	744.43	Elmer Flick	863.98
43	John McGraw	743.26	Cap Anson	829.07
44	Johnny Mize	742.54	Wade Boggs	828.99
45	Luke Appling	740.35	Willie Stargell	816.39
46	Rod Carew	740.33	Manny Ramirez	814.34
47	Mark McGwire	734.67	Al Kaline	802.27
48	Johnny Bench	729.54	Harmon Killebrew	765.47
49	Alan Trammell	713.69	Pete Browning	757.91
50	Joe Jackson	709.24	Paul Waner	757.50
51	Willie McCovey	706.52	Tim Raines	730.12
52	Paul Molitor	705.16	Fred Clarke	729.28
53	Joe Cronin	703.49	Eddie Murray	727.83
54	Derek Jeter	693.30	Rod Carew	716.83
55	Cal Ripken	689.69	Hank Greenberg	705.73
56	Lou Boudreau	679.51	Ken Griffey Jr.	691.51
57	Jim Thome	679.34	Arky Vaughan	685.40
58	Bill Dahlen	679.31	Roberto Clemente	684.20
59	Gary Sheffield	678.56	Pete Rose	672.44
60	Robin Yount	678.37	Carl Yastrzemski	665.57
61	Ernie Banks	677.43	Charlie Keller	662.03
62	Sam Crawford	669.62	Jason Giambi	654.69
63	Larry Doyle	667.20	Fred McGriff	653.82
64	Harry Heilmann	664.47	Al Simmons	647.31
65	Roberto Alomar	663.10	Paul Molitor	646.98
66	Gabby Hartnett	662.58	Will Clark	637.14
67	Elmer Flick	661.44	Sherry Magee	635.60
68	Pete Browning	661.15	Rafael Palmeiro	630.42
69	Bobby Grich	657.30	Tony Gwynn	627.09
70	Ted Simmons	657.05	Joe Kelley	623.50
71	Reggie Jackson	638.02	King Kelly	606.64
72	Jack Glasscock	637.74	Mike Tiernan	601.74
73	Nomar Garciaparra	631.25	Mike Piazza	601.21
74	King Kelly	624.55	Larry Walker	594.77
75	Roger Bresnahan	619.84	John McGraw	592.92
76	Harmon Killebrew	616.99	Duke Snider	572.89
77	Hughie Jennings	608.90	Frank Chance	572.81
78	Home Run Baker	606.86	Alex Rodriguez	564.30
79	Chipper Jones	594.75	Ken Singleton	563.32
80	Lou Whitaker	589.64	George Sisler	562.53
81	Gene Tenace	587.72	Chipper Jones	559.15
82	Joe Torre	584.66	Ralph Kiner	556.86
83	Cap Anson	583.67	Zack Wheat	556.00
84	Buck Ewing	582.67	Dolph Camilli	553.36
85	Jeff Bagwell	572.96	Sam Thompson	544.56
86	Manny Ramirez	568.79	Jack Clark	542.25
87	Stan Hack	567.93	Bill Terry	536.07
88	Cupid Childs	567.32	Dave Winfield	535.00
89	Jesse Burkett	564.89	Jimmy Wynn	532.86
90	Ken Griffey Jr.	561.16	Carlos Delgado	524.86
91	Gary Carter	561.10	Harry Stovey	518.98
92	Wally Schang	554.90	Jack Fournier	512.12
93	Al Kaline	549.13	Norm Cash	508.69
94	Pete Rose	544.47	Jim O'Rourke	507.56
95	Jackie Robinson	518.87	Larry Doby	507.00
96	Ernie Lombardi	517.26	Chuck Klein	506.95
97	Willie Stargell	516.99	Albert Belle	506.58
98	Ron Santo	511.03	Pedro Guerrero	506.12
99	Ryne Sandberg	500.29	Gavvy Cravath	504.11
100	Vern Stephens	486.40	Reggie Smith	502.95
101	Hank Greenberg	478.98	Brian Giles	501.31
102	Charlie Keller	477.65	Sammy Sosa	491.49
103	Fred Carroll	476.74	Hack Wilson	490.14
104	Jason Giambi	475.78	Frank Howard	489.47
105	Ed McKean	468.32	Home Run Baker	487.71
106	Paul Waner	467.08	Willie Keeler	484.24
107	Al Simmons	460.60	Todd Helton	482.74
108	Roy Campanella	459.87	Babe Herman	481.94
109	Duke Snider	457.60	Keith Hernandez	479.13
110	Tim Raines	455.75	Charlie Gehringer	477.51
111	Toby Harrah	454.66	Goose Goslin	475.34
112	Tony Lazzeri	451.48	George Gore	473.46
113	Jeff Kent	450.79	Bobby Abreu	472.04
114	Roberto Clemente	449.64	Boog Powell	471.28
115	Bill Joyce	449.28	Jim Edmonds	462.88
116	Jim Fregosi	449.15	John Olerud	456.82
117	Fred Dunlap	445.40	Jeff Heath	456.74
118	Denny Lyons	442.88	Mike Donlin	455.23
119	Al Rosen	428.34	Billy Williams	453.60
120	Jimmy Wynn	427.78	Bob Johnson	452.70
121	Mike Tiernan	423.81	Augie Galan	449.56
122	Bob Elliott	422.71	Bernie Williams	444.36
123	Frank Chance	421.83	Stan Hack	443.21
124	Pedro Guerrero	421.11	Edd Roush	440.38
125	Carl Yastrzemski	419.65	Orlando Cepeda	435.40
126	Sal Bando	413.89	Robin Yount	433.90
127	Darrell Porter	409.79	Enos Slaughter	433.58
128	Eddie Murray	403.77	Albert Pujols	429.85
129	Hack Wilson	403.69	Bill Nicholson	421.38
130	Will Clark	403.13	Joe Medwick	420.07
131	Joe Kelley	401.88	Gene Tenace	418.79
132	Bill Freehan	399.34	Tip O'Neill	418.40
133	Fred McGriff	398.66	Darryl Strawberry	414.51
134	Tony Gwynn	398.37	Bill Dickey	412.07
135	Larry Doby	396.39	Don Mattingly	411.21
136	Jim O'Rourke	389.50	Paul Hines	409.40
137	Heine Groh	385.43	Rusty Staub	409.31
138	Jim Edmonds	385.42	Topsy Hartsel	409.25
139	George Sisler	385.20	Dwight Evans	408.59
140	Jason Kendall	384.19	Charley Jones	406.68
141	Larry Walker	383.61	Bill Joyce	403.74
142	Joe Gordon	382.36	Jackie Robinson	397.33
143	Sherry Magee	381.15	Fred Lynn	395.40
144	Chuck Knoblauch	376.09	Roger Bresnahan	394.90
145	Ken Singleton	374.66	Ron Santo	394.03
146	Bobby Wallace	373.98	Tim Salmon	392.17
147	Hardy Richardson	371.17	Jimmy Sheckard	391.98
148	Fred Clarke	370.27	Minnie Minoso	389.67
149	Gavvy Cravath	369.84	Craig Biggio	388.33
150	Joe Sewell	368.49	George Van Haltren	388.16
151	George Gore	367.96	Vladimir Guerrero	386.95
152	Charlie Bennett	364.74	Earl Averill	385.64
153	Mickey Tettleton	364.12	George Stone	383.22
154	Frankie Frisch	364.09	Jose Canseco	381.33
155	Sam Thompson	362.83	Elmer Smith	379.97
156	Mike Grady	362.50	Roberto Alomar	379.06
157	Dolph Camilli	359.49	Buck Ewing	375.11
158	Ivan Rodriguez	358.52	George Davis	369.26
159	Tom Daly	358.29	Jimmy Ryan	367.70
160	Brian Giles	354.20	Jose Cruz	366.55
161	Thurman Munson	354.15	Lance Berkman	363.99
162	Jack Clements	352.88	Wally Berger	363.48
163	Smoky Burgess	350.97	Benny Kauff	363.38
164	Bernie Williams	350.13	Jim Bottomley	362.19
165	Ken Caminiti	349.67	Dave Orr	360.77
166	Albert Pujols	349.66	Roy White	360.74
167	Sammy Sosa	349.54	Rico Carty	360.72
168	Darren Daulton	349.39	Kiki Cuyler	358.19
169	Billy Herman	349.39	Tony Oliva	355.10
170	Scott Rolen	346.30	Mo Vaughn	353.71
171	Bill Madlock	342.43	Lefty O'Doul	353.42
172	Jack Clark	339.86	Roy Cullenbine	353.32
173	Edd Roush	339.74	Ross Youngs	352.07
174	Ralph Kiner	339.29	Larry Doyle	351.29
175	Jack Fournier	338.13	Rocky Colavito	350.84
176	Eddie Stanky	337.51	Gene Woodling	349.96
177	Dave Winfield	337.21	Bobby Bonds	348.55
178	Dick McAuliffe	337.19	Greg Luzinski	347.70
179	Paul Hines	332.57	Al Rosen	347.54
180	Carlos Delgado	332.05	Hugh Duffy	345.84
181	Todd Helton	331.12	George Foster	345.05
182	Rafael Palmeiro	328.64	Dale Murphy	343.67
183	Eddie Joost	327.09	Kevin Mitchell	342.85
184	Mike Donlin	325.97	Heinie Manush	342.78
185	Reggie Smith	323.78	Eric Davis	338.72
186	Albert Belle	321.94	Jake Stenzel	336.45
187	Chuck Klein	318.34	Hughie Jennings	336.25
188	Earl Averill	317.81	Earle Combs	335.07
189	Jorge Posada	317.05	Bobby Grich	334.49
190	Johnny Evers	313.98	Denny Lyons	333.47
191	Walker Cooper	313.33	Cecil Cooper	330.32
192	Harry Stovey	311.32	Ginger Beaumont	329.84
193	Julio Franco	310.63	Barry Larkin	329.32
194	Chief Meyers	307.53	Phil Cavarretta	328.70
195	Fred Lynn	304.41	Roy Thomas	326.98
196	Ron Cey	302.44	Mickey Cochrane	326.31
197	Eddie Yost	302.35	Tommy Henrich	323.21
198	Elston Howard	301.17	Riggs Stephenson	322.00
199	Bobby Abreu	297.11	Yogi Berra	321.63
200	Davey Lopes	291.96	Hal Trosky	321.20
201	Benny Kauff	286.81	Danny Tartabull	319.02
202	Augie Galan	286.64	Alan Trammell	318.49
203	Boog Powell	286.29	Joe Torre	318.16
204	Babe Herman	286.25	Richie Ashburn	317.77
205	Jake Stenzel	285.78	Dave Parker	314.41
206	Pee Wee Reese	285.45	Ken Williams	310.63
207	Bill Terry	285.27	Lenny Dykstra	310.04
208	Solly Hemus	285.02	Cupid Childs	309.50
209	Dave Bancroft	284.33	Tony Perez	308.21
210	Tony Perez	283.60	Bobby Murcer	307.68
211	Jimmy Ryan	283.27	Bob Watson	306.43
212	Frank Fennelly	282.20	Roger Maris	304.86
213	Willie Keeler	281.37	Bob Elliott	304.76
214	Jeff Heath	278.35	Oscar Gamble	304.10
215	John Romano	278.24	Carlton Fisk	301.47
216	Bobby Doerr	278.09	Ed Swartwood	301.13
217	Todd Hundley	277.88	Sal Bando	298.91
218	Tom Haller	277.64	Dixie Walker	298.67
219	Deacon White	277.59	John Mayberry	296.74
220	Bill Nicholson	277.38	Cesar Cedeno	296.62
221	Tip O'Neill	277.19	Chick Hafey	295.69
222	Javier Lopez	276.44	Ted Kluszewski	292.86
223	Jack Rowe	275.30	Oyster Burns	291.74
224	Bobby Bonilla	272.74	Kirk Gibson	291.24
225	Howard Johnson	272.36	Henry Larkin	287.21
226	Ginger Beaumont	268.10	George Burns-LF	286.35
227	Edgardo Alfonzo	268.06	Jim Rice	286.32
228	Hugh Duffy	267.86	Brian Downing	286.08
229	Jimmy Williams	267.57	John Kruk	285.79
230	Oyster Burns	266.88	Ryan Klesko	285.68
231	Norm Cash	264.06	Lou Boudreau	284.90
232	Willie Randolph	263.24	Fred Dunlap	281.91
233	Heinie Zimmerman	262.98	Mike Hargrove	280.63
234	Joe Ferguson	262.08	Ernie Banks	279.56
235	Art Wilson	261.53	Mickey Vernon	279.25
236	Bob Johnson	260.05	David Justice	279.22
237	Chris Hoiles	258.84	Bobby Veach	274.23
238	Darrell Evans	256.85	Juan Gonzalez	271.80
239	Dale Murphy	256.45	Cal Ripken	270.77
240	Zack Wheat	255.69	Johnny Bench	270.75
241	Dave Orr	254.91	Roy Sievers	268.99
242	Bubbles Hargrave	254.48	Alvin Davis	268.36
243	Darryl Strawberry	254.28	Luis Gonzalez	267.55
244	Cecil Travis	253.95	Bobby Bonilla	266.48
245	Charley Jones	253.68	Fred Carroll	266.11
246	Gil McDougald	252.95	Heine Groh	264.67
247	Ezra Sutton	252.86	Harry Davis	264.24
248	Buddy Myer	252.35	Hal McRae	260.31
249	Dick Dietz	252.28	Ken Caminiti	257.63
250	Candy Nelson	252.28	Toby Harrah	257.60

Back to Cyril Morong's Sabermetric Research