Comparing Win Shares and Total Player Rating

By Cyril Morong

cyrilmorong@sbcglobal.net

Click here to see my sabermetric blog called Cybermetrics

I have a website where I rank players in Win Shares per plate appearance. Since the new baseball Encyclopedia is out, I decided to rank that same group in Total Player Rating (TPR)per plate appearance and then compare the results. (Actually, Pete Palmer now calls it BFW or batting wins plus fieding wins)

For Win Shares (WS), I looked at everyone who had 5000 or more plate appearances (PA) through 2001 or at least 141 WS. There are 863 players. Using this same group, I calculated TPR per plate appearance. The correlation between the two is .859. The regression equation with WS as the dependent variable and TPR as the independent variable is

WS = 17.73 + 2.69*TPR

This was actually done per 648 PA. The r-squared was .739, so 73.9% of the variation in WS. The standard error is 2.25. Which players were over predicted? That is, had more WS than their TPR would predict? (or which players did Bill James rate higher than Pete Palmer did)?

The table below shows this. Benny Kauff, for example has 31.818 WS per 648 PA. TPR predicts him to have 23.061, so he his over by 8.821.

Player	TPR	WS	PRED	Diff
Benny Kauff	1.982	31.818	23.061	8.757
Patsy Dougherty	-0.608	23.695	16.094	7.601
Ty Cobb	4.238	35.788	29.130	6.658
Mickey Mantle	4.767	36.948	30.554	6.394
Honus Wagner	4.532	36.159	29.922	6.237
Larry Parrish	-0.861	21.571	15.414	6.157
Solly Hofman	-0.718	21.821	15.798	6.023
Sam Mertes	-0.052	23.333	17.591	5.742
Hugh Duffy	0.389	24.389	18.775	5.614
Paul Hines	0.438	24.245	18.909	5.337

Now the guys who are underpredicted, that is, they are rated higher by Palmer than James.

Player	TPR	WS	PRED	Diff
Ozzie Smith	2.748	19.540	25.121	-5.581
Manny Trillo	0.838	14.393	19.984	-5.591
Rick Burleson	1.927	17.229	22.913	-5.685
Tony Taylor	1.197	15.093	20.949	-5.856
Don Kessinger	0.137	12.080	18.098	-6.018
Ivan DeJesus	0.599	13.227	19.341	-6.114
Glenn Hubbard	2.556	17.712	24.604	-6.893
Bill Mazeroski	2.629	16.937	24.803	-7.867
Tim Foli	0.306	10.549	18.552	-8.003
Lance Parrish	1.845	12.882	22.693	-9.811

The top 10 players in WS are

Player	WSper648PA
Babe Ruth	39.920
Mickey Mantle	36.948
Ted Williams	36.739
Honus Wagner	36.159
Ty Cobb	35.788
Barry Bonds	34.564
Rogers Hornsby	34.332
Tris Speaker	34.051
Joe Jackson	33.482
Willie Mays	33.303

The top 10 in TPR

Player	TPRper648PA
Babe Ruth	7.874
Barry Bonds	6.087
Nap Lajoie	5.891
Rogers Hornsby	5.882
Ted Williams	5.759
Mike Schmidt	5.062
Mike Piazza	4.979
Mickey Mantle	4.767
Lou Gehrig	4.756
Honus Wagner	4.532

Bill James says that 15 WS is a run of the mill player. So I assumed that is like a TPR of zero. To make comparisons with this in mind, I looked at TPR per 690 PA. I think that might be closer to full time than 648. So I subtracted 15 from a players WS per 690 PA. Then divided by 3, since it takes 3 WS to get a win. The result is a predicted TPR. Which players had the biggest positive differential here? That is, who got rated higher by James than Palmer?

Player	DIFF
Benny Kauff	4.183
Patsy Dougherty	4.058
Ty Cobb	3.190
Mickey Mantle	3.038
Honus Wagner	3.008
Larry Parrish	3.573
Solly Hofman	3.510
Sam Mertes	3.337
Hugh Duffy	3.243
Paul Hines	3.139

Who had the biggest negative differential here?

Player	Diff
Ozzie Smith	-0.990
Manny Trillo	-0.784
Rick Burleson	-0.937
Tony Taylor	-0.917
Don Kessinger	-0.858
Ivan DeJesus	-0.943
Glenn Hubbard	-1.435
Bill Mazeroski	-1.788
Tim Foli	-1.581
Lance Parrish	-2.392

Here are all the players rankend by TPR per 648 plate appearances. Also listed are their actual Win Shares per Plate Appearance. Then their predicted WS based on the regression equation mentioned above and finally how the actcual and predicted WS differ.

Rank	Player	TPRper648PA	WSper648PA	PRED WSper648PA	Diff	POS
1	Babe Ruth	7.874	39.920	38.911	1.009	OF
2	Barry Bonds	6.087	34.564	34.103	0.461	OF
3	Nap Lajoie	5.891	30.727	33.578	-2.851	2B
4	Rogers Hornsby	5.882	34.332	33.551	0.781	2B
5	Ted Williams	5.759	36.739	33.222	3.517	OF
6	Mike Schmidt	5.062	30.075	31.347	-1.271	3B
7	Mike Piazza	4.979	31.820	31.123	0.697	C
8	Mickey Mantle	4.767	36.948	30.554	6.394	OF
9	Lou Gehrig	4.756	32.802	30.524	2.279	1B
10	Honus Wagner	4.532	36.159	29.922	6.237	SS
11	Jeff Bagwell	4.451	28.478	29.703	-1.225	1B
12	Tris Speaker	4.437	34.051	29.667	4.384	OF
13	Alex Rodriguez	4.410	28.227	29.592	-1.365	SS
14	Willie Mays	4.388	33.303	29.535	3.768	OF
15	Joe Jackson	4.362	33.482	29.463	4.019	OF
16	Fred Dunlap	4.270	25.075	29.217	-4.142	2B
17	Ty Cobb	4.238	35.788	29.130	6.658	OF
18	Bobby Grich	4.068	25.936	28.672	-2.736	2B
19	Edgar Martinez	4.055	24.054	28.637	-4.583	DH
20	Lou Boudreau	4.023	25.558	28.552	-2.993	SS
21	Frank Thomas-cws	4.014	29.022	28.528	0.494	1B
22	Gabby Hartnett	3.934	28.861	28.312	0.549	C
23	Jimmie Foxx	3.907	29.150	28.239	0.911	1B
24	Eddie Collins	3.902	30.896	28.227	2.668	2B
25	Stan Musial	3.874	30.789	28.151	2.638	OF
26	Joe DiMaggio	3.869	32.691	28.137	4.554	OF
27	Joe Morgan	3.855	29.286	28.100	1.185	2B
28	Jackie Robinson	3.831	28.703	28.035	0.668	2B
29	Hank Aaron	3.779	29.890	27.896	1.994	OF
30	Ken Griffey Jr.	3.653	26.222	27.555	-1.334	OF
31	Dan Brouthers	3.647	29.969	27.540	2.429	1B
32	Arky Vaughan	3.634	29.878	27.506	2.372	SS
33	Mickey Cochrane	3.623	28.714	27.476	1.238	C
34	Barry Larkin	3.604	26.452	27.425	-0.973	SS
35	Charlie Bennett	3.593	23.605	27.396	-3.791	C
36	Frank Robinson	3.548	28.639	27.275	1.365	OF
37	Rickey Henderson	3.543	26.337	27.261	-0.924	OF
38	Bill Dickey	3.534	28.820	27.236	1.585	C
39	Dick Allen	3.473	30.300	27.072	3.228	1B
40	Mel Ott	3.469	30.179	27.063	3.116	OF
41	Hank Greenberg	3.465	28.382	27.052	1.330	1B
42	Pete Browning	3.402	27.432	26.880	0.552	OF
43	Ivan Rodriguez	3.389	23.744	26.846	-3.102	C
44	Eddie Mathews	3.342	28.868	26.721	2.148	3B
45	Johnny Mize	3.314	29.714	26.645	3.069	1B
46	Ed Delahanty	3.289	27.405	26.576	0.829	OF
47	Home Run Baker	3.279	29.291	26.552	2.739	3B
48	Buck Ewing	3.267	27.056	26.518	0.538	C
49	Bobby Doerr	3.253	22.682	26.480	-3.799	2B
50	Roy Campanella	3.243	27.852	26.453	1.399	C
51	George Davis	3.234	25.387	26.429	-1.043	SS
52	Roy Thomas	3.223	25.624	26.399	-0.775	OF
53	Roger Connor	3.180	26.600	26.285	0.315	1B
54	Johnny Bench	3.177	26.611	26.276	0.335	C
55	Charley Jones	3.176	26.359	26.274	0.085	OF
56	Jack Glasscock	3.142	22.407	26.182	-3.775	SS
57	Ron Santo	3.124	22.345	26.134	-3.789	3B
58	Charlie Keller	3.111	30.683	26.097	4.586	OF
59	Jim Thome	3.107	24.348	26.087	-1.740	1B
60	Gene Tenace	3.085	27.093	26.028	1.065	C
61	Wade Boggs	3.083	23.772	26.024	-2.252	3B
62	Hughie Jennings	3.071	24.522	25.991	-1.469	SS
63	Bill Dahlen	3.022	24.549	25.859	-1.310	SS
64	Gary Sheffield	3.021	26.387	25.857	0.530	OF
65	Mark McGwire	3.020	28.932	25.854	3.078	1B
66	Roberto Alomar	3.017	24.959	25.845	-0.886	2B
67	Bill Joyce	3.011	24.491	25.829	-1.338	3B
68	Elmer Flick	3.003	29.422	25.808	3.615	OF
69	Yogi Berra	2.992	29.064	25.777	3.286	C
70	Manny Ramirez	2.982	26.387	25.752	0.635	OF
71	Sam Thompson	2.936	23.491	25.629	-2.138	OF
72	Cupid Childs	2.923	22.807	25.592	-2.785	2B
73	Art Fletcher	2.919	23.392	25.581	-2.189	SS
74	Joe Cronin	2.903	24.415	25.540	-1.125	SS
75	Albert Belle	2.894	23.597	25.514	-1.917	OF
76	Bob Johnson	2.875	23.111	25.463	-2.352	OF
78	Frank Chance	2.872	30.119	25.456	4.663	1B
77	Joe Gordon	2.855	23.993	25.411	-1.418	2B
79	Charlie Gehringer	2.855	24.244	25.409	-1.166	2B
80	King Kelly	2.851	27.908	25.399	2.508	OF
81	Hardy Richardson	2.848	24.721	25.392	-0.671	2B
82	Dave Bancroft	2.845	21.144	25.384	-4.240	SS
83	Kevin Mitchell	2.843	24.562	25.377	-0.814	OF
84	Lenny Dykstra	2.822	24.659	25.320	-0.661	OF
85	Gary Carter	2.816	24.213	25.306	-1.093	C
86	Heine Groh	2.800	25.054	25.262	-0.208	3B
87	Thurman Munson	2.788	22.614	25.230	-2.617	C
88	Jim Edmonds	2.760	23.749	25.155	-1.407	OF
89	Larry Walker	2.756	24.963	25.145	-0.181	OF
90	Ozzie Smith	2.748	19.540	25.121	-5.581	SS
91	Joe Sewell	2.738	21.548	25.096	-3.548	SS
92	Roger Bresnahan	2.714	27.859	25.029	2.830	C
93	Luke Appling	2.682	23.913	24.945	-1.032	SS
94	Gil McDougald	2.666	23.302	24.903	-1.601	2B
95	Chief Zimmer	2.642	19.524	24.836	-5.311	C
96	Keith Hernandez	2.637	23.562	24.822	-1.260	1B
97	Bid McPhee	2.636	20.992	24.821	-3.829	2B
98	Bill Mazeroski	2.629	16.937	24.803	-7.867	2B
99	Dave Orr	2.622	27.546	24.782	2.764	1B
100	Jack Fournier	2.621	24.812	24.780	0.032	1B
101	Craig Biggio	2.617	25.715	24.769	0.947	2B
102	Willie McCovey	2.609	27.295	24.749	2.547	1B
103	Bobby Wallace	2.589	23.258	24.694	-1.435	SS
104	Reggie Smith	2.568	26.161	24.638	1.524	OF
105	Ryne Sandberg	2.562	24.155	24.622	-0.467	2B
106	John McGraw	2.558	27.159	24.612	2.546	3B
107	Glenn Hubbard	2.556	17.712	24.604	-6.893	2B
108	Carlton Fisk	2.552	24.202	24.594	-0.392	C
109	Roy Cullenbine	2.545	24.642	24.577	0.065	OF
110	Willie Randolph	2.541	21.367	24.565	-3.198	2B
111	Denny Lyons	2.530	24.521	24.534	-0.013	3B
112	Jeff Kent	2.510	22.997	24.481	-1.484	2B
113	Ralph Kiner	2.507	25.066	24.473	0.594	OF
114	Norm Cash	2.499	25.805	24.451	1.354	1B
115	Darrell Evans	2.487	21.908	24.419	-2.511	3B
116	Ferris Fain	2.484	21.274	24.412	-3.138	1B
117	Rod Carew	2.475	23.586	24.389	-0.803	1B
118	Art Devlin	2.473	24.481	24.382	0.099	3B
119	Harlond Clift	2.472	20.303	24.380	-4.077	3B
120	Tony Gwynn	2.457	25.206	24.340	0.866	OF
121	Tim Raines	2.448	24.668	24.315	0.353	OF
122	Bernie Williams	2.445	24.455	24.308	0.146	OF
123	Jason Giambi	2.444	26.504	24.305	2.199	1B
124	Bill Terry	2.433	25.333	24.275	1.058	1B
125	Jimmy Wynn	2.427	24.674	24.259	0.416	OF
126	George Brett	2.419	24.083	24.238	-0.156	3B
127	Al Kaline	2.408	24.753	24.208	0.545	OF
128	Robin Ventura	2.407	21.597	24.204	-2.607	3B
129	Wally Berger	2.403	27.577	24.194	3.383	OF
130	Harry Heilmann	2.401	25.746	24.189	1.558	OF
131	Al Rosen	2.400	27.407	24.186	3.221	3B
132	Eddie Stanky	2.396	22.772	24.176	-1.404	2B
133	Frankie Frisch	2.393	23.482	24.167	-0.685	2B
134	Billy Herman	2.370	22.347	24.105	-1.757	2B
135	Darryl Strawberry	2.366	25.813	24.095	1.718	OF
136	Tim Salmon	2.352	22.440	24.057	-1.617	OF
137	Mike Scioscia	2.345	21.532	24.039	-2.508	C
138	Ray Chapman	2.340	20.867	24.026	-3.159	SS
139	Jack Clark	2.332	24.896	24.003	0.893	OF
140	Billy Hamilton	2.330	28.768	23.999	4.769	OF
141	Lou Whitaker	2.315	22.820	23.956	-1.136	2B
142	Rafael Palmeiro	2.309	22.414	23.940	-1.526	1B
143	Cap Anson	2.267	24.398	23.828	0.570	1B
144	Reggie Jackson	2.242	25.203	23.761	1.441	OF
145	Stan Hack	2.240	24.073	23.755	0.318	3B
146	Jim Fregosi	2.232	22.849	23.735	-0.886	SS
147	Lefty O'Doul	2.231	25.502	23.733	1.770	OF
148	John Olerud	2.228	22.184	23.722	-1.538	1B
149	Cal Ripken	2.218	21.478	23.697	-2.219	SS
150	Willie Stargell	2.211	26.563	23.678	2.885	OF
151	George Stone	2.192	25.814	23.628	2.186	OF
152	Alan Trammell	2.191	21.980	23.624	-1.644	SS
153	Robin Yount	2.180	22.378	23.593	-1.215	SS
154	Bobby Bonds	2.179	24.190	23.591	0.599	OF
155	Roberto Clemente	2.157	23.922	23.534	0.389	OF
156	Harmon Killebrew	2.149	24.454	23.510	0.944	1B
157	Chipper Jones	2.142	25.380	23.493	1.887	3B
158	Eric Davis	2.140	23.613	23.487	0.127	OF
159	Travis Jackson	2.134	20.471	23.472	-3.000	SS
160	Miller Huggins	2.125	21.158	23.447	-2.289	2B
161	Hack Wilson	2.123	26.125	23.440	2.685	OF
162	Ernie Lombardi	2.103	22.155	23.388	-1.233	C
163	Jesse Burkett	2.096	26.217	23.368	2.848	OF
164	Dick Bartell	2.090	18.677	23.352	-4.675	SS
165	Darrell Porter	2.061	21.896	23.275	-1.379	C
166	Wally Schang	2.058	24.721	23.267	1.454	C
167	Harry Stovey	2.040	25.142	23.217	1.925	OF
168	Joe Medwick	2.037	19.340	23.211	-3.871	OF
169	Paul Waner	2.035	25.470	23.205	2.265	OF
170	Ken Williams	2.020	23.316	23.164	0.152	OF
171	Johnny Kling	2.012	21.661	23.143	-1.483	C
172	Ron Hansen	2.012	18.940	23.141	-4.201	SS
173	Ray Lankford	2.007	22.788	23.129	-0.341	OF
174	Earl Battey	2.005	22.421	23.124	-0.703	C
175	Jeff Heath	2.005	25.291	23.122	2.168	OF
176	Sammy Sosa	2.000	22.066	23.111	-1.044	OF
177	Jimmy Collins	1.998	23.801	23.104	0.696	3B
178	Frank Howard	1.992	26.174	23.088	3.086	OF
179	Sherry Magee	1.986	26.839	23.073	3.766	OF
180	Benny Kauff	1.982	31.818	23.061	8.757	OF
181	Paul Molitor	1.972	22.062	23.034	-0.972	DH
182	Ken Caminiti	1.964	22.009	23.014	-1.005	3B
183	Kirby Puckett	1.961	23.252	23.005	0.247	OF
184	Carl Yastrzemski	1.959	22.602	23.000	-0.398	OF
185	Dwayne Murphy	1.953	21.386	22.984	-1.598	OF
186	Rocky Colavito	1.946	23.403	22.965	0.438	OF
187	Will Clark	1.940	25.895	22.949	2.946	1B
188	Red Smith	1.937	23.097	22.940	0.157	3B
189	Rick Burleson	1.927	17.229	22.913	-5.685	SS
190	Del Pratt	1.916	20.609	22.884	-2.275	2B
191	Tony Oliva	1.912	23.079	22.874	0.205	OF
192	Chuck Klein	1.907	21.516	22.861	-1.345	OF
194	Pedro Guerrero	1.907	26.068	22.861	3.207	1B
193	George Sisler	1.905	20.994	22.855	-1.861	1B
195	Fred Pfeffer	1.892	18.377	22.820	-4.444	2B
196	Stan Spence	1.880	24.632	22.788	1.844	OF
197	Henry Larkin	1.870	21.633	22.760	-1.128	1B
198	Larry Doby	1.861	27.557	22.736	4.821	OF
199	Buddy Bell	1.858	19.487	22.728	-3.241	3B
200	Rico Carty	1.856	21.436	22.724	-1.288	OF
201	Vern Stephens	1.853	23.718	22.714	1.004	SS
202	Tom Haller	1.850	25.668	22.706	2.962	C
203	Lance Parrish	1.845	12.882	22.693	-9.811	C
204	Jose Canseco	1.833	21.682	22.662	-0.980	OF
205	Fred Clarke	1.828	26.403	22.648	3.755	OF
206	Matt Williams	1.827	20.877	22.644	-1.767	3B
207	Babe Herman	1.821	24.146	22.630	1.517	1B
208	Johnny Pesky	1.821	21.968	22.628	-0.660	SS
209	Johnny Logan	1.814	19.903	22.611	-2.708	SS
210	Duke Snider	1.809	27.692	22.597	5.094	OF
211	Phil Rizzuto	1.806	22.308	22.588	-0.280	SS
212	Juan Gonzalez	1.799	21.858	22.570	-0.713	OF
213	Tommy Henrich	1.797	24.918	22.564	2.355	OF
214	Sam Crawford	1.792	27.275	22.550	4.725	OF
215	Eddie Murray	1.790	22.094	22.544	-0.451	1B
216	Cesar Cedeno	1.777	23.584	22.509	1.074	OF
217	Jack Clements	1.776	20.099	22.507	-2.408	C
218	Joe Tinker	1.766	23.369	22.481	0.888	SS
219	Minnie Minoso	1.765	23.785	22.478	1.307	OF
220	Darren Daulton	1.763	23.762	22.474	1.288	C
221	Bill Nicholson	1.737	22.515	22.401	0.114	OF
222	Kid Elberfeld	1.721	22.616	22.359	0.257	SS
223	Chick Hafey	1.711	23.573	22.332	1.240	OF
224	Mike Griffin	1.706	23.221	22.319	0.902	OF
225	John Kruk	1.703	21.961	22.312	-0.351	1B
226	Ernie Banks	1.696	20.696	22.291	-1.595	1B
227	Jesse Barfield	1.694	19.942	22.287	-2.344	OF
228	Bob Elliott	1.693	22.708	22.285	0.423	3B
229	Fred Tenney	1.692	18.317	22.281	-3.965	1B
230	Bill Freehan	1.691	25.078	22.278	2.800	C
231	Andy Van Slyke	1.691	23.107	22.278	0.830	OF
232	Roy Smalley	1.690	17.787	22.277	-4.490	SS
233	Ray Schalk	1.678	19.911	22.245	-2.334	C
234	Davey Johnson	1.672	20.276	22.227	-1.951	2B
235	Mike Donlin	1.665	26.332	22.208	4.124	OF
236	Ron Cey	1.654	21.745	22.180	-0.435	3B
237	Riggs Stephenson	1.653	23.981	22.178	1.804	OF
238	Sid Gordon	1.650	22.191	22.170	0.021	OF
239	Joe Torre	1.642	23.193	22.147	1.046	C
240	David Justice	1.638	23.468	22.138	1.330	OF
241	Robby Thompson	1.634	19.186	22.125	-2.939	2B
242	Jimmy Williams	1.633	21.946	22.122	-0.176	2B
243	LUIS GONZALEZ	1.631	20.390	22.118	-1.728	OF
244	Fred McGriff	1.618	22.333	22.084	0.249	1B
245	Rico Petrocelli	1.617	21.530	22.081	-0.551	SS
246	Fred Lynn	1.611	22.900	22.064	0.836	OF
247	Dave Winfield	1.599	21.761	22.032	-0.271	OF
248	Joe Kelley	1.592	24.283	22.013	2.270	OF
249	Chet Lemon	1.589	21.814	22.004	-0.190	OF
250	Ed Konetchy	1.586	21.465	21.995	-0.530	1B
251	Moises Alou	1.585	24.246	21.993	2.253	OF
252	Tony Lazzeri	1.579	22.357	21.978	0.379	2B
253	Tony Fernandez	1.577	20.637	21.973	-1.336	SS
254	Zack Wheat	1.563	24.646	21.935	2.711	OF
255	Mike Hargrove	1.559	20.525	21.923	-1.398	1B
256	Kenny Lofton	1.554	21.068	21.910	-0.842	OF
257	Earl Averill	1.552	25.123	21.906	3.218	OF
258	Boog Powell	1.552	23.398	21.904	1.494	1B
260	Ken Singleton	1.545	22.867	21.885	0.982	OF
259	Ken Boyer	1.544	21.866	21.883	-0.017	3B
261	Don Buford	1.539	23.511	21.870	1.641	OF
262	Jose Cruz	1.538	22.710	21.868	0.842	OF
263	George Foster	1.535	22.313	21.858	0.455	OF
264	Bobby Veach	1.534	22.714	21.857	0.857	OF
265	Al Simmons	1.532	25.533	21.851	3.682	OF
266	John Titus	1.526	22.387	21.835	0.552	OF
267	Goose Goslin	1.524	23.419	21.829	1.589	OF
268	Dwight Evans	1.521	21.275	21.820	-0.545	OF
269	Richie Ashburn	1.504	21.897	21.776	0.121	OF
270	Doug DeCinces	1.478	20.331	21.705	-1.374	3B
271	Oscar Gamble	1.471	22.070	21.688	0.382	OF
272	Jimmy Sheckard	1.471	24.095	21.688	2.407	OF
274	Willie Kamm	1.467	18.781	21.676	-2.895	3B
273	Socks Seybold	1.467	23.503	21.676	1.827	OF
275	Billy Williams	1.466	23.039	21.674	1.366	OF
276	Andy Seminick	1.460	20.130	21.658	-1.527	C
277	Walker Cooper	1.455	22.076	21.643	0.433	C
278	Sixto Lezcano	1.454	21.403	21.641	-0.238	OF
279	Ted Simmons	1.452	21.076	21.636	-0.560	C
280	Danny Tartabull	1.442	20.853	21.609	-0.756	OF
281	Pie Traynor	1.438	21.410	21.598	-0.188	3B
282	Toby Harrah	1.434	21.216	21.588	-0.372	3B
283	George Gore	1.433	26.540	21.585	4.955	OF
284	Johnny Evers	1.429	24.087	21.574	2.512	2B
285	Orlando Cepeda	1.423	23.103	21.559	1.544	1B
286	Tommy Holmes	1.421	21.891	21.551	0.340	OF
287	Jake Beckley	1.421	19.640	21.551	-1.911	1B
289	Augie Galan	1.416	24.336	21.538	2.798	OF
288	Brian Downing	1.413	20.744	21.531	-0.787	DH
290	Bob Allison	1.412	22.217	21.528	0.689	OF
291	Jerry Priddy	1.397	17.310	21.487	-4.177	2B
292	Bob O'Farrell	1.394	22.001	21.479	0.521	C
293	Mike Tiernan	1.388	24.196	21.464	2.732	OF
294	Jay Bell	1.384	18.784	21.452	-2.668	SS
295	Oyster Burns	1.384	24.652	21.452	3.200	OF
296	Smoky Burgess	1.383	22.233	21.451	0.783	C
298	Ellis Burks	1.377	20.655	21.434	-0.779	OF
297	Lonny Frey	1.377	21.053	21.433	-0.380	2B
299	Tony Phillips	1.373	19.063	21.423	-2.360	OF
301	Derek Jeter	1.372	23.018	21.420	1.597	SS
300	Graig Nettles	1.369	20.341	21.412	-1.071	3B
302	Dolph Camilli	1.367	22.851	21.407	1.444	1B
303	Lonnie Smith	1.361	20.685	21.391	-0.705	OF
304	Ross Youngs	1.361	25.031	21.391	3.640	OF
305	Ned Williamson	1.352	22.059	21.366	0.693	3B
306	Don Mattingly	1.334	22.073	21.320	0.753	1B
307	Jim Rice	1.331	20.174	21.309	-1.135	OF
308	Dan McGann	1.329	19.610	21.304	-1.694	1B
309	Rusty Staub	1.327	20.659	21.300	-0.641	OF
310	Larry Hisle	1.315	19.792	21.267	-1.475	OF
311	Sherm Lollar	1.313	18.446	21.262	-2.816	C
312	HEINIE ZIMMERMAN	1.310	24.159	21.253	2.906	3B
313	Jim O'Rourke	1.304	24.854	21.237	3.617	OF
314	Ken Keltner	1.304	20.430	21.237	-0.808	3B
315	Deacon White	1.292	21.722	21.205	0.517	3B
317	Bobby Bonilla	1.287	20.959	21.193	-0.234	3B
316	Jody Reed	1.284	16.793	21.184	-4.392	2B
318	Rudy York	1.283	20.639	21.180	-0.542	1B
319	Roy White	1.282	22.033	21.178	0.855	OF
320	Chicken Wolf	1.274	18.677	21.157	-2.480	OF
321	Edgardo Alfonzo	1.267	24.006	21.138	2.868	2B
322	Andre Thornton	1.267	19.153	21.137	-1.984	DH
323	Ben Chapman	1.266	20.351	21.137	-0.786	OF
324	Reggie Sanders	1.264	19.790	21.131	-1.341	OF
325	Paul O'Neill	1.245	20.153	21.079	-0.926	OF
326	Kip Selbach	1.234	19.645	21.048	-1.403	OF
327	Richie Zisk	1.231	20.105	21.042	-0.937	OF
328	Julio Franco	1.231	19.249	21.041	-1.791	SS
329	Max Bishop	1.223	20.643	21.019	-0.377	2B
330	Cecil Travis	1.221	20.228	21.014	-0.786	SS
331	Dave Concepcion	1.203	18.082	20.967	-2.885	SS
332	Tony Taylor	1.197	15.093	20.949	-5.856	2B
333	Alvin Davis	1.190	19.789	20.931	-1.142	1B
334	Hal McRae	1.182	18.496	20.910	-2.414	DH
335	Johnny Ray	1.180	17.526	20.904	-3.378	2B
336	Ron Hunt	1.179	20.099	20.900	-0.802	2B
337	Kirk Gibson	1.178	21.224	20.899	0.325	OF
338	Dave Cash	1.177	17.652	20.896	-3.243	2B
339	Tony Pena	1.173	16.033	20.885	-4.852	C
340	Bill Bradley	1.169	20.485	20.875	-0.390	3B
341	Gene Woodling	1.166	22.345	20.867	1.478	OF
342	Ed Bailey	1.155	22.329	20.837	1.492	C
343	Kevin McReynolds	1.148	21.675	20.818	0.857	OF
344	Earle Combs	1.145	22.599	20.810	1.789	OF
345	Bob Watson	1.145	21.966	20.810	1.156	1B
346	Buck Herzog	1.136	18.324	20.786	-2.461	3B
348	Danny Green	1.135	23.695	20.784	2.911	OF
347	Jerry Denny	1.135	17.650	20.782	-3.132	3B
349	Buddy Myer	1.132	20.423	20.775	-0.352	2B
351	John Briggs	1.125	21.301	20.757	0.544	OF
350	Ryan Klesko	1.118	23.652	20.737	2.915	OF
352	Pee Wee Reese	1.115	21.486	20.730	0.756	SS
353	Roy Sievers	1.111	20.368	20.719	-0.350	1B
354	Red Schoendienst	1.110	18.410	20.716	-2.307	2B
355	Roger Peckinpaugh	1.105	18.475	20.703	-2.229	SS
356	Greg Luzinski	1.104	21.301	20.699	0.602	OF
357	Davey Lopes	1.104	21.188	20.699	0.489	2B
358	Gil Hodges	1.103	21.030	20.698	0.331	1B
360	Tony Cuccinello	1.102	19.128	20.696	-1.568	2B
359	Jim Sundberg	1.099	18.788	20.687	-1.899	C
361	Elston Howard	1.098	22.513	20.683	1.830	C
362	Mickey Tettleton	1.094	20.754	20.673	0.081	C
363	Lave Cross	1.093	18.530	20.670	-2.141	3B
364	Brett Butler	1.093	20.027	20.670	-0.643	OF
365	Kent Hrbek	1.090	20.883	20.661	0.222	1B
366	Billy Nash	1.089	21.401	20.660	0.741	3B
367	Andre Dawson	1.089	20.459	20.660	-0.201	OF
368	Woodie Held	1.088	21.344	20.657	0.687	SS
369	Max Carey	1.083	21.119	20.643	0.475	OF
370	Kiki Cuyler	1.080	23.366	20.636	2.730	OF
371	Doug Rader	1.078	18.444	20.629	-2.185	3B
372	Bill Werber	1.075	17.960	20.623	-2.663	3B
373	Tom Tresh	1.072	21.181	20.614	0.566	OF
374	Don Mincher	1.070	22.217	20.608	1.610	1B
375	Roger Maris	1.064	24.718	20.592	4.126	OF
376	Fred Luderus	1.055	19.186	20.569	-1.383	1B
377	Rick Ferrell	1.054	18.876	20.565	-1.689	C
378	Danny Murphy	1.053	23.329	20.561	2.768	2B
379	Topsy Hartsel	1.052	24.966	20.561	4.405	OF
380	Freddy Lindstrom	1.051	20.489	20.557	-0.068	3B
381	Dickie Thon	1.051	19.556	20.557	-1.001	SS
382	Del Crandall	1.045	20.783	20.541	0.242	C
383	Jim Ray Hart	1.040	22.640	20.528	2.112	3B
384	Enos Slaughter	1.034	23.041	20.512	2.529	OF
385	Dave Magadan	1.018	19.193	20.470	-1.276	3B
386	Duke Farrell	1.014	18.928	20.457	-1.529	C
387	Willie Keeler	1.011	22.454	20.451	2.003	OF
388	Dom DiMaggio	1.010	22.007	20.448	1.559	OF
389	Raul Mondesi	1.003	21.002	20.429	0.574	OF
390	Steve O'Neill	1.002	17.712	20.426	-2.714	C
391	Vic Wertz	0.997	20.213	20.411	-0.199	OF
392	Von Hayes	0.996	18.952	20.409	-1.457	OF
393	Dixie Walker	0.989	23.499	20.390	3.109	OF
394	Dick McAuliffe	0.986	21.805	20.383	1.422	2B
395	Curt Welch	0.984	21.648	20.377	1.271	OF
396	Kevin Seitzer	0.983	18.600	20.375	-1.776	3B
397	Jackie Jensen	0.981	19.934	20.368	-0.435	OF
398	Clete Boyer	0.977	16.289	20.359	-4.070	3B
399	Pete Rose	0.976	22.348	20.357	1.991	OF
400	Chuck Knoblauch	0.974	21.051	20.351	0.700	2B
401	Jay Buhner	0.973	19.023	20.347	-1.324	OF
402	Bert Campaneris	0.963	18.851	20.320	-1.469	SS
403	Spud Davis	0.962	20.486	20.319	0.167	C
404	Tim McCarver	0.961	21.301	20.314	0.987	C
405	Ezra Sutton	0.960	22.992	20.314	2.679	3B
406	Chili Davis	0.959	18.475	20.311	-1.835	OF
407	Harry Davis	0.957	20.900	20.305	0.596	1B
408	Dave Parker	0.954	20.807	20.297	0.509	OF
409	Elbie Fletcher	0.945	20.577	20.273	0.304	1B
410	Amos Otis	0.943	22.475	20.267	2.208	OF
411	Mike Greenwell	0.941	18.314	20.261	-1.947	OF
412	Mark Grace	0.937	21.017	20.249	0.768	1B
413	Freddie Patek	0.934	15.562	20.242	-4.680	SS
414	Larry Doyle	0.930	25.369	20.233	5.136	2B
415	Bill North	0.926	20.053	20.220	-0.167	OF
416	Hank Sauer	0.922	20.826	20.209	0.617	OF
417	Sam Wise	0.908	19.793	20.172	-0.379	SS
418	Don Money	0.907	18.242	20.171	-1.929	3B
419	Matty McIntyre	0.906	21.279	20.167	1.112	OF
420	Ray Boone	0.905	20.307	20.165	0.142	3B
421	Nellie Fox	0.902	18.910	20.155	-1.246	2B
422	Jimmy Ryan	0.896	22.467	20.140	2.328	OF
423	Ripper Collins	0.894	22.653	20.134	2.519	1B
424	Buddy Lewis	0.884	19.537	20.108	-0.571	3B
425	Elmer Valo	0.883	19.891	20.105	-0.214	OF
426	Pinky Whitney	0.882	15.284	20.103	-4.819	3B
427	Tim Wallach	0.880	18.040	20.098	-2.057	3B
428	Johnny Callison	0.880	20.999	20.097	0.902	OF
429	Johnny Grubb	0.873	21.094	20.079	1.015	OF
430	Hal Trosky	0.868	21.987	20.065	1.922	1B
431	Billy Jurges	0.859	15.708	20.042	-4.334	SS
432	Tommy Leach	0.859	23.483	20.041	3.442	OF
433	Muddy Ruel	0.857	19.102	20.036	-0.934	C
434	Buck Freeman	0.856	22.446	20.032	2.414	OF
436	Mo Vaughn	0.856	20.827	20.032	0.795	1B
435	Mark Belanger	0.854	15.901	20.027	-4.126	SS
437	Harold Reynolds	0.852	14.765	20.023	-5.257	2B
439	Manny Trillo	0.838	14.393	19.984	-5.591	2B
438	John Roseboro	0.832	21.221	19.969	1.252	C
440	Dick Groat	0.832	17.826	19.968	-2.142	SS
441	Travis Fryman	0.832	18.356	19.967	-1.612	3B
442	Marty McManus	0.831	17.307	19.966	-2.658	2B
445	Carlos Baerga	0.829	17.653	19.959	-2.306	2B
443	Rick Dempsey	0.815	18.935	19.922	-0.987	C
444	Wally Joyner	0.814	20.203	19.921	0.282	1B
446	Jake Daubert	0.808	19.497	19.904	-0.407	1B
447	Claude Ritchey	0.798	19.475	19.877	-0.401	2B
448	Chris Speier	0.795	16.369	19.867	-3.499	SS
449	Eddie Joost	0.793	19.966	19.863	0.103	SS
450	Cy Williams	0.789	19.725	19.852	-0.127	OF
451	Mike Mitchell	0.787	20.377	19.847	0.530	OF
452	Brooks Robinson	0.786	19.580	19.846	-0.266	3B
453	Manny Sanguillen	0.783	18.910	19.836	-0.926	C
454	Woody English	0.782	18.365	19.834	-1.468	SS
455	Harold Baines	0.777	17.935	19.820	-1.885	DH
456	Maury Wills	0.773	19.743	19.808	-0.065	SS
457	Don Baylor	0.772	18.059	19.807	-1.747	DH
458	Edd Roush	0.771	24.948	19.803	5.144	OF
459	George Grantham	0.769	21.208	19.799	1.409	2B
460	Ben Oglivie	0.766	19.053	19.791	-0.738	OF
461	Ken Griffey Sr.	0.765	20.854	19.788	1.066	OF
462	Omar Vizquel	0.764	14.739	19.784	-5.045	SS
463	Earl Torgeson	0.762	19.750	19.780	-0.030	1B
464	Harry Hooper	0.759	20.303	19.772	0.532	OF
465	Dale Murphy	0.753	21.074	19.755	1.320	OF
466	Larry Gardner	0.751	21.766	19.750	2.016	3B
467	Sal Bando	0.751	22.126	19.749	2.377	3B
468	Garry Templeton	0.750	16.500	19.748	-3.248	SS
469	Eric Young	0.746	14.812	19.737	-4.925	2B
470	Bobby Avila	0.740	21.224	19.720	1.504	2B
471	Bobby Murcer	0.739	23.257	19.717	3.539	OF
472	George Kell	0.732	19.712	19.698	0.014	3B
473	George Van Haltren	0.728	24.790	19.688	5.102	OF
474	Cecil Cooper	0.718	19.671	19.662	0.009	1B
475	Scott Fletcher	0.716	16.048	19.655	-3.607	SS
476	Luis Aparicio	0.716	16.907	19.655	-2.748	SS
477	Johnny Bates	0.715	20.614	19.654	0.960	OF
479	Frank White	0.704	16.148	19.624	-3.476	2B
478	Spike Owen	0.704	14.079	19.624	-5.544	SS
480	Ken McMullen	0.701	19.791	19.616	0.174	3B
481	Joe Adcock	0.701	20.938	19.615	1.322	1B
482	Donie Bush	0.697	17.213	19.606	-2.393	SS
484	Rick Monday	0.697	23.343	19.604	3.739	OF
483	Steve Finley	0.693	18.998	19.595	-0.596	OF
486	Lyn Lary	0.693	17.323	19.594	-2.271	SS
485	George Wood	0.690	18.479	19.587	-1.107	OF
487	Tom Daly	0.689	21.477	19.584	1.893	2B
488	Cecil Fielder	0.687	17.457	19.579	-2.122	1B
489	Phil Cavarretta	0.682	19.942	19.563	0.379	1B
490	John Stone	0.674	19.299	19.542	-0.243	OF
491	Andy Pafko	0.673	20.290	19.541	0.749	OF
492	Norm Siebern	0.664	21.038	19.517	1.521	1B
493	Phil Garner	0.633	18.420	19.432	-1.013	2B
494	Terry Pendleton	0.628	17.140	19.419	-2.279	3B
495	Johnny Edwards	0.619	18.814	19.394	-0.581	C
496	Ruppert Jones	0.617	17.879	19.391	-1.512	OF
497	Tony Perez	0.615	20.822	19.383	1.439	1B
498	Bill Madlock	0.607	21.272	19.362	1.910	3B
499	George Burns-of	0.605	22.775	19.357	3.419	OF
500	Ivan DeJesus	0.599	13.227	19.341	-6.114	SS
501	Ival Goodman	0.598	21.016	19.340	1.677	OF
502	Dave Henderson	0.594	18.263	19.327	-1.063	OF
503	Rabbit Maranville	0.593	17.386	19.325	-1.939	SS
504	Greg Vaughn	0.588	18.977	19.311	-0.334	OF
505	Al Oliver	0.583	20.213	19.299	0.914	OF
506	Jason Thompson	0.581	18.804	19.293	-0.489	1B
507	Billy Rogell	0.580	17.629	19.291	-1.662	SS
508	Denis Menke	0.579	19.219	19.287	-0.067	SS
509	Frank McCormick	0.574	21.088	19.275	1.814	1B
510	Joe Judge	0.572	19.080	19.270	-0.190	1B
511	Terry Steinbach	0.572	19.014	19.267	-0.254	C
512	Horace Clarke	0.569	15.699	19.260	-3.560	2B
513	Terry Puhl	0.556	20.815	19.225	1.590	OF
514	Howard Johnson	0.556	21.997	19.225	2.772	3B
515	Bill Doran	0.547	21.119	19.202	1.917	2B
517	Jim Delahanty	0.539	20.596	19.180	1.415	2B
516	Butch Wynegar	0.537	17.393	19.175	-1.782	C
518	Bill Skowron	0.536	19.614	19.172	0.442	1B
519	Jerry Mumphrey	0.526	18.698	19.145	-0.447	OF
520	Sam Rice	0.519	20.683	19.125	1.558	OF
521	Pepper Martin	0.516	21.643	19.118	2.525	OF
522	Pete Runnels	0.513	19.100	19.110	-0.009	1B
523	Abner Dalrymple	0.503	22.172	19.082	3.090	OF
524	Mike Bordick	0.501	14.686	19.077	-4.392	SS
525	Sammy West	0.493	17.845	19.055	-1.210	OF
526	Ron Gant	0.487	18.159	19.039	-0.881	OF
527	Andres Galarraga	0.485	18.552	19.036	-0.483	1B
528	Fielder Jones	0.485	23.814	19.033	4.781	OF
529	Del Ennis	0.482	19.016	19.025	-0.010	OF
530	Dusty Baker	0.477	19.793	19.012	0.781	OF
531	Brady Anderson	0.475	18.160	19.008	-0.848	OF
532	Carl Furillo	0.471	20.025	18.996	1.029	OF
533	Bob Bailey	0.451	17.389	18.943	-1.554	3B
534	Deacon McGuire	0.448	17.751	18.936	-1.185	C
535	Ron Fairly	0.445	20.660	18.928	1.732	1B
536	Chick Stahl	0.443	23.950	18.921	5.029	OF
537	Gus Mancuso	0.438	17.409	18.909	-1.500	C
538	Paul Hines	0.438	24.245	18.909	5.337	OF
539	Ted Sizemore	0.436	14.915	18.903	-3.988	2B
540	Tom Herr	0.435	18.027	18.899	-0.873	2B
541	Lee Lacy	0.427	17.871	18.880	-1.009	OF
542	Gary Matthews	0.427	20.337	18.879	1.457	OF
543	Dummy Hoy	0.425	19.643	18.874	0.769	OF
545	Al Lopez	0.422	16.967	18.864	-1.897	C
544	Bill White	0.417	20.274	18.852	1.422	1B
546	Richie Hebner	0.416	20.227	18.848	1.379	3B
547	Garry Maddox	0.411	19.416	18.836	0.580	OF
548	Hugh Duffy	0.389	24.389	18.775	5.614	OF
549	Harry Steinfeldt	0.387	20.135	18.772	1.363	3B
550	Willie Horton	0.378	18.751	18.747	0.004	OF
551	Bud Harrelson	0.376	16.564	18.741	-2.177	SS
552	Ginger Beaumont	0.371	23.626	18.729	4.896	OF
553	Wally Moses	0.369	18.609	18.723	-0.114	OF
554	Donn Clendenon	0.368	17.239	18.719	-1.479	1B
555	Casey Stengel	0.359	21.161	18.697	2.464	OF
556	Marty Marion	0.359	18.677	18.695	-0.018	SS
557	Cass Michaels	0.349	15.619	18.668	-3.048	2B
558	Bucky Dent	0.348	14.959	18.667	-3.708	SS
559	Tony Gonzalez	0.347	20.470	18.663	1.807	OF
560	Jimmy Dykes	0.340	16.996	18.644	-1.648	3B
561	Al Dark	0.339	18.706	18.643	0.063	SS
562	Paul Radford	0.323	15.357	18.598	-3.241	OF
563	Mickey Rivers	0.323	19.890	18.598	1.293	OF
564	Heinie Manush	0.316	21.947	18.579	3.367	OF
566	Eddie Miller	0.312	15.376	18.569	-3.194	SS
565	Gorman Thomas	0.307	17.954	18.556	-0.602	OF
567	Pat Kelly	0.306	19.050	18.553	0.497	OF
568	Tim Foli	0.306	10.549	18.552	-8.003	SS
569	Lou Bierbauer	0.301	14.730	18.540	-3.810	2B
571	Jim Northrup	0.298	20.005	18.532	1.473	OF
572	Al Bumbry	0.288	19.490	18.506	0.984	OF
573	Ted Kluszewski	0.280	17.928	18.484	-0.557	1B
574	Mike Stanley	0.273	18.833	18.464	0.370	C
575	Jack Doyle	0.266	17.356	18.446	-1.090	1B
576	Shawon Dunston	0.265	15.980	18.442	-2.461	SS
577	Jeff Burroughs	0.251	19.694	18.406	1.288	OF
578	Hector Lopez	0.250	17.023	18.403	-1.380	OF
579	Lu Blue	0.243	17.803	18.383	-0.580	1B
580	Benito Santiago	0.235	16.220	18.361	-2.141	C
581	Ken Oberkfell	0.234	16.528	18.361	-1.832	3B
582	Mickey Vernon	0.231	19.505	18.350	1.154	1B
583	John Morrill	0.221	18.553	18.325	0.228	1B
584	Sam Chapman	0.220	16.782	18.322	-1.540	OF
585	Jimmy Johnston	0.219	18.077	18.318	-0.242	3B
586	Burt Shotton	0.203	18.150	18.276	-0.126	OF
587	George Burns-1b	0.197	17.918	18.260	-0.342
588	Tilly Walker	0.194	18.763	18.253	0.510	OF
589	Herman Long	0.191	20.207	18.243	1.964	SS
590	Jimmy Austin	0.185	14.706	18.228	-3.522	3B
591	Devon White	0.184	16.603	18.226	-1.623	OF
592	Eddie Yost	0.184	18.857	18.224	0.633	3B
593	George Hendrick	0.182	19.626	18.220	1.406	OF
595	Hank Bauer	0.180	20.194	18.213	1.981	OF
594	Gary Gaetti	0.178	16.436	18.209	-1.773	3B
596	Billy Shindle	0.174	17.061	18.197	-1.136	3B
597	George Kelly	0.174	16.987	18.197	-1.210	1B
598	John Anderson	0.172	20.008	18.194	1.814	OF
599	John Mayberry	0.171	20.005	18.190	1.815	1B
600	Vada Pinson	0.168	19.995	18.182	1.813	OF
601	Red Rolfe	0.168	19.422	18.182	1.241	3B
602	Leo Cardenas	0.166	17.421	18.177	-0.756	SS
604	Willie Davis	0.165	21.244	18.174	3.070	OF
603	Wid Conroy	0.162	17.726	18.166	-0.440	3B
605	Steve Sax	0.161	16.811	18.164	-1.353	2B
606	Bob Bescher	0.160	18.911	18.159	0.751	OF
607	George McBride	0.156	13.201	18.149	-4.948	SS
608	Roberto Kelly	0.155	17.458	18.147	-0.690	OF
609	Fred Merkle	0.151	19.261	18.137	1.124	1B
610	Johnny Hopp	0.148	20.903	18.129	2.774	OF
611	Don Kessinger	0.137	12.080	18.098	-6.018	SS
612	Buck Weaver	0.135	18.612	18.092	0.520	SS
613	Jim Gantner	0.134	15.574	18.090	-2.516	2B
614	Lou Brock	0.133	20.072	18.087	1.985	OF
615	Bill Russell	0.129	14.948	18.078	-3.130	SS
616	Wally Moon	0.116	20.374	18.043	2.331	OF
617	Vic Power	0.100	15.245	18.000	-2.755	1B
618	Barney McCosky	0.095	19.876	17.986	1.889	OF
619	John Reilly	0.066	19.827	17.907	1.921	1B
620	David Segui	0.064	15.861	17.903	-2.042	1B
621	Cesar Tovar	0.063	18.673	17.899	0.774	OF
622	Todd Zeile	0.062	17.588	17.896	-0.309	3B
623	Felipe Alou	0.057	19.748	17.884	1.864	OF
624	Jim Gilliam	0.055	19.235	17.877	1.359	2B
625	Leon Wagner	0.052	20.160	17.871	2.289	OF
626	Delino DeShields	0.050	18.306	17.865	0.441	2B
627	Willie Wilson	0.047	18.465	17.856	0.610	OF
628	Bob Meusel	0.043	19.780	17.846	1.934	OF
629	Frank Malzone	0.033	14.908	17.819	-2.911	3B
630	Jose Offerman	0.033	15.829	17.818	-1.989	SS
631