Players Ranked by Their Average Rank in Total Win Shares and Win Shares per Plate Appearance

 

by Cyril Morong

 

 

Email


Click here to see my sabermetric blog called Cybermetrics

 

I have another site where all players are ranked by their Win Shares per Plate Appearance. Win Shares (WS) is a stat created by Bill James to taken into account all phases of baseball. WS can never be negative. Here I look at all players who had at least 5000 plate appearances (PA) and/or 141 WS through 2001. There were 861 such players.

 

One problem with ranking players by WS per PA is that a player with a short career can have a high WS per PA and rank higher than other players simply because he did not play long enough to see the decline phase in his career when his WS per PA would have fallen. Conversely, a player with a high WS total may have just played a long time while never being a very good player.

 

So here I combine the two ranks. For example, if a player was 20th in WS per PA and 40th in total WS, his rank would be 30. So I basically took the average of the two ranks. Once that was done, all players were re-ranked. Now Ruth had the best “average rank” at 2, with his WS per PA rank being 1 and his total WS rank being 3. No other player had a higher rank. So I simply changed Ruth’s “average rank” to 1. Cobb was next with a total WS rank of 1 and a WS per PA rank of 5. That “average rank” was 3. So this was changed to a 2, and so on (I only included Ruth’s WS from hitting and fielding, not pitching). Also, players who played under the 162 game schedule had their total WS reduced by 5%. The appropriately weighted reduction was used on players who played under both a 154 game schedule and the 162 game schedule.

 

The players are grouped below by position and then ranked by what their “average rank” was among all 861 players. Gehrig, for example, had the best rank among first basemen. Foxx was second. “Total Rank” says what a player’s rank was in total WS among all 861 players. “Per WS Rank” says what a player’s rank was in WS per PA among all 861 players. A player was listed at the position he played more games than any other.

 

Now if the WS per PA should be more important, I also calculated an “average rank” with rank in WS per PA getting a weight of .75 and rank in total WS getting a weight of .25. Where a player ranked here among all players is in the second column from the right. The last column reverses this, with rank in WS per PA getting a weight of .25 and rank in total WS getting a weight of .75, in case total WS is more important than WS per PA.

 

The Lee Sinins sabermetric encyclopedia was very helpful in putting this together.

 

 

Pos Rank

Player

POS

WS*

WS per 648 PA

Total Rank

Per WS Rank

Average Rank

75% Per WS Rank

75% Total Rank

1

Lou Gehrig

1B

489

32.8

18

11

12

10

14

2

Jimmie Foxx

1B

435

29.15

24

30

19

19

19

3

Dan Brouthers

1B

355

29.97

57

23

25

21

33

4

Willie McCovey

1B

389.5

27.3

38

54

27

32

25

5

Johnny Mize

1B

338

29.71

72

26

28

26

43

6

Dick Allen

1B

324.9

30.3

87

19

30

25

51

7

Roger Connor

1B

363

26.6

52

61

35

41

34

8

Mark McGwire

1B

324.9

28.93

88

33

39

30

56

9

Frank Thomas-cws

1B

308

29.02

108

32

47

34

69

10

Jeff Bagwell

1B

302.1

28.48

117

41

53

43

79

11

Will Clark

1B

314.45

25.89

98

79

58

62

73

12

Cap Anson

1B

381

24.4

42

135

59

86

48

13

Harmon Killebrew

1B

355.17

24.45

56

132

66

87

57

14

Norm Cash

1B

300.38

25.81

120

80

68

66

91

15

Hank Greenberg

1B

267

28.38

184

42

82

55

123

16

Rod Carew

1B

364.8

23.59

51

176

84

117

61

17

Bill Terry

1B

278

25.33

161

94

97

84

116

18

Frank Chance

1B

237

30.12

254

21

107

56

173

19

Eddie Murray

1B

415.15

22.09

28

261

111

184

67

20

Keith Hernandez

1B

295.45

23.56

132

179

120

138

115

21

Orlando Cepeda

1B

299.03

23.1

125

205

131

158

118

22

Rafael Palmeiro

1B

317.3

22.41

95

240

135

186

105

23

Pedro Guerrero

1B

233.7

26.07

264

77

137

99

197

24

Boog Powell

1B

267.9

23.4

181

188

154

159

160

25

Fred McGriff

1B

300.2

22.33

121

249

155

200

128

26

Jack Fournier

1B

231

24.81

275

113

163

123

214

27

Babe Herman

1B

232

24.15

271

149

179

153

222

28

Tony Perez

1B

331.55

20.82

77

364

186

277

124

29

Ed Konetchy

1B

287

21.47

146

308

195

250

165

30

Ernie Banks

1B

323.71

20.7

89

371

199

288

135

31

Don Mattingly

1B

249.85

22.07

223

263

214

236

213

32

George Sisler

1B

292

20.99

135

351

215

281

170

33

Dolph Camilli

1B

224

22.85

303

216

232

222

265

34

Mark Grace

1B

270.75

21.02

175

345

233

293

199

35

John Olerud

1B

229.9

22.19

282

256

245

244

254

36

Gil Hodges

1B

262.73

21.03

199

343

248

299

216

37

Jake Beckley

1B

318

19.64

94

462

256

367

163

38

Bob Watson

1B

224.2

21.97

301

275

264

265

282

39

Ron Fairly

1B

256.65

20.66

210

375

270

331

231

40

Harry Davis

1B

238

20.9

253

354

284

322

262

41

Mickey Vernon

1B

296

19.5

131

476

285

385

198

42

Jim Thome

1B

182.4

24.35

471

137

286

203

388

43

Joe Adcock

1B

233.04

20.94

266

353

291

328

274

44

Jim Bottomley

1B

258

20.01

206

429

300

372

243

45

Jason Giambi

1B

158.65

26.5

590

64

313

168

456

46

Wally Joyner

1B

240.35

20.2

247

414

317

370

275

47

Jake Daubert

1B

263

19.5

198

477

324

417

248

48

Hal Trosky

1B

195

21.99

404

273

326

296

368

49

Joe Judge

1B

270

19.08

176

504

328

430

240

50

Kent Hrbek

1B

218.5

20.88

325

358

329

349

326

51

Roy Sievers

1B

228.1

20.37

289

396

331

366

309

52

Hal Chase

1B

280

18.85

159

528

333

442

232

53

Steve Garvey

1B

265.05

19.1

190

500

334

431

247

54

Phil Cavarretta

1B

237

19.94

256

436

336

388

290

55

Frank McCormick

1B

202

21.09

376

336

344

343

358

56

Rudy York

1B

214

20.64

341

378

347

365

338

57

Dave Orr

1B

145

27.55

685

50

362

192

538

58

Cecil Cooper

1B

228.95

19.67

286

460

371

427

321

59

Mike Hargrove

1B

201.4

20.53

381

385

378

382

376

60

Bill White

1B

202.36

20.27

375

408

387

402

378

61

Henry Larkin

1B

177

21.63

492

298

393

345

434

62

Fred Tenney

1B

249

18.32

225

573

397

495

303

63

Elbie Fletcher

1B

185

20.58

456

384

416

407

429

64

Pete Runnels

1B

213.68

19.1

344

501

421

470

379

65

Andres Galarraga

1B

225.15

18.55

298

551

426

499

354

66

Mo Vaughn

1B

175.75

20.83

503

362

436

398

472

67

John Mayberry

1B

189.05

20

433

434

438

439

424

68

Don Mincher

1B

153.9

22.22

618

255

441

341

539

69

Joe Kuhel

1B

243

17.31

238

646

447

556

329

70

Norm Siebern

1B

166.34

21.04

551

342

452

393

515

71

Ferris Fain

1B

161

21.27

575

322

454

383

525

72

Ripper Collins

1B

147

22.65

673

226

456

334

585

73

Fred Merkle

1B

191

19.26

422

489

466

478

430

74

Earl Torgeson

1B

184

19.75

463

455

471

464

460

75

George Kelly

1B

193

19.05

414

508

473

494

427

76

Dan McGann

1B

183

19.61

468

466

476

472

471

77

John Kruk

1B

148.2

21.96

662

277

478

373

590

78

Bill Skowron

1B

179.26

19.61

483

467

483

477

487

79

Stuffy McInnis

1B

227

17.06

295

660

488

591

384

80

Lee May

1B

213.75

17.74

343

614

491

559

410

81

George Burns-1b

1B

200

17.92

385

601

511

560

432

82

Lu Blue

1B

198

17.8

393

608

519

572

440

83

Chris Chambliss

1B

209.95

17.24

354

651

521

599

419

84

George Scott

1B

205.2

16.93

368

672

539

620

436

85

Wally Pipp

1B

203

16.82

374

678

545

625

444

86

Fred Luderus

1B

160

19.19

583

494

565

531

584

87

Ted Kluszewski

1B

178.6

17.93

487

599

571

593

527

88

John Reilly

1B

151

19.83

643

446

573

507

624

89

Gus Suhr

1B

170

18.39

531

569

581

579

557

90

Dan Driessen

1B

170.05

18.28

526

577

584

586

553

91

Bill Buckner

1B

214.7

14.6

338

791

602

700

446

92

Alvin Davis

1B

145.35

19.79

683

450

604

525

659

93

Jason Thompson

1B

156.75

18.8

604

533

606

568

615

94

Jack Doyle

1B

176

17.36

497

642

607

626

550

95

Wes Parker

1B

140.6

19.84

718

445

617

530

683

96

Tino Martinez

1B

159.6

18.04

587

590

627

615

617

97

Charlie Grimm

1B

198

14.67

392

789

630

713

504

98

George McQuinn

1B

173

16.99

517

668

633

655

572

99

John Morrill

1B

151

18.55

642

552

639

597

655

100

Tommy Tucker

1B

176

15.69

498

736

657

699

578

101

Doc Hoblitzell

1B

149

17.98

653

594

662

627

671

102

Deron Johnson

1B

162.45

16.74

566

685

664

677

627

103

Cecil Fielder

1B

152

17.46

628

631

667

656

667

104

Gregg Jefferies

1B

153.9

17.29

619

649

674

662

664

105

Bruce Bochte

1B

151.05

17.19

636

655

680

673

672

106

Eric Karros

1B

149.15

16.81

648

681

693

696

686

107

Dots Miller

1B

155

15.51

610

745

709

728

675

108

Whitey Lockman

1B

156

15.34

607

755

711

736

676

109

Vic Power

1B

149.92

15.24

647

760

725

746

700

110

Donn Clendenon

1B

129.2

17.24

779

652

734

705

761

111

Joe Pepitone

1B

132.05

16.45

766

697

746

732

763

112

Earl Sheely

1B

129

15.88

782

725

763

750

775

113

Pete O'Brien

1B

133.95

14.81

759

776

778

778

771

114

David Segui

1B

116.85

15.86

818

726

783

755

800

115

Willie Montanez

1B

133.95

14.26

760

803

790

798

777

116

Ed Kranepool

1B

125.4

14.26

791

804

805

805

799

117

Kitty Bransfield

1B

120

14.44

813

797

812

806

814

118

Charles Comiskey

1B

125

13.41

793

828

817

825

806

119

Jim Spencer

1B

114

14.38

828

800

820

815

824

120

Candy LaChance

1B

111

13.58

834

821

833

830

835

121

Patsy Tebeau

1B

105

13.55

848

823

840

835

844

122

George Stovall

1B

111

12.9

835

838

841

842

837

1

Rogers Hornsby

2B

502

34.33

14

7

8

9

11

2

Eddie Collins

2B

574

30.9

8

15

10

11

9

3

Nap Lajoie

2B

496

30.73

17

17

15

13

15

4

Joe Morgan

2B

486.4

29.29

19

28

17

18

16

5

Craig Biggio

2B

324.9

25.72

86

84

57

64

66

6

Bobby Grich

2B

312.55

25.94

102

78

61

63

76

7

Charlie Gehringer

2B

383

24.24

41

142

65

92

49

8

Roberto Alomar

2B

327.75

24.96

83

106

67

72

68

9

Ryne Sandberg

2B

328.7

24.16

80

147

83

105

78

10

Frankie Frisch

2B

366

23.48

49

184

87

120

62

11

Larry Doyle

2B

289

25.37

143

93

88

80

102

12

Jackie Robinson

2B

257

28.7

209

39

91

58

143

13

Lou Whitaker

2B

333.45

22.82

74

217

113

155

90

14

Johnny Evers

2B

268

24.09

179

151

129

131

152

15

Billy Herman

2B

298

22.35

127

246

156

199

132

16

Bobby Doerr

2B

281

22.68

155

225

160

190

153

17

Hardy Richardson

2B

230

24.72

280

117

167

130

220

18

Joe Gordon

2B

242

23.99

243

156

170

151

201

19

Willie Randolph

2B

296.4

21.37

130

314

192

251

155

20

Bid McPhee

2B

305

20.99

111

350

200

275

151

21

Tony Lazzeri

2B

252

22.36

218

244

201

221

204

22

Cupid Childs

2B

238

22.81

252

218

207

210

224

23

Danny Murphy

2B

215

23.33

335

194

240

212

286

24

Dick McAuliffe

2B

228.95

21.81

287

288

263

271

273

25

Buddy Myer

2B

258

20.42

205

393

277

342

234

26

Gil McDougald

2B

194

23.3

409

197

282

233

347

27

Davey Lopes

2B

228

21.19

290

329

290

309

287

28

Del Pratt

2B

242

20.61

242

380

292

339

258

29

Miller Huggins

2B

222

21.16

309

331

304

315

308

30

Eddie Stanky

2B

191

22.77

421

221

305

257

367

31

Jimmy Williams

2B

207

21.95

363

279

306

286

331

32

Tom Daly

2B

215

21.48

337

307

308

303

319

33

Nellie Fox

2B

298.34

18.91

126

523

311

432

207

34

Jeff Kent

2B

187.15

23

444

211

314

253

383

35

Fred Dunlap

2B

165

25.08

560

101

316

197

438

36

Chuck Knoblauch

2B

217.55

21.03

329

344

323

336

325

37

Lonny Frey

2B

208

21.05

359

341

339

340

344

38

Jim Gilliam

2B

243.43

19.24

237

491

358

434

289

39

George Grantham

2B

193

21.21

413

328

368

348

392

40

Red Schoendienst

2B

261.77

18.41

201

568

380

483

280

41

Bill Doran

2B

183.35

21.12

466

335

399

363

423

42

Bobby Avila

2B

175

21.22

505

326

412

368

459

43

Max Bishop

2B

184

20.64

465

379

420

404

435

44

Claude Ritchey

2B

205

19.48

370

480

427

457

396

45

Tony Cuccinello

2B

203

19.13

373

499

439

474

403

46

Ron Hunt

2B

181.45

20.1

476

423

458

445

463

47

Edgardo Alfonzo

2B

136.8

24.01

746

155

460

295

630

48

Fred Pfeffer

2B

202

18.38

377

570

482

534

416

49

Davey Johnson

2B

162.45

20.28

565

407

505

452

536

50

Bill Mazeroski

2B

212.2

16.94

348

671

524

616

420

51

Phil Garner

2B

185.25

18.42

454

567

526

550

494

52

Marty McManus

2B

202

17.31

379

647

530

601

439

53

Jim Delahanty

2B

149

20.6

654

382

533

455

613

54

Delino DeShields

2B

173.85

18.31

514

575

574

580

541

55

Frank White

2B

200.45

16.15

384

708

577

652

467

56

Steve Sax

2B

188.1

16.81

438

680

593

646

514

57

Tom Herr

2B

161.5

18.03

570

592

616

610

600

58

Robby Thompson

2B

147.25

19.19

670

495

620

551

663

59

Bobby Lowe

2B

188

15.72

439

733

622

686

526

60

Tony Taylor

2B

190.29

15.09

426

764

637

701

524

61

Billy Goodman

2B

169.69

17.09

535

659

640

654

592

62

Juan Samuel

2B

167.2

17.11

548

658

647

657

601

63

Terry Turner

2B

171

16.65

524

692

651

671

593

64

Dave Cash

2B

156.75

17.65

603

621

654

640

637

65

Johnny Temple

2B

155.96

16.86

608

676

677

685

661

66

Johnny Ray

2B

145.35

17.53

684

629

691

663

696

67

Jerry Priddy

2B

145

17.31

686

648

697

682

702

68

Jorge Orta

2B

152

16.05

631

710

699

714

684

69

Carlos Baerga

2B

139.65

17.65

722

623

702

670

717

70

Jim Gantner

2B

154.85

15.57

614

741

708

725

679

71

Bret Boone

2B

132.05

17.89

765

602

712

664

734

72

Glenn Hubbard

2B

133

17.71

763

619

719

676

739

73

Felix Millan

2B

144.4

15.57

690

742

736

743

721

74

Jody Reed

2B

129.2

16.79

780

682

744

723

768

75

Sparky Adams

2B

144

15.11

699

763

745

754

727

76

Don Blasingame

2B

136.89

15.28

744

759

760

763

762

77

Bucky Harris

2B

133

15.51

762

746

764

757

770

78

George Cutshaw

2B

140

14.6

719

792

767

781

748

79

Hughie Critz

2B

141

14.24

713

805

768

792

746

80

Frank Bolling

2B

137.67

14.76

739

783

770

779

764

81

Lou Bierbauer

2B

137

14.73

743

785

775

783

767

82

Manny Trillo

2B

138.7

14.39

729

799

776

791

759

83

Horace Clarke

2B

120.65

15.7

809

735

784

761

794

84

Cass Michaels

2B

121

15.62

807

739

785

765

793

85

Jerry Lumpe

2B

123.22

15.13

803

762

792

780

796

86

Cookie Rojas

2B

136.8

13.58

745

820

793

807

772

87

Ted Sizemore

2B

123.5

14.92

802

771

794

789

798

88

Eric Young

2B

124.45

14.81

796

778

795

793

795

89

Julian Javier

2B

129.31

14.16

777

808

801

804

787

90

Otto Knabe

2B

120

14.8

814

779

802

796

810

91

Mark McLemore

2B

128.25

14.14

783

810

803

811

792

92

Mickey Morandini

2B

113.05

15.02

830

767

806

794

820

93

Harold Reynolds

2B

116.85

14.77

819

782

807

797

815

94

Tito Fuentes

2B

125.4

14.08

792

811

808

814

801

95

Glenn Beckert

2B

118.75

14.54

815

794

811

803

816

96

Bill Hallman

2B

129

12.63

781

845

819

834

802

97

Hobe Ferris

2B

113

14.35

832

801

822

817

830

98

Bobby Richardson

2B

116.36

13.45

822

827

831

831

827

99

Tommy Helms

2B

108.3

13.85

842

815

834

828

836

100

Joe Quinn

2B

120

10.58

812

857

839

852

828

101

Derrel Thomas

2B

103.55

13.41

849

829

843

836

849

102

Frankie Gustine

2B

102

13.12

852

834

850

843

851

103

Cub Stricker

2B

102

13

851

837

851

846

852

104

Sandy Alomar Sr.

2B

98.8

13.06

855

835

853

844

854

105

Bill Wambsganss

2B

106

11.26

845

854

854

854

850

106

Ski Melillo

2B

88

10.3

857

859

858

859

858

107

Pete Suder

2B

83

9.83

859

860

860

860

859

1

Mike Schmidt

3B

443.65

30.08

22

22

16

17

18

2

Eddie Mathews

3B

441.94

28.87

23

34

21

20

20

3

Home Run Baker

3B

301

29.29

119

29

51

35

77

4

George Brett

3B

410.4

24.08

29

152

64

95

42

5

Wade Boggs

3B

374.3

23.77

47

164

77

112

58

6

Stan Hack

3B

316

24.07

97

153

92

116

93

7

Heine Groh

3B

272

25.05

172

103

108

94

129

8

Jimmy Collins

3B

274

23.8

168

162

130

135

144

9

Darrell Evans

3B

344.85

21.91

66

280

141

209

99

10

Ron Santo

3B

307.8

22.34

109

247

146

195

114

11

Bob Elliott

3B

287

22.71

144

223

153

185

139

12

John McGraw

3B

207

27.16

364

56

178

111

271

13

Sal Bando

3B

268.85

22.13

178

260

185

224

178

14

Ken Boyer

3B

272.4

21.87

171

284

196

239

181

15

Ron Cey

3B

266

21.74

188

291

211

246

195

16

Pie Traynor

3B

274

21.41

169

310

212

261

185

17

Heinie Zimmerman

3B

214

24.16

339

148

216

170

278

18

Toby Harrah

3B

272.65

21.22

170

324

218

269

192

19

Larry Gardner

3B

258

21.77

208

289

220

252

210

20

Al Rosen

3B

185

27.41

455

53

226

124

342

21

Graig Nettles

3B

304.95

20.34

114

400

228

320

162

22

Art Devlin

3B

198

24.48

391

131

236

172

313

23

Brooks Robinson

3B

340.74

19.58

68

469

243

364

147

24

Ken Caminiti

3B

229.9

22.01

283

269

252

258

263

25

Denny Lyons

3B

190

24.52

429

129

257

187

341

26

Larry Parrish

3B

235.6

21.57

260

300

258

274

252

27

Bobby Bonilla

3B

253.65

20.96

216

352

260

306

230

28

Chipper Jones

3B

176.7

25.38

496

92

271

165

395

29

Robin Ventura

3B

224.2

21.6

302

299

279

285

294

30

Bill Madlock

3B

229.9

21.27

281

321

280

301

277

31

Billy Nash

3B

222

21.4

308

311

289

300

300

32

Buddy Bell

3B

285.95

19.49

149

478

295

394

211

33

Matt Williams

3B

220.4

20.88

314

357

322

344

312

34

Carney Lansford

3B

231.8

20

273

433

340

391

305

35

Eddie Yost

3B

267

18.86

183

527

342

447

249

36

Lave Cross

3B

278

18.53

164

554

346

462

241

37

Deacon White

3B

190

21.72

428

292

350

317

394

38

Bill Joyce

3B

157

24.49

596

130

355

231

489

39

Howard Johnson

3B

184.3

22

461

271

361

307

411

40

Harlond Clift

3B

216

20.3

333

405

365

384

339

41

George Kell

3B

229

19.71

284

458

370

424

316

42

Richie Hebner

3B

208.05

20.23

357

409

379

395

365

43

Willie Kamm

3B

243

18.78

239

536

382

469

306

44

Harry Steinfeldt

3B

208

20.14

358

420

383

414

370

45

Ken Keltner

3B

199

20.43

387

392

385

387

389

46

Red Smith

3B

161

23.1

578

206

388

283

498

47

Ned Williamson

3B

173

22.06

518

267

389

325

453

48

Freddy Lindstrom

3B

193

20.49

412

386

396

390

406

49

Ezra Sutton

3B

158

22.99

591

212

402

298

510

50

Doug DeCinces

3B

194.75

20.33

406

402

404

412

405

51

Arlie Latham

3B

221

19.06

312

507

410

466

352

52

Tim Wallach

3B

235.6

18.04

261

589

429

521

332

53

Bill Bradley

3B

181.45

20.48

475

388

435

419

450

54

Jimmy Dykes

3B

245

17

232

666

455

576

330

55

Jim Ray Hart

3B

140.6

22.64

714

227

479

347

621

56

Buddy Lewis

3B

179

19.54

484

473

490

482

492

57

Gary Gaetti

3B

236.55

16.44

258

699

492

613

363

58

Ray Boone

3B

166

20.31

556

403

495

449

531

59

Ken McMullen

3B

166.25

19.79

552

448

517

480

537

60

Puddin' Head Jones

3B

189

18.24

437

579

523

554

478

61

Don Money

3B

187.15

18.24

442

580

527

558

484

62

Travis Fryman

3B

182.4

18.36

473

572

542

562

513

63

Red Rolfe

3B

162

19.42

569

486

547

519

564

64

Todd Zeile

3B

189.05

17.59

435

626

550

600

495

65

George Pinckney

3B

157

19.61

598

468

555

513

589

66

Milt Stock

3B

188

17.53

440

628

557

603

500

67

Terry Pendleton

3B

191.9

17.14

419

656

564

621

486

68

Hans Lobert

3B

157

19.46

599

482

566

528

596

69

Mike Higgins

3B

195

16.73

405

686

576

639

482

70

Buck Herzog

3B

171

18.32

522

574

579

582

551

71

Kevin Seitzer

3B

165.3

18.6

558

549

586

569

573

72

Tom Burns

3B

154

19.2

617

493

588

537

614

73

Bob Bailey

3B

179.55

17.39

482

639

596

622

533

74

Eddie Foster

3B

171

17.54

523

627

610

623

567

75

Doug Rader

3B

157.7

18.44

593

566

614

594

616

76

Bill Werber

3B

162

17.96

568

596

619

614

599

77

Jimmy Johnston

3B

157

18.08

600

587

635

617

628

78

Ossie Bluege

3B

183

15.91

470

721

638

684

548

79

Billy Shindle

3B

167

17.06

550

662

649

660

607

80

Dave Magadan

3B

139.65

19.19

723

496

652

571

693

81

Wid Conroy

3B

153

17.73

624

617

658

644

658

82

Clete Boyer

3B

152.98

16.29

625

702

692

703

677

83

Jerry Denny

3B

140

17.65

720

622

700

669

716

84

Pinky Whitney

3B

149

15.28

658

758

727

747

708

85

Bobby Byrne

3B

137

16.16

740

707

738

733

743

86

Ken Oberkfell

3B

133.95

16.53

758

695

742

727

754

87

Jimmy Austin

3B

143

14.71

703

786

757

772

733

88

Frank Malzone

3B

132.2

14.91

764

773

779

776

774

89

Dean Palmer

3B

122.55

15.47

804

747

788

768

791

90

Brook Jacoby

3B

114

15.47

827

748

796

774

812

91

Ray Knight

3B

116.85

15.06

820

765

800

790

811

92

Enos Cabell

3B

122.55

13.26

805

830

824

829

818

93

Joe Dugan

3B

116

12.79

823

842

835

841

834

94

Aurelio Rodriguez

3B

117.8

11.35

816

853

838

849

831

95

Charlie Hayes

3B

110.2

13.04

838

836

842

839

839

96

Ken Reitz

3B

79.8

10.72

861

856

859

858

860

1

Yogi Berra

C

373.04

29.06

48

31

24

24

27

2

Gabby Hartnett

C

325

28.86

85

35

38

31

53

3

Johnny Bench

C

338.2

26.61

71

60

43

45

50

4

Bill Dickey

C

314

28.82

99

36

45

36

63

5

Mickey Cochrane

C

275

28.71

167

38

70

48

109

6

Carlton Fisk

C

349.6

24.2

64

144

74

100

64

7

Gary Carter

C

320.15

24.21

93

143

89

106

88

8

Mike Piazza

C

242.25

31.82

241

13

96

47

161

9

Buck Ewing

C

241

27.06

245

58

119

79

177

10

Bill Freehan

C

253.65

25.08

215

100

122

103

164

11

Roger Bresnahan

C

231

27.86

277

45

124

77

200

12

Joe Torre

C

300.04

23.19

123

202

126

157

112

13

Wally Schang

C

245

24.72

235

116

145

118

188

14

Gene Tenace

C

219.45

27.09

321

57

158

98

237

15

Roy Campanella

C

207

27.85

365

46

175

102

268

16

Ted Simmons

C

299.25

21.08

124

338

202

268

156

17

Ivan Rodriguez

C

195.7

23.74

402

167

261

207

333

18

Ernie Lombardi

C

217

22.15

331

259

275

262

304

19

Tom Haller

C

170.19

25.67

525

85

287

166

414

20

Elston Howard

C

197.58

22.51

395

233

296

260

343

21

Thurman Munson

C

195.7

22.61

403

229

298

259

350

22

Darrell Porter

C

210.9

21.9

351

282

299

284

327

23

Tim McCarver

C

193.8

21.3

410

317

356

337

386

24

Charlie Bennett

C

157

23.6

597

175

381

264

505

25

Walker Cooper

C

173

22.08

519

262

386

318

451

26

Smoky Burgess

C

169.45

22.23

537

253

392

313

469

27

Darren Daulton

C

151.05

23.76

637

165

401

267

532

28

John Roseboro

C

174.1

21.22

510

327

414

371

466

29

Bob O'Farrell

C

161

22

572

272

419

346

512

30

Del Crandall

C

177.08

20.78

491

367

431

399

458

31

Ray Schalk

C

191

19.91

423

439

434

441

418

32

Mickey Tettleton

C

174.8

20.75

507

368

444

411

477

33

Mike Scioscia

C

159.6

21.53

586

303

449

374

528

34

Rick Ferrell

C

206

18.88

366

526

451

496

407

35

Johnny Kling

C

155

21.66

612

295

463

376

547

36

Ed Bailey

C

142.93

22.33

704

250

486

360

619

37

Jim Sundberg

C

190

18.79

430

535

502

527

454

38

Earl Battey

C

136.53

22.42

748

239

512

362

657

39

Duke Farrell

C

183

18.93

469

520

514

522

493

40

Deacon McGuire

C

190

17.75

427

613

538

588

479

41

Spud Davis

C

149

20.49

661

387

543

461

622

42

Sherm Lollar

C

175.97

18.45

499

564

553

563

529

43

Bob Boone

C

199.5

16.7

386

687

561

633

462

44

Terry Steinbach

C

164.35

19.01

563

512

563

538

568

45

Chief Zimmer

C

153

19.52

621

475

578

529

612

46

Jack Clements

C

146

20.1

680

424

585

500

646

47

Muddy Ruel

C

156

19.1

606

502

587

541

609

48

Andy Seminick

C

142

20.13

707

421

601

505

669

49

Rick Dempsey

C

150.1

18.94

645

518

618

567

643

50

Manny Sanguillen

C

149.15

18.91

651

525

626

574

654

51

Al Lopez

C

173

16.97

516

670

634

658

569

52

Johnny Edwards

C

149

18.81

656

532

636

584

660

53

Steve O'Neill

C

152

17.71

632

618

663

648

666

54

Tony Pena

C

166.25

16.03

554

713

672

697

625

55

Mike Stanley

C

137.75

18.83

737

531

673

607

710

56

Terry Kennedy

C

142.5

17.93

706

600

686

651

705

57

Benito Santiago

C

151.05

16.22

635

705

698

710

685

58

Gus Mancuso

C

135

17.41

751

637

721

691

732

59

Butch Wynegar

C

129.2

17.39

778

640

730

698

755

60

Jim Hegan

C

137

16.69

742

689

735

721

740

61

Frankie Hayes

C

130

16.45

775

698

750

735

769

62

Doggie Miller

C

135

15.37

750

753

759

759

765

63

Lance Parrish

C

147.25

12.88

669

839

765

801

725

64

Rollie Hemsley

C

130

15.29

776

757

777

769

781

65

Jimmie Wilson

C

124

15.3

799

756

789

773

790

66

Luke Sewell

C

128

13.73

786

817

809

818

797

67

Jack O'Connor

C

124

13.89

798

814

813

819

807

68

Wilbert Robinson

C

116

13.84

824

816

828

824

825

1

Paul Molitor

DH

393.3

22.06

36

266

118

191

75

2

Edgar Martinez

DH

250.8

24.05

221

154

157

142

184

3

Brian Downing

DH

283.1

20.74

152

369

234

304

190

4

Harold Baines

DH

291.65

17.94

137

598

363

492

235

5

Don Baylor

DH

248.9

18.06

227

588

407

511

310

6

Hal McRae

DH

218.5

18.5

324

556

446

512

377

7

Andre Thornton

DH

176.7

19.15

495

498

515

510

509

1

Babe Ruth

OF